Open 571- Pick Your Poison Game over

[reinoe]

Your reasoning is awful. You're saying she'll be conftown or confscum tomorrow. Ten seconds using your brain you should be able to come up with at least one scenario where that would not be the case.

[reinoe]

I've highlighted some good posts so that the shit town players can know what some good posts look like. If you want to know what some shit posts look like just look through Fluminator's, Aphix's, and doublade/caledfwitch's entire post histories. They're ISO's are full of shit posts.

[notscience]

Day End

reinoe was lynched. He was a

Vanilla Townie.

Pretty Picture

You still don't get any.

4.01

With

7

alive, it takes

4

to lynch.

[/b]

Fluminator(1)

- Krystal Bald

reinoe(4)

- Alchemist21, aphix, Doublade, reinoe

Not Voting:

Fluminator

Deadline

Night deadline is October 21st at 6:30 PM EST. This is in (expired on 2014-10-21 17:30:00)

Boring Mod notes

IM BACK BABY

Also, caledfwitch is replacing Doublade effective now

[notscience]

Day 5 Opening

aphix was killed last night!

He was a

Vanilla Townie.[/align]

Pretty Picture

You still don't get any.

5.00

With

5

alive, it takes

3

to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline

Deadline is November 4th at 7 PM EST. This is in (expired on 2014-11-04 19:00:00)

Boring Mod notes

IM BACK BABY

[Alchemist21]

lol @ 75 alive.

Flum, what are your current thoughts on the game?

[Fluminator]

Well, I wrote an out of game message for Reino. I hope he reads it.
Message to Reino:

Spoiler:

First: There are two main parts to mafia if you are town. One is finding scum, and the other one is convincing the rest of town to vote for your scum reads. You may be fantastic at catching maf (Although it seems you make just as many mistakes as the rest of us.), but it is meaningless if you can't get them lynched. Your method in trying to convince town was not convincing at all and very polarizing. You can blame us all you want for not seeing it your way, but in the end you are just as much to blame. You didn't do a good job convincing us. If you read this far, I respectfully advise you to work on your politics in getting your reads lynched.

Second: At the top of my head, Majiffy, me, Aphix, Kurigan, Doublade, Alchemist, Gaiden all wanted you lynched. That is at least 7 people wanting you lynched. 5 to 6 townies. (Krystal didn't want you lynched but I can tell she isn't impressed with you.) When this many people are against you, you can't blame it on all of us being “idiots.” There is much more likely a problem with the game-play of the 1 player (you), and not the 8.

Third: Your self hammer basically screwed town over. I'm not sure if you intended for it to be that way in your emotional state, but it did. That is playing against your win condition. I am considering reporting you to the listmods, but I don't really want to.
What you should have done at L-1 was wait to see if either Gaiden or I would lynch you. We have both expressed desire to lynch you and it would have given us much information if neither of us hammered you. (I wasn't planning to, and if Gaiden didn't we could have had him as a strong town read). Now that you self hammered, you deprived us of the necessary information to have a very reasonable shot at this.

I hope you read this and consider what I say.

All I have to say is I won't selfhammer as town. Here's to no one playing with you ever again.

To Alchemist: I have a strong scum read on someone after skimming through the night. I don't want to say who it is yet, because I want to watch how he/she interacts with the other players. Both my gut and mind agree so I am reasonably confident.
The last night kill also makes me more confident I'm on the right track.

[Fluminator]

Heppy Birthday btw.
And what do you mean by 75 alive?

[Alchemist21]

Heppy Birthday btw.
And what do you mean by 75 alive?

Thanks. Happy belated birthday to you as well.

Also notty had the night scene saying "with 75 alive it takes 3 to lynch". Lol

[caledfwitch]

i think aphix was a safe kill
thoughts

[Fluminator]

Well, what do you mean by safe kill?

[caledfwitch]

his biggest recent scumreads were on dead people
didnt have much presence throughout the game



thus
safe kill

[Alchemist21]

If the scum team wanted to kill for those reasons, I think they would have killed you or Gaiden. Unless the two of you are actually the scum.

[SXTLHGaiden]

You're logic is faulty.
Scum would keep me around for obvious reasons.
i'm not seeing the whole "safe kill" thing.

[SXTLHGaiden]

Your**
i shouldn't type in the mornings.

[Alchemist21]

Gaiden, do you still think Flum is scum, and if so then why?

[Fluminator]

his biggest recent scumreads were on dead people
didnt have much presence throughout the game



thus
safe kill

I don't think that is quite true, and if it was it wouldn't be a reason for them to kill him.
He has had a presence in game. I would say more than you and Gaiden. And his main scum read may be dead but he implied who he thought was scum if Reino was innocent.
What do you think Krystal? You haven't posted yet today.

[Nikanor]

Both heads are LA until either tonight or tomorrow. Posting from my phone atm.
The fact that aphix was killed when my two suspects yesterday were aphix and caled makes me think that caled might be town being set up for the mislynch today. I still haven't read the day 2 stuff I wanted to read because I was pretty sure we were toast last night, but I want to read through it when I get off VLA.

[Fluminator]

Why did you think you would be killed last night Krystal?
I predicted either Alchemist or Aphix would get killed. Reason being they would be the two least likely to get lynched. Although I thought it more likely Alchemist would get killed.
Hey Alchemist, would you have done anything differently this game had you been scum? (Assuming your town.)

I think me, Krystal, and Alchemist would all appreciate if Doublade and Gaiden gave us who they thought were scum and reasons. (More ideally a reads list) I have had a hard time getting a read on them due to lack of posting. This definitely can't wait any longer.

[SXTLHGaiden]

why would you think alchemist would be killed?

[Fluminator]

Reason being they would be the two least likely to get lynched.

I thought Aphix had more suspicion around him than Alchemist though. Makes me think there was also another reason Aphix was killed. A reason I think I have an idea why. But I don't want to give away all my thoughts yet until I see some more from you and Doublade, so it doesn't effect how you guys act.

[Alchemist21]

Why did you think you would be killed last night Krystal?
I predicted either Alchemist or Aphix would get killed. Reason being they would be the two least likely to get lynched. Although I thought it more likely Alchemist would get killed.

Hey Alchemist, would you have done anything differently this game had you been scum?

(Assuming your town.)

I don't really know how to answer that question. It's hard to answer when I've been playing the game with a town mindset, and that single change to the game alone could have drastically changed how the game played out. The only key difference I can think of is that I would have probably tried to draw out a PR claim.

I think me, Krystal, and Alchemist would all appreciate if Doublade and Gaiden gave us who they thought were scum and reasons. (More ideally a reads list) I have had a hard time getting a read on them due to lack of posting. This definitely can't wait any longer.

I support this. So far, looking at their ISO's, all I really saw from Doublade/Cal was the desire to lynch midget and Reinoe. (Did the other head ever post at all or has it been just Caledfwitch?). Gaiden's looks fishier. There are Matsumi interactions that don't look as null now as they did at first. I think I also see what looks like it could be a breadcrumb for a future jailkeeper fakeclaim.

Gaiden, you still haven't answered my question about Flum.

[caledfwitch]

at first it was just marquis and then he got sick so i took the wheel
(im a shitty hydra partner but here i am trying to make up for it i guess)

[Fluminator]

Nah, you'll do fine. Just give us a reads list or something to work with.

[caledfwitch]

is tomorrow ok?? im tired rn ;n;

[notscience]

Pretty Picture

You still don't get any.

5.01

With

5

alive, it takes

3

to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline

Deadline is November 4th at 7 PM EST. This is in (expired on 2014-11-04 19:00:00)

Boring Mod notes

Broken Deadline fixed