InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[BBmolla]

obligatory

[Kagami]

VOTE: Duck

[Majiffy]

And then he waddled away! Waddle waddle waddle.

[Kagami]

So I'm beginning to rethink my position here.

I was originally scumreading the duck on the basis of his obviously inconsistent stance with regard to his preference for grapes and lemonade, but on second thought it's not clear to me what the scum motivation is there. This might actually represent an organic town thought process. While he's tunneling grapes for 4 days, it's not completely crazy that he would realize that lemonade is the superior commodity.

In contrast, I'm really doubt the lemonade vendor's claim. I find it very unlikely that a real lemonade vendor would profess to sell "ICE FRESH" lemonade, which makes absolutely no sense. I also feel like his blatant AtE is forced. Rather than attempt to lynch the duck as he originally claims to want to do, he bends over backward to appease the duck. The switch from attacking the duck to suddenly trying to buddy him feels extremely ingenuous.

[Kagami]

I'll also add that no one actually received lemonade, so the claim is completely unsubstantiated.

[ActionDan]

The duck is a troll.

[Egg]

So....

Flip?

[Majiffy]

The duck is a troll.

And he gets so much better in the later duck sequels too

[Cephrir]

ProHawk was

Tsubaki, Town Human Jewel Thief

.

[Cephrir]

P.s. phone modding: not even once.

[Egg]

Wtf

[ActionDan]

I'm not even surprised.

[Kagami]

Why did he have only one shard? o.o

[ActionDan]

I think the best course of action is to panic.

Then to lynch Bbmolla because this game makes no sense.

[Egg]

So if we trust that BBMolla is SK
And we trust that Kagami is town for being killed by scum
And we trust that Y+B is town because BBMolla fucks himself if he lies about that as SK
And we trust that I'm town for catching Aronis
And we trust that there are three scum left

The team must be Actiondan/majiffy/notscience

Kagami and Y+B, I want your thoughts. If you agree on the above, we should vote as a block on any one of those three players. The reason I won't lynch BBMolla is because if he flips SK, we lose even if scum's kill is unsuccessful barring two scum left.

[Kagami]

VOTE: Majiffy

They had more than enough time to quickhammer.

BB is SK beyond any reasonable doubt.

[ActionDan]

I don't think he ever claimed to get more than the one from NS.

As you said, it's possible something else took oversoul's shard before he was lynched. there's a one-night window.

pedit:

Well guess what. I'm not scum! surprise! I think a 2/3 puppet scum is weird and be inclined to think it's all or nothing.

[ActionDan]

VOTE: Majiffy

They had more than enough time to quickhammer.

BB is SK beyond any reasonable doubt.

technically they might fear bbm poisoning one of them (if we're going with 3 scum)

[ActionDan]

about kagami being killed by scum. we're still assuming that was a scum strong-man shot in a game with no doctor?

[Kagami]

They still would win as soon as the lynch occurs with any reasonable win condition.

[Kagami]

BB appears to have blocked the last two scum kills, you're really trying to pretend that they have no use for a strongman?

[ActionDan]

And we trust that there are three scum left

I don't trust this.

few things in this setup that make no sense atm to me.
7 scum with an apparent strongman shot vs 1 SK where town has poisonproof + town doctor (I don't care if you don't believe me, I am)

Conclusion: I don't think there's that many scum anymore.
Another random thought: I bet Naraku can self-revive from getting lynched.
Other Other thought: I think everyone is town atm besides Molla and Maybe he has a partner

^ Why I want to lynch Molla.

People thought it had to be Beast. It wasn't. People thought it had to be Prohawk. It wasn't.

I'm sticking to egg being a town tracker when a mafia ninja has flipped and naraku not being able to be tracked to kills.
I'm sticking to kagami not being mafia scum with the kill on mhork that same night, poison be damned.
I'm sticking to Y++B not being mafia scum.

I'm sticking to it being fucked up if NS + majiffy are both mafiascum, or even if one is.

I also think it's fucked up that BBm revived Kagami but I think that might be a compulsive thing.

I also think that Bbm isn't particularly forthcoming when 3 mafia would be a huge threat to him.

I also think that it's possible that having only one death a night for the last 2 nights just might be because mafia don't exist anymore.

So this is my position. I'm not changing it to make sense of something seriously fucked up anymore.

[ActionDan]

VOTE: Bbmolla


I invite Mafia to quickhammer this btw. if you dare.

I feel like cindy at the end of the 2nd scary movie.

[ActionDan]

BB appears to have blocked the last two scum kills, you're really trying to pretend that they have no use for a strongman?

If you are referencing commutes, I'd say that in general commutes supersede strongman shots, since strongman shots break protects most times, like jailkeeps and docs and BPs (and sometimes roleblocks). but commutes, hides, and w/e is like that is different.

+ strongman does so so little against your protection in particular when Bbm can revive you (and probably compulsively)

[Kagami]

I don't buy that ceph made a 28 player game and put in the band of seven without there being all seven of them. One of them being town seemed possible as a flavor miller, but I don't think they're missing.

I also really doubt mhork would have claimed to be "the town-aligned Bo7" while the possibility that an actually-town-aligned Bo7er might CC him. I'd have to review the timing of that, though. It may have been late enough to be safe.

p-edit: strongman should go through commutes and definitely would go through his multi-day blocks.