My case against TTH, in book form.
I’m guessing what bugs me is that she claimed vengeful. Vengeful is something you should never claim as either town or scum. As FG suggested, as Mafia she could have done a day 2 gambit, claimed cop and done real damage. As town, she should have stayed quiet, waited to Mylo and then nailed the hammerer. Since she did neither of those, we have to assume she didn’t play it optimally, regardless of her alignment. Now, I have 2 reasons I want to lynch her. 1, she is scum. 2, we can win the game if she flips scum.
Evidence for the first point. 1. I still think her earlier post (quoted below so there is no misrepresention) didn’t make sense in the neighbor flow and was probably a scum slip and would make more sense in the scum PT flow. 2. She is a bit of a lurker, hasn’t really put too much out there pushing wise and is sheeping a little. In fact, she’s barely been here day 2. My guess is the scum PT is going to be a great deal of “pls don’t talk anymore” posts to TTH. 3. She was behind that awful vengeful gambit day one to try to get to use her power. Nobody, not anybody, has told me why they thought that was a good idea yet. Vengeful is an anti-town ability and to suggest losing a townie to get scum maybe is just dumb beyond belief. Feels more like scum wanting to seem important than town trying to win.
Now, the associative reads part (all of this assumes she flips scum). 1. We have a hard confirm of Wake as town as the topic of the below reference PT post. We have a soft confirm of the following, (AK, Myself, Massive). If you include broken toaster in the mix, these are all people she was trying to venge. She also voted Boons at one point. So, her flipping scum gives associative town reads to AK/Myself/Wake/Massive/Boons. That should be enough that we can lynch everybody else and still be ahead. I’m assuming there are 2 more scum in this game, of the remaining, I would say, in likelhood from most to least scummiest is Fakegod/Rufflig/Flubber/Titus. She was hard sheeping Fakegod toward the end, especially with the “If you say JA is scum, then I’ll vote”. It’s almost like a new scum player begging for help from an experienced scum buddy.
@Everybody, where am I wrong?
PS @TTH, I volunteer to be vengekilled for putting this forward. If I am indeed wrong, please kill me.
TTH
Post #3 (ISO) » Sat Sep 06, 2014 8:19 pm
I haven't had any games with him, but I've read a couple games with Wake88 and I've seen his posts around the forum (particularly Mafia Discussion). To my understanding, he's a pretty divisive player.
Have you played with Wake88 before and how do you go about tackling a read like that?
