Open 572: Nightless Vengeful Mayhem - Game Over

[Dyslexicon]

Won't have much time just tonight/tomorrow morning anyway though (a bit unpredictable, studies...)

[Phillammon]

I responded to part of that in #659, I'll handle the rest shortly, apologies for missing the other question

[Dyslexicon]

I responded to part of that in #659, I'll handle the rest shortly, apologies for missing the other question

Unless I've misinterpreted (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong), it was prettymuch entirely #560 (and by extension #526)- I've already mentioned that I found Blair's defences more townish than scummish, even with the suspect reasoning in #526. I'm unconvinced that pointing this out is enough to take someone off my hitlist, based on the points I've already made.

I'm a bit confused as to what "it" is refering to here. You point out my 560 and Blair's 526, and you say that you find Blair's defense more townish than scummish. So that is kind of answering why you don't think Blair is scum, although it's not very reasoned, so I'd like you to expand if you can. I don't see you answer any of my other questions here unless I'm missing something obvious?

[Dyslexicon]

But yeah. I'll wait for the response.

[DCLXVI]

Part 2!

Yes, I have read/skimmed/glanced/looked at everything so far. It was underwhelming. But it did provide some clarity.

I've also given up on trying to spell some of your names correctly for the time being, please don't be offended.

More thoughts: (p. 16 up through the present era)

1. I dislike acroyn (however the heck you spell it). I disagree with almost every one his reads which suggests to me at least that he is viewing this game from a very different perspective than I am.

2. Droog is kissing a lot of ass. It's making me uncomfortable (and no, it's not because I'm homophobic (was that too much? Probably, but whatever))

3. I'm strongly disliking acroyn's push on thor on page 18.

4. 465 and 467 by Droog is excellent posting, he just takes apart acroyn's argument.

5. Exactly what I've been noticing as well.

Droog has become my most solid town read, just all-around pushing things in the right direction, trying to curb some of the play that seems actively anti-town.

6. 483 is more very townish posting by droog, calling attention to the fact that everyone has him as a town read doesn't seem as likely to happen from a scum player.

7. This is an interesting point, I'm not sure I agree with it though.

I like Blair less. Especially 526, "Yes, if Dys is lynched and flips scum it would be perfectly reasonable to find my defense of her suspicious - that is a tell I wouldn't argue with. (Hold me to it!)". This does not seem town to me. It sound like you're not at all worried that I will flip scum. Which is curious, cause what she calls a "defense" of me doesn't sound very convincing to me.

Some of my reads... more will come later as there are some things I still want to think about.

Town: Droog, Thor
Scum: acroyn

vote:acryon

[DCLXVI]

Ok guys, you now have no excuses for not posting.

[Thor665]

I don't hate your vote.
I'd rather lynch Blair.

[Dyslexicon]

I don't hate your vote.
I'd rather lynch Phil.

:3

I'll have more to say when my silly research paper is done.

[Thor665]

Of course I have actually already provided info on why Blair is a superior lynch, whereas your case on Phil has been questioned and not defended.

:3

[droog]

I'm waiting on DCLXVI too, right now. I have to concur, that's one helluvan entrance, as they go.

something about tis screams scum to me

i think in my absence from reading im starting to like the idea of town thor and town blair
i think id be okay with philamon. let me read through the thread to confirm my new biases

[droog]

probably acryon too

[droog]

*as a lynch

[Dyslexicon]

Of course I have actually already provided info on why Blair is a superior lynch, whereas your case on Phil has been questioned and not defended.

:3

>:(

I can't tonight. I have a head ache.

But really, I can't understand why you think he's town. Like, at all.
I might even be Acryon > Blair right now.
More on this and exciting stuff soon. I've been thinking about things (I know, Thor, it thrills you, but ceep calm, and you shall maybe get opinions from me :3)

[droog]

ceep

[Dyslexicon]

Yes, droog, yes.

[droog]

is it just me or is the entirety of acryon's 136 really namby pamby
thats a lame insult sooooooo

" I don't like when players seem to be stifling discussion. "
"You have nothing better to say, so you tell someone else the things they are saying are dumb? Not sure I get this. "
"What the heck is this? Why would someone hammer this early and in the middle of discussion... Thank God cheetory was a sniper."
"This didn't seem genuine to me. It's easy to say in response to someone calling you out that it was just banter, but I don't think I buy that."

[droog]

i dont even remember what i was pushing before
being sick in bed all weekend does that

but someone please explain to me why arycons first sentences are all these vague trickle down licorices that sound as scripted as joe biden isnt

[droog]

When did I not have a vote in play?

I didn't say you didn't. But for all of the discussion you were involved in, you would think your vote would move at some point in an effort to actually pressure someone. It wasn't doing much sitting on wgeurts for all of day 2.

[droog]

why the hell am i voting yyr
[unvone][/unvote]
VOTE: vote: acryno

[droog]

2. Droog is kissing a lot of ass.

[droog]

i dont even like that i was voting yyr so why is philamon voting yyr

[Thor665]

But really, I can't understand why you think he's town. Like, at all.

Well, to avoid straw men - my stance is simply that I lean town on him *and* that I find the case on him empty. I will agree to the former my reasoning is mostly 'gut' and 'lack of scumminess' to the latter however I have offered very clear thoughts - something the Phil wagon (which got suspiciously large) totally lacked.
If there isn't scum on that wagon I will eat my metaphorical hat.

Also, you should really stop acting like it's cute that I'm bothered by your lack of input whilst you admit to lacking input.
Yes, I know you're lacking input.
Being self aware of it on your end changes absolutely nothing about the issue with it.

[Thor665]

i dont even like that i was voting yyr so why is philamon voting yyr

Because neither of you are voting Blair.
Y'know, the one who I caught using a double standard who is trying to bluff through it because she "expects" more from a given player because he "presented" as being more logical despite doing zero assessment of whether he is or is not actually logical regardless?
Yeah.
Y'know, the scum?

[Dyslexicon]

Thor, I'm not admitting lack of input. Sorry that you misunderstand me.

[Thor665]

This from the person DCL claims seeks motivation as a scumhunting tool.
Y'know.
Y'know.
Y'know.

Especially by the time you're admitting that your last vote had no reasoning to it?
I am so frustrated right now.
Seriously.