Mini 458 - Game over!

[Carrotcake]

Im going to re-roll, having no lynch as an option for the first vote was a bit silly.

Original Roll String: 1d12

1 12-Sided Dice: (6) = 6

[Carrotcake]

Unvote
Vote: DanMonkey

[molestargazer]

Unvote

Vote: MoS

for trying to out-confuse the mod.

Unvote.

Now I've gotta say that the random stage of the game is over, we need to stop dicerolling to lynch people and see if we can find some solid evidence to go on.

Vote: carrotcake

[/b]

This was the second vote on carrotcake at the time. I mean, it's not serious, but he could have at least thought of a silly reason.

[Adel]

J-man & molestargazer were the last to confirm, which to me means that they are the most likely to have been engaging in PMs before game start. placing the second vote on carrotcake is another thing that sends a up a flag, but analysis of silly votes does seem a little..... silly.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Down with molestargazer!

unvote, vote: molestargazer

[Per]

Vote Count (#3)

Tromboner: 3 (fak, J-man, pickemgenius)
molestargazer: 2 (Adel, Mastermind of Sin)
carrotcake: 1 (dylan41985)
dylan41985: 1 (DanMonkey)
DanMonkey: 1 (Carrotcake)
No lycnh: 1 (Tromboner)

Not voting: 3 (molestargazer, Kate, ThAdmiral)

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[pickemgenius]

Wouldn't mind hearing more from:
fak(random vote only)
DanMonkey(random vote+QFT)
dylan41985(random vote)
tromboner(no lynch vote)

All with confirmation posts.

Tromboner why the vote for a no-lynch?

[Carrotcake]

J-man & molestargazer were the last to confirm, which to me means that they are the most likely to have been engaging in PMs before game start.

Thats a bit unfair to people with odd time zones.

[pickemgenius]

Heads up for everyone here, I know i've posted this in the Vacation thread already, but from June 20th-26th(ish) I will be on vacation.


95% I should have Internet access, just letting you know in case for some reason that doesn't happen =/

Don't need a replacement.

[Kate]

J-man & molestargazer were the last to confirm, which to me means that they are the most likely to have been engaging in PMs before game start

.


Thats a bit unfair to people with odd time zones.

Or theywere just last by chance. In my old game I was last to confirm, but I was the cop.

[pickemgenius]

J-man & molestargazer were the last to confirm, which to me means that they are the most likely to have been engaging in PMs before game start

.


Thats a bit unfair to people with odd time zones.

Or theywere just last by chance. In my old game I was last to confirm, but I was the cop.

That's true also.
Just because somebody isn't on 24/7 and confirms last really doesn't mean alot.
RL takes over sometimes.
I don't take alot of stock in the last few to confirm, unless of course you want to mention it jokingly in connection to a random vote.

[fak]

I agree that being last to confirm doesn't mean much.
Bringing up the last-to-confirm-theory seems more suspicious, but that's not much either.

For now I'm keeping my vote to see if pickemgenius' springboard works.

[J-man]

Down with tromboner

no lynch this ealry in first day is stupid and stupid people will be more likely to break under pressure therefore...

BANDWAGON TOMBONER

[Adel]

I agree that being last to confirm doesn't mean much.
Bringing up the last-to-confirm-theory seems more suspicious, but that's not much either.

Looking at activity logs, molestarman didn't post at all while the rest of us were confirming, and J-man had only one other post, just an hour before he confirmed. I guess I should've checked the logs before I gave voice to my hunch. My bad. I always imagined that scum would plan out elaborate plans requiring military precision, and that would take time. Does that mean we may have sloppy and unprepared scum who won't be all on the same page? I am a newbie, just in case that last question doesn't give it away.

[ThAdmiral]

I just think you're reading into things a mite bit too much. But good effort to check up on their messages and stuff though.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Heads up for everyone here, I know i've posted this in the Vacation thread already, but from June 20th-26th(ish) I will be on vacation.


95% I should have Internet access, just letting you know in case for some reason that doesn't happen =/

Don't need a replacement.

You'll be gone because you're coming to MoS-Faire?

[molestargazer]

I wont bother quoting the Last to Confirm thing, reading back, that's all dealt with.

Down with molestargazer!

unvote, vote: molestargazer

DOWN WI- no, wait. Not down with molestargazer. Please?

placing the second vote on carrotcake is another thing that sends a up a flag, but analysis of silly votes does seem a little..... silly.

OMG SCUMBUDDY ROFLOL!!!!
Not really.
I agree with you - I'm just trying to get some discussion going, and it seems it worked, aye?

[pickemgenius]

Heads up for everyone here, I know i've posted this in the Vacation thread already, but from June 20th-26th(ish) I will be on vacation.


95% I should have Internet access, just letting you know in case for some reason that doesn't happen =/

Don't need a replacement.

You'll be gone because you're coming to MoS-Faire?

lol, I wish. That'd be nice.



I actually have family out in Colorado, and i'm going to a few Rockies vs. Yankees games while i'm there, so that's swell.

[Adel]

<- Colorado native. They do have internets there, I promise.

How far are you willing to take the tromboner bandwagon? Are there more open seats? Does it have a/c and a good stereo? Leather seats and minibar?

[pickemgenius]

<- Colorado native. They do have internets there, I promise.

How far are you willing to take the tromboner bandwagon? Are there more open seats? Does it have a/c and a good stereo? Leather seats and minibar?

<- Colorado born, Nebraska raised.


1. The tromboner wagon?
Umm, i'd actually, basically like to see him post something, that'd be a good start on what vibes i'm getting, or not getting, shit i'm not sure yet, I just don't like the no lynch vote. *shrug*

2. A/C- yes
Good Radio- i'd say pretty decent
Leather Seats- no
Minibar- umm, how's a cooler work filled with assorted beverages, and whatnot?

Room Hmmm.

Van(8 people)- Family(4 people)- room taken up by luggage and whatnot(2 people+back)= theoretically two spots open.



Yeah, not sure what hotel i'm going to be at (weird right, why the hell do you stay at a hotel when visiting family?)

Oh well, I say the 5% no internet because i'm not sure what hotel we're staying at, at that time.


Now i'm at 99.99% Internet (barring I forget to bring a laptop) I should be good.

[Mastermind of Sin]

The molestargazer wagon has a snack cart! and it's free!

[J-man]

cmon guys lets get rolling bandwagons only work well if people actually jump on *wink its called gravity oh and by the way we are on a slope (hence the gravity)

[fak]

Sounds like we have a werewolf rooting for a quick lynch.

Unvote: tromboner
Vote: J-man

for pushing for a bandwagon.

[molestargazer]

The molestargazer wagon has a snack cart! and it's free!

Oi - oi!
I'll have you know it's

MY

bandwagon, I choose the prices.

[Adel]

no, no, you are just the draft animal. Yep, we're in a wagon being pulled by a mole. Exciting stuff.

A general question for the rest of you: where do you stand on the "lynch the lurkers" tactic? I think that on Day 1 the player with the least posted activity (content consisting of insightful posts, original opinions, FoSs and votes,

not

word count) should always have a wagon until a very convincing case can be built for one player.

In general, I think it is better to wait until

two

convincing cases can be built. The debate between the proponents of each case could be very illuminating.

It is all about generating enough information to make an informed decision.

Anyway, I'll suggest unorthodox tactics throughout the game. Some people think Mafia is a game about social conformity. "The nail that sticks up get hammered down." I'm an iconoclast and I just do not operate that way. So, fair warning.