Mafia 64: The New "C9" - Game over!

[inHimshallibe]

I'm against for letting Guardian off the hook.

unvote; vote: Guardian

[Mastermind of Sin]

Original Roll String: 1d18

1 18-Sided Dice: (6) = 6

[Mastermind of Sin]

vote: Autumn Evenings

[Mastermind of Sin]

EBWOP: I'm on Page 14 right now, I'll change my vote to a serious one when I finish rereading this weekend. Gonna be gone all night, so I won't be able to give you my thoughts yet.

<3 Schtick.

[Yosarian2]

I'll try to post something before monday.

(nods) Ok, I'll hold you to that. And when you do, please let us know who you think is scummy.

[Yosarian2]

MOS: Why random vote when replacciin a 24 page game before reading the game? Weren't you worried you might accidently randomally lynch someone?

[Shteven]

I really don't consider myself lurking, but I didn't have time thursday night, and I get home friday, and there's already 8 more pages posted in two days. That's just insane, from my pov. So compared to you guys, I may be. But really, just wow. Get up and get yourselves some drinks My post on wednesday night at 11:30 local (10:27 forum time) was the very post on page 16. it's been about 44 hours since then, and we're on page 24. Some sympathy please. For the record, I have read up to page 19, I will try to catch up this weekend, or later tonight.

I'll answer some of the criticisms of me that were raised in those pages.

Shteven--are you aware that the only person you've voted all game is Albert? And that you placed that vote (which was the 6th vote on his early game wagon) in post 60 and said:
Shteven wrote:
I just laughed when I saw point #3, so I'm tossing out a mostly random vote to help him out: Vote: Albert
? And that aside from Albert, all you've done up until this page is voice a minor suspicion (based on gut feeling) of Glork and discuss game theory? FoS: Shteven.

Yes, I am very aware that albert is the only person I have voted for. I am also having no trouble remembering that it started out as a random vote. It did not remain random for long, though, as I explained in several posts.

From my second post (I'm doing a sort by my posts only):

Albert, keep in mind that some of us aren't regulars. I'm not in 4 games right now, and I've never played with you. I don't spend much time on this site, and there is absolutely no way I am going to go read your previous games to hope to pick up some hint as to if you are being "usually scummy". My vote on you was mostly random, but as of now, it's still feeling quite correct.

So I'm saying that despite random voting, all the things going on since then have reinforced it. It's becoming, over time, a serious vote. I also raised some suspicions of Glork in this post.

In my 4th post I mentioned I did not like Albert's claim, and that I was quite happy remaining on his bandwagon. In my 6th post I was still holding onto Albert, but other posters are catching up, mainly battle mage, guardian, and glork. Lately I haven't seen much from battle mage, and his bandwagon was just as suspicious as he was, so I'm not too certain about that.

And then this is my favorite part, in that 6th post:

I am not forgetting that my vote is still on albert.

But I guess Autumn must have missed that, having just finished reading the thread <.< Also, while I haven't built full fledged cases on most, I have argued against Albert, Glork, Guardian, Battle Mage, Haut Boy (Autumn) and Hungry Joe, which is a bit more than the Albert/Glork you listed. Granted, I haven't said volumes about the other targets, they were merely mentioned. Re-reading my own posts, the only problem I see is that TCS seemed sane back then, and he's now seeming much less so. Where I left off around page 19 he's just starting to pick up a wagon.

Shteven: WHY did you decide you wanted to keep your vote on Albert in Post 160?

Well, it may be the reason I listed right there in post 160:

Albert, keep in mind that some of us aren't regulars. I'm not in 4 games right now, and I've never played with you. I don't spend much time on this site, and there is absolutely no way I am going to go read your previous games to hope to pick up some hint as to if you are being "usually scummy". My vote on you was mostly random, but as of now, it's still feeling quite correct.

To paraphrase, he's acting scummy -- and admitted to acting scummy -- then offered the defense that we should read his other games, and find out that this is normal. I object to that as I hardly am able to keep up with one game, there's no way I'm going to read another 4 so that I can meta-game this one. Considering that defense as completely worthless, My vote remained.

With all that said, there simply wasn't much to go on in the earlier pages (and I'm counting pretty much all the way up to page 15 in that) to make me change my mind. The last few (16-19) have gotten much more interesting, and there are better targets out there. Once I finish reading it, I will post again, and pick someone else. For now,

Unvote.

[Shteven]

by the way, what does EBWOP stand for?

[Yosarian2]

Edit by way of post

[YogurtBandit]

Edit by Way of post.

[Jack]

edit by way of post

[Albert B. Rampage]

EDIT BY WAY OF POST

[Guardian]

edit by way of post.

[Yosarian2]

Boy, you guys are trying to get your post counts up, aren't you

[YogurtBandit]

Boy, you guys are trying to get your post counts up, aren't you

=o

[inHimshallibe]

edit by way of post... >.>

But in all seriousness, let's hang Guardian... or TCS... or... Glrawk.

[Albert B. Rampage]

edit by way of post... >.>

But in all seriousness, let's hang Guardian... or TCS... or... Glrawk.

lol what ?

[inHimshallibe]

Bleh, my sarc meter's down at the moment. Do you have a question in particular for me, or just goofing?

[Albert B. Rampage]

Yeah, I was and I got one. Do you hate me ?

[LoudmouthLee]

Please stay on topic. I know the game is moving fast, but...

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote

until I get a strong case on someone.

[AutumnEvenings]

vote: Autumn Evenings

This is my very first vote ever on mafiascum.

Just thought you'd all like to know. Good thing I wasn't anywhere near a lynch.

Shteven, I did indeed read those posts. It wasn't hard, as you only had about 5 of them. (I just looked, you now have 9, including the one asking what EBWOP stands for.) What I'm saying is that you aren't adding anything except "I'm happy with my random vote." You have

not

argued against those people...unless you're counting this:

Taking the vote count off page 9 (seemed as good as any) BM's wagon was: Haut Boy, HungryJoe, Guardian. If you want to check other pages for other names, please add them here, it's getting late. Haut is now AutumnEvenings, of course. HJ's been a bit odd, but nothing too anti-town, but this would be enough to FOS him in my book. Guardian would be the worst of those three.

as an argument, which I certainly wouldn't. (Not to mention, that's in the post where I said "up until your last post", so...thank you, drive through.)

And for crying out loud, would people stop calling the game boring?! If you don't like what's happening, step up and post something

real

. Don't just lurk and/or complain while waiting for other people to do everything for you.

[LoudmouthLee]

Vote Count:

Guardian- 4 (BattleMage, TCS, HackerHuck, inHimshallibe)
Albert B. Rampage- 3 (AutumnEvenings, Yosarian2, Guardian)
YogurtBandit- 2 (BeanBagBoy, Jack)
Shteven- 1 (Glork)
TCS- 1 (YogurtBandit)
BattleMage- 1 (Johhan)
AutumnEvenings- 1 (MoS)

Not voting (5): Shteven, MBL, HungryJoe, Albert B. Rampage, Billy Twilight

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I'm pretty sure I unvoted.

[MrBuddyLee]

Unvote

until I get a strong case on someone.

It's Day One. Your vote should ALWAYS be on someone.

vote: Albert