Mini Normal 1609: The Case Of Doctor Pepper (Game Over)

[Flubbernugget]

This thread needs more passive aggression.

Here's the wikipedia article on self-fulfilling prophecies.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-fulfilling_prophecy

[Titus]

VOTE: Jagged

I don't like him or tell tale.

[Titus]

Don't you find it funny that when I suggest the vengeful shoot Jagged how his wagon deteriorates?

[Wake1]

Is that L1?

Did he claim VT?

[Wake1]

I do not trust BBT, TTH, or FG. My gut is really telling me they're in cahoots, baking each other up, and scummy.

[FakeGod]

Titus, if you could give me your thoughts after catching up, I would appreciate it greatly.

I will take your vote as you're not doing this.

TTH, hammer.

[FakeGod]

Nevermind.

I think that was the hammer.

[Wake1]

*Backing, not baking.

[FakeGod]

Nevermind again.

He's at L-1.

Someone hammer please.

[Wake1]

I'll let someone else do it, because he's not my ideal lynch. He hasn't come up with an elaborate claim like certain others have. Mark my words for future Days, please.

[Titus]

Titus, if you could give me your thoughts after catching up, I would appreciate it greatly.

I will take your vote as you're not doing this.

TTH, hammer.

Tomorrow I will. I wanted to play today out and get wagon info. Jagged and TTH's responses were not good today but I don't want to be stuck in tunnel vision mode.

That should be L-1 by my notes.

[FakeGod]

I think it's rather careless of you to put Jagged at L-1, and expect the thread to be still open tomorrow.

[FakeGod]

Or maybe fearless.

Nevertheless, I will be here tomorrow.

[Titus]

FakeGod, fearless is the right answer. If someone fasthammers, we get info. Given my play will center on flips and cracking them, that's the idea. I do not fear death or much negative consequence. I do not act stupid but I do not act out of fear.

[Jagged Appliance]

If my flip will help you all so much then could someone please hammer.

[Green Crayons]

Guys, Jagged's lack of scumhunting is a lot more recent than AK's, keeping in mind AK usually doesn't post on weekends.

lol

1) Yes, but Anatole spent 1000+ posts not scum hunting. And then did it in a minimalist, unobtrusive fashion.

2) Actually, Jagged did a bit of scum hunting over the weekend, so he's got Anatole "beat" by your peculiar standard of vote worthiness.

3) This is a weird argument because both Anatole and the Jagged slot have not provided much substance, so how does the recent quality of either's contribution relate to alignment?

[Green Crayons]

At least give AK the chance to replace out when he sees this shitfest.

Also, what?

[Jagged Appliance]

Anatole wagon appears, now I'm getting pushed through rather quickly. Awaiting Anatole's hammer.

[DoctorPepper]

Anatole Kuragin and massive have been prodded

[Doogal121]

STAHP!!!! We are not bringing up another person to the noose to force them to claim. We have 5 claims already, pick one and hang them.

Firstly, let me discuss TTH vengeful ability. It is anti town. Period. Even if TTH lets everybody else discuss on who she uses it on, we still have to A: Kill a townie to use it and B: We lose all vote counts on the target and C: We have to make the decision on who to kill will less info then if we waited for the next noose to come by. I’d rather analyze all the flips first and then make smart decisions then just shoot randomly.

BBT: I’m having a real hard time with this claim HOWEVER I do not believe we should kill him now. If he is not lying, eventually we’ll have a counterclaim or possibly a night kill of his mason buddy that will make him confirmed town in my eyes.

Csareo-Titus: VT claim, seems townie, waiting to see more for Titus and looking forward to doing VCA.

Boons: Tracker claim is somewhat reasonable, let’s see what happens tonight.

Jagged: VT Claim, doesn’t seem townie, let’s hang him sooner rather than later

@Green, BBT, TTH Seriously? Another wagon? Come on!!!!! (Jagged, I forgive you for jumping on this for self preservation purposes)

[Jagged Appliance]

Please elaborate on why I'm not townie. That's for everyone, if only to help my play in future games.

[TellTaleHeart]

I just read Doogal's latest post and I have to say that I'm not a fan.

[TellTaleHeart]

Don't you find it funny that when I suggest the vengeful shoot Jagged how his wagon deteriorates?

When did this occur? You just put the wagon at L-1.

[Green Crayons]

@Green, BBT, TTH Seriously? Another wagon? Come on!!!!! (Jagged, I forgive you for jumping on this for self preservation purposes)

To quote one of my favorite players (Untrod Tripod): I'm not searching for "the platonic ideal of wagoniness." I don't think anyone is in this game, actually.

I do recognize that we need to lynch

someone

, and that that person might actually claim in the march up to that lynch. However, recognizing that we need to lynch someone doesn't mean that we shouldn't take into account the role reveals as they develop, evaluate those claims and the wagons on them, and shift our focus on other players as appropriate.

Your message is basically, "hey we have five claims, so we should lynch out of that pool even if you don't think that any of them are a helpful lynch to the town." From my position, you post is declaring that I should vote either a claimed, non-counter-claimed, appropriate-given-the-mason/neighbor-scenario PR (Boon), a 99% likely town player (BBT), a person whose likely-town flip won't tell us much (Jagged), a person whose probable-town flip won't tell us much (TTH), or Csareo's slot who doesn't have enough votes to push through a lynch.

No thank you.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Flubber, Boon and Doogal have been on 3 separate wagons together so far, GreyIce, myself and now JA. Their voting has been very similar in this game, I would bet there is at least one scum in those three, possibly two.