In post 349, Nazarene wrote:I've found the case on gray to be particularly boring and based on misunderstandings more than anything, but I'll read it thoroughly now.
It's not even so much that there IS much of a case on GF's misunderstandings. He did something scummy and, when called on it, defended himself by attacking and accusing those calling him on it scum. His reaction to being called out is as telling, if not moreso, than the problem I had with his play before.
I suppose this could be a case of town-vs-town, but I'm leaning away from that the more he tries to push a case on me for disagreeing.
In post 349, Nazarene wrote:
Thoughts on max? mantis? Heel while you're at it just gimme all your reads
Max is null leaning town. I haven't had any problems with his interpretations of events for the most part. I disagree that effort = town, though. Effort may equal appearing to look town, but it's not a towntell any more than it is a scumtell. I find myself agreeing on a lot of his points about SoS. I may also be more suspicious of them(SoS) because they are agreeing with me.
Mantis is null. She has posted enough, I suppose, but she hasn't really said much in the way of content.
Quinoa is practically useless and has been active lurking/trolling all game. Would not be sad to see him executed today, either, policy lynch or not. His few posts with content appear to be pulled from his backside.
You are... teetering. I'm starting to see a pattern of people assigning scumminess on account of associative reads all over this game, though. I'm going to go with null leaning town. Your contributions seem mostly genuine.