Mini 447 -Game Over

[pickemgenius]

we're randomly lynching as it is.

we have like 4 people that will decide who will be lynched.

I can in good conscience lynch somebody who hasn't posted for the reason that they could have gotten their role pm, saw oh shit i'm mafia, i'm out of here, and that's it.



I'd be ok with Relph also, because he promised analysis and hasn't yet.

[Arkest]

It's WIFOM to try and determine a role based on the player abandoning the game. A mafioso who has abandoned the game can't hurt us though

Poison Ivy never posted in this game, and hasn't posted on site since 5/16.
Relph hasn't posted since 5/22.
Y.C has asked to be replaced.
These three need to be replaced, not lynched.

thethirdnail has been around, but isn't posting now for some reason?

[Haschel Cedricson]

It's WIFOM to try and determine a role based on the player abandoning the game. A mafioso who has abandoned the game can't hurt us though

/signed

Poison Ivy has given us absolutely no information. I would much rather vote for someone that gives of scummy vibes than for someone who gives off no vibes at all.

[pickemgenius]

1.It's WIFOM to try and determine a role based on the player abandoning the game.
2.mafioso who has abandoned the game can't hurt us though

first off, yes those numbers magically appeared out of nowhere.

1. Yes, but I can think about it.
2. We still want them gone either way.

[blahgo]

Alright guys It's deadline time and it appears to me tha Poision Ivy has been lynched. He was a townie.


Get night choices in. Deadline is Monday.

[blahgo]

AlSleet Will be replacing Y.C.

[blahgo]

As the town wakes up they find Arkest Dead.



Arkest was a Townie.


With 7 left 4 to lynch.

[pickemgenius]

Vote: Blue Zebra

Just a hunch really.

Arkest always gets NK'ed

I am thought thinking Alsleet could be scum, since the night choice was made right after he replaced in the game.


But that's straying off in WIFOM territory.

[Blue Zebra]

Why only one NK? Last time there was two.

[pickemgenius]

beats me. Maybe the SK/Vig??? is inactive

unvote

Vote: Alsleet

[thethirdnail]

sorry guys, i hadn't checked the post in awhile (due to lack of activity) and then i went to denver for a few days. Sorry i missed the deadline, though i don't think i would have changed my vote.

too bad arkest is gone, he had a lot of good things to say.

i'm thinking relph has not posted due to lost interest.

[AlSleet]

FOS:pickemgenius

You hopped on the lynch Ryan bandwagon at the beginning and now all it seems to me like you've been doing is accusing people to draw attention away from the fact that you're looking pretty scummy.

[AlSleet]

beats me. Maybe the SK/Vig??? is inactive

unvote

Vote: Alsleet

What reason do you have for voting for me?

[pickemgenius]

That's kind of the response I knew would come from you.


I always change my vote alot.

You can check other games I don't mind.

[AlSleet]

That's kind of the response I knew would come from you.


I always change my vote alot.

You can check other games I don't mind.

Well, I do believe that is a classic scum tell.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Alright, I have three questions that I would like answered before I vote for anyone.

pickemgenius: You are the one who first advocated lynching somebody who had not shown up. Was there nobody else you felt was scummy enough to merit a vote?

SpinWizard: You unvoted thethirdnail before the deadline, but you failed to vote for anybody else afterwards. Why?

Blue Zebra: What is your analysis of pickemgenius and SpinWizard?

[SpinWizard]

Because i miss read the thread and gave a reson that never happerned, also do we have a SK or a vig???

[Blue Zebra]

At first I thought SpinWizard's lack of content was from him not knowing what to say because nobody was asking him questions, like I said earlier.

i think thethirdnail was silly putting ryan at -1 but then pmg and your bandwagon on thethirdnail was very over the top as it was only page 2

Though here it looks like he's answering the question by repeating what everyone else said instead of saying anything for himself.

I'll comment on pickemgenius after he answers HC's question.

[AlSleet]

Well, I changed my mind. I'm still suspicious of pickemgenius(no really hard evidence other than his constant vote changing). But, for right now, I'll

vote: thethirdnail

. He bandwagoned in the way beginning, then he tried to clear himself by drawing suspicion to nonposters and delivering some ultimatum that I don't know if you guys remember. And now he hasn't posted for a real long time, but that may be because this thread is like dead. Anyhow, scummy is scummy nonetheless.

Speaking of nonposters, this guy Relph really needs to post.

[pickemgenius]

Alright, I have three questions that I would like answered before I vote for anyone.

pickemgenius: You are the one who first advocated lynching somebody who had not shown up. Was there nobody else you felt was scummy enough to merit a vote?

Nobody that has been semi-active, or active here when I placed the vote looks scummy. I was shocked to see a pretty quick second vote applied in the very next post by BZ.

[pickemgenius]

Also straying into WIFOM territory (and cause I see Alsleet is on)


Isn't it *possible* that Alsleet is scum, since a few hours after the fact, the NK was made? And I didn't see anybody else on during that time.

[AlSleet]

Also straying into WIFOM territory (and cause I see Alsleet is on)


Isn't it *possible* that Alsleet is scum, since a few hours after the fact, the NK was made? And I didn't see anybody else on during that time.

Well, I did have to confirm myself replacing Y.C and getting my role(which isn't mafia by the way) and whatnot so the game couldn't continue unless I was confirmed. So that's why night ended right after I came in.

[pickemgenius]

Also straying into WIFOM territory (and cause I see Alsleet is on)


Isn't it *possible* that Alsleet is scum, since a few hours after the fact, the NK was made? And I didn't see anybody else on during that time.

Well, I did have to confirm myself replacing Y.C and getting my role(which isn't mafia by the way) and whatnot so the game couldn't continue unless I was confirmed. So that's why night ended right after I came in.

Sat Jun 09, 2007 1:47 pm - point at which you replaced Y.C.



Sat Jun 09, 2007 3:37 pm - point at which NK was made.



Night ended two hours after you replaced in.
Nobody else was on during that time from this game (that I saw, correct me if i'm wrong) so you were the only one who could have made the NK.

[AlSleet]

Also straying into WIFOM territory (and cause I see Alsleet is on)


Isn't it *possible* that Alsleet is scum, since a few hours after the fact, the NK was made? And I didn't see anybody else on during that time.

Well, I did have to confirm myself replacing Y.C and getting my role(which isn't mafia by the way) and whatnot so the game couldn't continue unless I was confirmed. So that's why night ended right after I came in.

You were monitoring who was and wasn't on from this game for nearly two hours? If you were then I'd say that's unhealthy. And also, there's people who keep their names hidden when they log on so consider that possibility.

I know it seems highly coincidental, but that's all this really is: a coincidence. If you want to vote on such thin logic, fine, then we'll be down another townsperson and I don't think anyone except scum would be willing to take that risk, so I suggest you point your suspicion to someone who warrants it moreso than I do.


Sat Jun 09, 2007 1:47 pm - point at which you replaced Y.C.



Sat Jun 09, 2007 3:37 pm - point at which NK was made.



Night ended two hours after you replaced in.
Nobody else was on during that time from this game (that I saw, correct me if i'm wrong) so you were the only one who could have made the NK.

[AlSleet]

Also straying into WIFOM territory (and cause I see Alsleet is on)


Isn't it *possible* that Alsleet is scum, since a few hours after the fact, the NK was made? And I didn't see anybody else on during that time.

Well, I did have to confirm myself replacing Y.C and getting my role(which isn't mafia by the way) and whatnot so the game couldn't continue unless I was confirmed. So that's why night ended right after I came in.

You were monitoring who was and wasn't on from this game for nearly two hours? If you were then I'd say that's unhealthy. And also, there's people who keep their names hidden when they log on so consider that possibility.

I know it seems highly coincidental, but that's all this really is: a coincidence. If you want to vote on such thin logic, fine, then we'll be down another townsperson and I don't think anyone except scum would be willing to take that risk, so I suggest you point your suspicion to someone who warrants it moreso than I do.


Sat Jun 09, 2007 1:47 pm - point at which you replaced Y.C.



Sat Jun 09, 2007 3:37 pm - point at which NK was made.



Night ended two hours after you replaced in.
Nobody else was on during that time from this game (that I saw, correct me if i'm wrong) so you were the only one who could have made the NK.

Did you really monitor everyone who was and wasn't on from this game for nearly two hours. If you did, I'd say that's unhealthy. Plus, two hours is a relatively long span of time so I don't think it'd be terribly unlikely for someone to log in for even ten or fifteen minutes to NK. Also, some people keep their names hidden when they login so you should also consider that possibility.

I know this all seems very coincidental, but that's all it is. Coincidence. Now, you can follow your thin logic and lynch yet another townsperson or you can aim your suspicion at someone who warrants it more than I do.