Robbery! At The Casino (Game Over)

[geraintm]

This is going nowhere. I've been waiting for a day for a reason to post and I got nothing.
Random vote will stick where it is till I see a good reason to move it

[BlueBloodedToffee]

This is going nowhere. I've been waiting for a day for a reason to post and I got nothing.
Random vote will stick where it is till I see a good reason to move it

Another person complaining nothing is happening but doing nothing to progress the game at the same time.

What exactly was you expecting to happen to allow you to post?

[GrayFoxxxx]

BlueBloodedToffee

Spoiler:

post 27

Votes prolapsed for understandable reasons. Could be scum looking to wagon.

post 40

Nothing special here.

post 52

Actually thinks I died. Scum would know that I am town, so towny vibe. Unless WIFOM.

Also questioned a town read on beck.

Probably the most informative post.

post 54

Sarcasm. I think.

post 68

4th to vote shos. Haven't ISO'd shos yet to see if it makes sense. Sent up a mental flag.

post 75

Pressures Double to generate content.

post 79

Gives a little insight to why he voted the way he did. Not really much substance though.

post 86

I agree it was wierd, but what information are you talking about?

post 89

Plausible point.

post 96

Grilling me, but why? I still dont see why it was horrible questioning.

post 99

More sarcasm



All in all tough to read. Don't like the vote pattern but its nothing definitive

[GrayFoxxxx]

Shos

Spoiler:

post 5

This has been called buddying, but IDK. I don't think that EVERY post is alignment indicative.

post 6

Fluff

post 24

Votes prolapsed 2nd. Didn't give a reason.

post 29

Fluff.

post 39

Pushing for wagon still no reasons.

post 42

More pushing on prolapsed. Literally done nothing else but this.

post 48

Claims Beck is town. Another claim with no reason. THIS feels more like buddying. Unless he is making a scum look more town?

post 50

More buddying

post 53

Just a wierd post all around. I don't get the mason thing.

post 57

Fluff.

post 64
post 67
post 70

Pretty much all Fluff.

post 85

I dont get why you would troll in the first place, if experience has shown you its bad. This could be a weak excuse for scum play. I don't see a town acting like that, knowing it seems scummy.

Questions BlueBloodedToffee. I think this is is first towny move.

post 87

Questions the buddying claim. Also asks why if his other posts look wierd. Don't really get the question, but doesn't scream scum.

post 88

Could be another "excuse" for scummy play. Or he really was drunk.

post 91

Defends the buddying stuff. I dont quite understand what he is saying.

post 92

Why? After pushing Prolapsed so hard?

post 93

Asks a reasonable question.


Shos hasn't really done much scumhunting, and has 1) Pushed for a wagon while not giving reason. 2) Changes votes suddenly.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Aronis

Spoiler:

post 58
3rd to vote Shos.No reasoning.

post 66

Responds to Shos


This is about at null as it gets. Lurking hard.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Egg

Spoiler:

post 44

Votes Prolapsed 4th. Nothing else.

post 65

Votes me for defending myself. But-

post 72

Unvotes me when I defend myself here. Kinda counterintuitive, but w/e.

Dont get the logic, but again, very null.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Your last two 'reads' on Aronis and Egg prove my point of why asking for reads at this stage is an awful question.

You're going to come up with an awful lot of null reads.

[shos]

GrayFox, while I appreciate your effort, keep your energy. the game has not yet evolved enough for anything to truly analyze like you do.
for your quesiton - the reason it 'proved badly' was because I was quickhammered while making the first serious post, on page 5. assume that by now I'm already dead. that was a horrible hammer, and the reason was that I posted "making a post", lol. town failed miserably that game >_> but surely enough, in all my other games (and that one too actually) the idea is to provoke reactions etc. this time I just decided to stop early before any chance of quickhammer arises.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Double Trouble

Spoiler:

post 15

Fluffy

post 20

Flavor hinting I guess.

post 45

Asks a Desp about his vote on me. Could be scum hunting Desp, or trying to seem relevant. I'm going more towny on this one.

post 74

Fluff.

Not alot to go off of here.

[GrayFoxxxx]

I agree alot of reads will be null. Doesn't mean there is nothing in looking.

The replies to them may also generate some valuable info. It doesn't hurt to give early game reads (if there are any). We can possibly have more informed votes for Day 1, and I don't see how that it bad in any situation.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

It's not bad per se, just a waste of time. If you were doing this on like p15, I wouldn't have a problem with it.

If you have questions you want to ask, ask them. You don't need to do Pbpa on everyone at this stage.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Perfect Chaos

Spoiler:

post 25

Votes Desp.

post 35

Gives meta reason for his vote. Meta doesn't mean alot to me, but alot of people use it so this is ok.

post 37

Elaborates on the meta reasoning.

post 77

Asks beck to elaborate kinda towny. Also speculates on Prolapsed's intent. I like that part.


This guy is giving off a small town vibe, even if he is mainly tunneling Desp.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Geraintm

Spoiler:

post 16

Giving his formula for RVS vote. Safe way to vote.

post 26

Shos got the post.

post 100

Says he doesn't have reads, but is willing to keep his vote on the largest wagon. Why not unvote?

Nothing much, don't like the last post though.

[shos]

as I said, keep your energy for later in the game, where it matters more and has more meaning.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Dr.Pants

Spoiler:

post 28

RVS vote on beck. Maybe he doesn't like that band.

post 55

Votes Shos with a legit reason. Towny feel.

post 78

I dont know how I was awkward. This seems like active scumhunting regardless.

post 82

I like this post and I like the logic behind it. Unless Prolapsed and Pants are scum together.

post 84

Philosphy about game mechanics.


Pants has given me the strongest town feel so far.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Guys I have plenty of energy for this. I am willing to do another round of these after more content is available, so dont worry.

[theaceofspades]

i honestly don't think so. His town strikes me more towny then it does scummy.

And i did mean the band.

could you explain this?

town should be tone. typo.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Prolapsed Brain

Spoiler:

post 17

The only confirmation post I am looking at. This seems to be the main topic right now so I will give my opinion. I can't understand a scum doing this, but maybe thats why he did it. Wayyy too WIFOM. I wont vote someone based off this alone, but if he continues to act ambiguously I am going to assume its scummy.

post 34

Fluff.

post 69

It doesn't look like you are paying attention to anything actually. Is this a ploy to make 2 scum seem distant?


Slight scum read, but I need more to move my vote to him.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Beck

Spoiler:

post 18

Interprets Prolapsed's posts as scummy.

post 23

Locks in vote. I cant tell if this is scum taking advantage of a wierd post or not. He isn't the only one to think that way though. Infact he initiated the wagon. I find it more likely scum would hop on a little later.

post 32

WHY DIDNT HE GET MOD KILLED??? all jokes aside fluffy.

post 41

Sticks to his guns about his vote. This is always towny in my eyes.

post 43

Pushing for more votes. Null

post 49

I did.

post 62

Fluff

post 73

Tunneling prolapsed. I'm iffy about him doing this so much.

post 76

Uses meta to defend his vote. Meta isn't the best method IMO but I've said before it's ok.

post 80

Doesn't acknowledge counter point to the Prolapsed debate. Also doesn't give proof of scum tell, after using it to push the wagon. I can't tell if he is just hyper tunneling or scum trying to get a mislynch.

post 81

Again one of my fav town tells is standing your ground. He does this here. I think scum would usually find another goat to go after.

post 83

Debates RVS wagon. I disagree with him 100%

post 90

More standing his ground


Getting a light town vibe, even though I dont fundamentally agree with alot of his posts.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Going to eat then come back and finish up.

[GrayFoxxxx]

Also

UNVOTE: Beck

[Metal Sonic]

Perfect Chaos, can you please put your name on the bottom of your post so I know if it's Fish or MS posting.

I do agree with what Beck is saying. PB's confirmation post felt all kinds of wrong, but so does Shos' play so far as well.

ATM, I find Shos' recent posting to be scummier than PB's confirmation post, so that's where I'm at.

It has been always been fish I haven't posted yet

[Metal Sonic]

Lol jiffy can you update the title it's not pregame

[GrayFoxxxx]

Desperado

Spoiler:

post 33

Im not sure if this is serious or just RVS.

post 36

I guess this is a defense for the vote against him

post 38

Same as last post.

post 46

Dont like he is so sure I am scum.


Null again.

[GrayFoxxxx]

theaceofspades

Spoiler:

post 30

RVS.

post 47

Easy

post 56

I think he is giving his opinion of Shos here. I dont agree with it

Another lurker. Hard to read.