NY 176: Completely Ridiculous Mafia (Game Over)

[T S O]

I'm not moving my vote today. That list doesn't even contain the point about the vig n1 - which, for what it's worth, didn't seem like such a fantastically common theory when I didn't even know it existed and I'm one of the people actually questioning Ceph's alignment.

[T S O]

It's entirely possible Cabd is scum. It's also entirely possible he is town. I am not going to risk the game when Cephrir is so much more blatantly scum than him.

[T S O]

I don't intend to say much on the matter - scum are obviously content to let this game die to apathy, which is why they're not posting.

Every town player has to be responsible for constantly pushing this game. Every game I've had as scum in LyLo with apathetic town, I have won. Every single one.

[T S O]

I won't, though, have it said that I was part of a lacklustre shower of morons who handed the game to scum. No.

Vote Cephrir. He's scum.

[TheWayItEnds]

But you've hard voted twice today too.

Why would Ceph's vote on Cabd be more scummy than either of yours?

[ika]

hey tso, you scum?

if not tell me why

[T S O]

hey tso, you scum?

if not tell me why

please just fucking play or replace out

But you've hard voted twice today too.

Why would Ceph's vote on Cabd be more scummy than either of yours?

because my vote was/is not a blatant survivalistic piece of shit with no actual build-up?

there is no way you can be this dense, twie.

[TheWayItEnds]

Like you voted AP earlier.

And AP is like... pretty town I think?

He shows up in very few of my paranoia teams even.

And crumbing nurse in a game that almost HAS to have a mafia doc in his first post seems pretty good.

Like, is it possible that AP looks at his scum team and sees maf doc and crumbs nurse? Yeah.

But without knowing what town power looks like that seems like a risky thing to do.

So why, if AP is town, would he not have been quickhammered with your vote left on him?

[T S O]

ap's not town?

plus loads of this is complete bull - I won a scumgame recently by d1 crumbing PGO. AP wouldn't necessarily have to claim his crumb. etc.

[TheWayItEnds]

He would have after we had our d2 conversation about it.

[T S O]

Call me Rose Tyler because I'm looking for a man with a sonic screwdriver.

I have a feeling I'm going to be a lot like state farm mafia this game.

VOTE: Nero

Que tal?

This is an obscure crumb which next to no-one could even comprehend.

[T S O]

But let's not discuss AP, let's discuss Cephrir. You still haven't really refuted anything I've said, bar ...a 4-man quickhammer?

[TheWayItEnds]

And yet....

Thats where I got nurse from.

[TheWayItEnds]

Because if he was scum, people would easily have jumped on him, or quickhammered him, or SOMETHING. There's been nothing.
Because I've had a horrible gut feeling from him all game.
Because he repeatedly pulls shit like hardvoting Cabd when it's going to be him vs Cabd today which is horribly scummy.
Because he has done nothing all game.
Because there are quite probably 4 scum players alive today and for him to be town is incomprehensible to me.
Because a lot of stuff he's done makes no sense as town trying to figure stuff out.
Because he is a better town player than this.

You want me to refute...

no 4 man quickhammer on Ceph
Gut
his hardvoting vs your hardvoting which ive already brought up
doing nothing is subjective, especially coming from you
4 scum players left isnt a reason
Lets talk about this one. This one is fine.
meta?

What stuff has he done that makes no sense as town trying to figure stuff out?

[ika]

tso answer the question or i will vote you

[T S O]

go ahead

[TheWayItEnds]

Or you know what?

Instead of voting Cabd or Ceph.

We could just vote Ika.

For being the worst fucking town player I've ever seen if hes town.

Plus Ki-gi was like... not town either.

[T S O]

you don't know how much I'd love to do that

but I don't really feel like tossing the game on a coinflip, which is what ika is in my pov. actually, in your pov too, I guess.

[TheWayItEnds]

Yeah but I dont want to lose to someone who plays like a retard on the off chance he rolls scum so he can play like a retard and win because of it.

[T S O]

thing is if he's town we've already lost

if I was on the scumteam, and I really wish I was, I would have told them to withhold voting/doing anything today, and watch us no lynch.

the worst bit is it'll probably work.

[T S O]

he's never going to actually be helpful/vote scum/do anything except moronic bullshit, I guess

[T S O]

I'd do it, but I want to make proper predictions first.

[T S O]

Ceph/Iz/ika/{cabd/ap} is my guess. maybe right, maybe wrong.

gun to my head, cabd's last scum.

[TheWayItEnds]

What do you think about aegor?

[T S O]

fairly sure I re-read him and something makes me think he's town. I have a 3/3 record of reading Aegor, afaik, so meh.