Mini 427 - Clue Mafia 1 - Game Over, Who Won!?

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #175 (ISO) » Wed May 23, 2007 5:03 pm

Yeah, no PBPA. Lynch the liar. I have to go to bed. I'll try to do something tomorrow. Work was murder.

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #176 (ISO) » Fri May 25, 2007 2:24 am

Sick yesterday... limited time. Still lying.

BillyTwilight · Post Post #177 (ISO) » Mon May 28, 2007 4:00 am

chaotic_diablo wrote:I'm going to side with Billy on this. He has justification for his actions that make sense. The arguments that Billy voted a -1 is like a hammer given the threat of TCS is pretty much void given that Billy did explain consistency in TCS's actions in previous games. In fact, they are actually the same game.

I don't quite understand the MBL votes given the reasons are crap and I'm kind of suspicious of the people who actually followeed through with that sort of poor reasoning.

What reasons for voting MBL do you see as crap? My main problem with MBL is that he is constantly mischaracterizing the events at the end of day 1, not only in this game, but in the other two games as well. I think that is well worthy of a vote, especially since most people who have commented on it have agreed that my interpretation of events is the correct one.

Alko, can I get some feedback from you on post #166?

On a reread, I really don't like DoS's post #165. He is piling on without adding anything or committing a vote or the like. Minor scumtell.

FoS: DoS

.

Ectomancer · Post Post #178 (ISO) » Mon May 28, 2007 8:08 am

Actually Billy, what DOS did was even worse in my mind. He is there trying to set up a "one or the other" scenario. Without some game mechanic (if both were to claim cop for example) to give us an honest situation where 1 of them must be scum, then setting up 2 people where one of them (at least) must be lynched is a scum tactic.

unvote, vote DOS

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #179 (ISO) » Wed May 30, 2007 2:50 am

I'm bored with this game. No one posts.

I'm a cop. I have a guilty on MBL.

Battle Mage · Post Post #180 (ISO) » Wed May 30, 2007 2:57 am

hmm well it fits with your behaviour, but im reluctant to believe TCS is town, and MBL is scum, when it really doesnt fit with the gameplat imo.
also, we already had a cop. i highly doubt we have 2 sane cops in a 12 player game.
unless your role name is The Cop, like it was last time we caught you as scum.

FOS: TCS

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #181 (ISO) » Wed May 30, 2007 2:58 am

I am Wadsworth. It's possible I'm insane or paranoid. I don't know. We'll find out one way or t'other, I suspect.

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #182 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 2:06 am

I wonder if, being Clue mafia and all, a whole bunch of us have investigative-type roles.

Ectomancer · Post Post #183 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 4:16 am

The Central Scrutinizer wrote:I'm bored with this game. No one posts.

I'm a cop. I have a guilty on MBL.

Well alrighty. So we lynch MBL today, and if you are lying, we lynch you tomorrow.

unaccuse, accuse MBL

MrBuddyLee · Post Post #184 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 11:03 am

I'm not scum.

vote: TCS

MrBuddyLee · Post Post #185 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 11:09 am

Holy crap, if by some odd chance you're actually a cop, what a terrible play you just made. There's already a cop revealed and you don't for a minute think your investigation might be a paranoid or insane one? A pro-town cop would consider the potential worth of his next few days' investigations and not shoot his wad as you did.

I'm not buying it. I think you're bored of the game and you just wanna cause some chaos and take a good scumhunter down with you.

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #186 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 11:34 am

MrBuddyLee wrote:Holy crap, if by some odd chance you're actually a cop, what a terrible play you just made. There's already a cop revealed and you don't for a minute think your investigation might be a paranoid or insane one? A pro-town cop would consider the potential worth of his next few days' investigations and not shoot his wad as you did.

I'm not buying it. I think you're bored of the game and you just wanna cause some chaos and take a good scumhunter down with you.

You're right. I'm bored of this game. It sucks ass. The setup is fine but no one is talking.

I am a cop. I have a guilty. I as good as said it anyway when I accused you so if I waited another night I might have died if my investigation is correct. So you die now.

If I'm wrong, I'm dead. And I could care less. I've tried my best to keep things moving in these Clue games, damn my alignment, and I all get for them is a lot of shit and a lynch.

Here, let's maybe save a town, if I'm paranoid/insane.

unvote, vote:TCS

If I'm a sane cop, if the mod says so either way, lynch MBL tomorrow. I'm fucking done with this game.

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #187 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 11:37 am

Like, I'm removing it from my watched list and pretending I never played it. Decide without me.

DragonsofSummer · Post Post #188 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 11:46 am

Unaccuse Accuse MBL

@Ecto: All I was saying is that they were my top two suspects for those reasons. I just wasn't ready to vote either of them because of the reason that TCS is so fed up with these games.

MrBuddyLee · Post Post #189 (ISO) » Thu May 31, 2007 12:10 pm

Your reasoning for voting me?

DragonsofSummer · Post Post #190 (ISO) » Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:25 pm

I am trusting TCS's claim.

al_kohaulec · Post Post #191 (ISO) » Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:53 pm

Yeesh, I'm doing bad right now, I do intend to respond to the post Billy referred to, and have been ever since I first read it, but my schedule right now definitely isn't going to allow it of me.

Good news though, this week is the last week of classes, next week I finish up finals, and then I'll have summer and a little more free time. I do promise to respond to that post ASAP though, I will say for now that I did not agree with everything in it, though.

al_kohaulec · Post Post #192 (ISO) » Sun Jun 03, 2007 2:54 pm

EBWOP: Based on his play so far in all three games, I'm inclined to believe that TCS is town, but until I have time to look things over, I don't know what to say about his cop claim.

Battle Mage · Post Post #193 (ISO) » Sun Jun 03, 2007 10:26 pm

hmm im not sure who to believe. to some extent, the odds of TCS being scum here look high, and MBL NEVER looks scummy. there again, its a risky play to make as scum. if TCS is right about 2 claimed cops, lynching MBL might not prove TCS's alignement either way.

MrBuddyLee · Post Post #194 (ISO) » Mon Jun 04, 2007 5:03 am

I'm not scum, so either TCS is not a sane cop or he's scum.

I've never been lynched as town before in order to prove a retarded "cop" was insane or lying. Let alone one who's bored of the game and is playing carelessly.

I'd prefer this not be the first time, obviously, but that's really up to you guys to decide at this point.

Mastermind of Sin · Post Post #195 (ISO) » Wed Jun 06, 2007 6:06 pm

Posting would be nice.

The Central Scrutinizer · Post Post #196 (ISO) » Thu Jun 07, 2007 10:52 am

I am currently a little less angry at this game, and will therefore post.

I have a guilty on MBL, but my role PM does indicate that I should check to make sure I am correct, or something to that effect. It is possible I just have a questionable sanity. This is something I should have looked over before claiming. But have it what you will, I am Wadsworth, FBI, and I have a guilty on MBL. I could be sane, insane, or paranoid. In 2/3 of those he COULD be scum and in 1/3 he is with certainty.

I would just lynch MBL today, and if it turns out badly, we can lynch someone else tomorrow. If that someone else is me, fine. I shouldn't have claimed, and I'm an idiot. Oh well.

al_kohaulec · Post Post #197 (ISO) » Thu Jun 07, 2007 3:19 pm

Doesn't FBI normally find out the SKs?

Battle Mage · Post Post #198 (ISO) » Thu Jun 07, 2007 11:20 pm

and just when i was about to give you the benefit of the doubt. I dont like the way in which you are safe-guarding yourself, so when MBL comes up town, you are still not certain scum. the problem is, whichever one of you is lynched, we wont necessarily gain insight into the role of the other.
what can we do?

The Central Scrutinizer wrote:I am currently a little less angry at this game, and will therefore post.

I have a guilty on MBL, but my role PM does indicate that I should check to make sure I am correct, or something to that effect. It is possible I just have a questionable sanity. This is something I should have looked over before claiming. But have it what you will, I am Wadsworth, FBI, and I have a guilty on MBL. I could be sane, insane, or paranoid. In 2/3 of those he COULD be scum and in 1/3 he is with certainty.

I would just lynch MBL today, and if it turns out badly, we can lynch someone else tomorrow. If that someone else is me, fine. I shouldn't have claimed, and I'm an idiot. Oh well.

BillyTwilight · Post Post #199 (ISO) » Fri Jun 08, 2007 3:54 am

I am still sticking with the vote against MBL, less because of TCS' claim and more because of the same reason I was voting him in the first place. In lieu of lynching MBL, I think DoS is the second best play for the day, mostly because of post #165.

As far as TCS' claim goes, I think its very odd. I really

don't

think that TCS is scum here, but I am getting a nagging feeling from the way that he claimed, seemed to realize he'd made a mistake, then quit posting for a while. Plus, the stuff about his PM saying something about "making sure you are correct" doesn't sit well with me; it seems a little... forced.

Alko, do you have any comment about my rebuttal post to your vote of me a couple of weeks ago?