Open 571- Pick Your Poison Game over

[SXTLHGaiden]

grab

[Fluminator]

Alchemist: You caught my eye because you were following paths that won't lead anywhere too useful. It could be explained by you coming from a different site that is more meta-based. Would you care to link me the site you played on previously? People coming from different sites seem do things that could be interpreted as scummy on this site.

I really see nothing suspicious with Reino. I don't like it when people suspect people based on their aggressiveness. I believe it's helpful for town to have a few aggressive players. People voting for Reino should re-analyze there vote and see if it is based on reason or personality.

Krystal Bald wagon seems to be gaining traction. Maybe I will do a meta on them. Unless anyone else already knows them pretty well? Also which one of the hydra heads did that gambit? It was so blatant that I have trouble believing it would be that easy.

Aphix: Hey! The only guy I know. Good to play with you again. Your two votes are Kurigan and Krystal I believe? Do you currently lean to believing both are scum?

UNVOTE: SXTLHGaiden
Not impressed with you so far, but I feel this vote isn't doing anything.
VOTE: randomidget
Definitely leaning scum on this guy.

[Alchemist21]

Ok, now I see it. When they said caps, I thought they meant all caps.

[Alchemist21]

Here Fluminator. This is the site where I do traditional mafia. I just started there so I'm learning how to play from there. Only have 1 game on it which is still ongoing, and lurked through some of their older games to try and pick up how they play.

http://www.millenniumforums.com/forumdi ... afia-Forum

This is another site I've been playing on for months, but the mafia games work very differently here because they're heavily focused on night actions instead of day phase posts.

http://otakucentral.org/forumdisplay.php?f=35

[Krystal Bald]

To clarify the first point in my post, I think it's inconsistent to say something is both sarcasm and a reaction test. Even rereading it I can't really see it as having a sarcastic tone.

I have no idea what you're talking about. The sarcasm thing was completely different from the test.

[Matsumi Sisters]

I don't particularly agree with the angle about KB scum slipping. any scum who is not complete shit at the game would read the role PMs and the setup and realize how it's played. that is literally rule #1 of scum. so the logical conclusion is either he's town reaction testing or scum doing a fake reaction test for towncred

in either case it's not a scum slip

KB might be scum, but not for that

my townread on KB mostly comes from a pattern I'm observing in their play. I've modded one game they were in (they were town) and I saw it there, and I have very good reason to believe it'd be different if they were scum. however, I'd rather not out it until I'm sure of it. also I really liked their angle re: aphix (185).

-Yuu

[Matsumi Sisters]

btw reinoe

I don't like anything reinoe is doing. all he's done so far is comment about roles and push a theory that one or more of Alchemist/Ank are scum. his entrance reads more like scum who isn't sure how to blend in with the thread, so he attempts to focus on setup spec to cover it up; it's also really bad that he calls out Alchemist for not having any town reads, while not having any himself.

I made a case on you that has nothing to do with aggression or playstyle. respond to it instead of dodging it.

-Yuu

[Krystal Bald]

Are you even reading our posts Al?

[reinoe]

btw reinoe

I don't like anything reinoe is doing. all he's done so far is comment about roles and push a theory that one or more of Alchemist/Ank are scum. his entrance reads more like scum who isn't sure how to blend in with the thread, so he attempts to focus on setup spec to cover it up; it's also really bad that he calls out Alchemist for not having any town reads, while not having any himself.

I made a case on you that has nothing to do with aggression or playstyle. respond to it instead of dodging it.

-Yuu

Why should I give a damn about your case on me?

[Krystal Bald]

Based on the last eleventy billion Pick Your Poison games the roles are almost definitely...

1 shot cop
innocent child
2 shot vig.

Anyone who doesn't claim one of these should just be lynched.

This is a really bad idea.

^ what happens when scum start fake claiming reinoe

It's precisely because of fake claims that anything besides those three roles should be hammered. Scum can fake roles not in this game without ever being countered. Those three roles are almost always taken.

What are your thoughts on this Krystal?

well i was thinking that scum could just fake claim those particular roles

[Matsumi Sisters]

are you fucking serious

-Yuu

[reinoe]

Based on the last eleventy billion Pick Your Poison games the roles are almost definitely...

1 shot cop
innocent child
2 shot vig.

Anyone who doesn't claim one of these should just be lynched.

This is a really bad idea.

^ what happens when scum start fake claiming reinoe

It's precisely because of fake claims that anything besides those three roles should be hammered. Scum can fake roles not in this game without ever being countered. Those three roles are almost always taken.

What are your thoughts on this Krystal?

well i was thinking that scum could just fake claim those particular roles

You think scum could easily fake-claim 2-shot vig or innocent child?

[Alchemist21]

Are you even reading our posts Al?

Yeah, but I was confused about what you two heads were saying because I couldn't tell the heads apart. Now that I see how you two are identifying yourselves I'll reread the posts and try to re-evaluate them.

[Matsumi Sisters]

Why should I give a damn about your case on me?

if you legitimately do not understand this, I do not have any faith you would ever be capable of understanding it

the whole point is that you explain to me why I'm wrong so that, if you are town, I can fix my read on you

there is also the fact that if no one ever responds to cases made on them, all it does is allow scum to hide by just dodging every single time someone calls them out

there are several other reasons why making arguments and responding to them is literally how the game works. what you are doing is anti-town as fuck and as long as you keep dodging I have no choice other than to assume you have no explanation. so, try again

-Yuu

[reinoe]

Why should I give a damn about your case on me?

if you legitimately do not understand this, I do not have any faith you would ever be capable of understanding it

the whole point is that you explain to me why I'm wrong so that, if you are town, I can fix my read on you

there is also the fact that if no one ever responds to cases made on them, all it does is allow scum to hide by just dodging every single time someone calls them out

there are several other reasons why making arguments and responding to them is literally how the game works. what you are doing is anti-town as fuck and as long as you keep dodging I have no choice other than to assume you have no explanation. so, try again

-Yuu

Why can't it be that I just don't care? Let's say your theory that you've put too much though into is true. Do you think me not giving a fuck about your case is scummy? If you do think it's scummy how scummy do you think it is?

[Krystal Bald]

You think scum could easily fake-claim 2-shot vig or innocent child?

ahhh. no :p
didn't even think of that

[Matsumi Sisters]

Why can't it be that I just don't care? Let's say your theory that you've put too much though into is true. Do you think me not giving a fuck about your case is scummy? If you do think it's scummy how scummy do you think it is?

HELL FUCKING YES. town who have an incorrect case pushed on them should, you know, be able to actually EXPLAIN why the case is wrong. on the other hand, scum are more likely to get defensive or just outright ignore arguments against them, which is what you're doing here.

also, you trying to discredit my argument because "lol I put too much thought into it" is scummy as fuck.

-Yuu

[reinoe]

Why can't it be that I just don't care? Let's say your theory that you've put too much though into is true. Do you think me not giving a fuck about your case is scummy? If you do think it's scummy how scummy do you think it is?

HELL FUCKING YES. town who have an incorrect case pushed on them should, you know, be able to actually EXPLAIN why the case is wrong. on the other hand, scum are more likely to get defensive or just outright ignore arguments against them, which is what you're doing here.

also, you trying to discredit my argument because "lol I put too much thought into it" is scummy as fuck.

-Yuu

This is actually kinda fun...

what's your opinion of Alchemist "dodging" my case on him?

[reinoe]

Why can't it be that I just don't care? Let's say your theory that you've put too much though into is true. Do you think me not giving a fuck about your case is scummy? If you do think it's scummy how scummy do you think it is?

HELL FUCKING YES. town who have an incorrect case pushed on them should, you know, be able to actually EXPLAIN why the case is wrong. on the other hand, scum are more likely to get defensive or just outright ignore arguments against them, which is what you're doing here.

also, you trying to discredit my argument because "lol I put too much thought into it" is scummy as fuck.

-Yuu

This is actually kinda fun...

what's your opinion of Alchemist "dodging" my case on him?

Lulz. It's like the Matsumi Sisters saw exactly where I was going with this and decided to shut the fuck up. I see you logged in on the bottom of the forum page.

[Fluminator]

SXTLHGaiden, who are your scum reads right now?

[Krystal Bald]

i think i like reinoe

[Krystal Bald]

he's another snarky one

[Krystal Bald]

SXTLHGaiden, who are your scum reads right now?

also, ya i've been trying to get him to post more.

[Krystal Bald]

i'm unsure on anatole.. cause i liked him for town. but then his vote was kinda of.. "ok since ppl are asking me, i'll just put it there"
i didn;t like it cause it seemed too convenient if he is scum to place it after being prompted


i hope this makes sense... im half asleep

[Ankamius]

Eh. That's too much of a stretch. He hadn't stated any particular scumread towards anyone else before that.

I'm more worried about the fact that it was his first vote in the entire game, but even that's less scummy and more a minor annoyance.