Open 571- Pick Your Poison Game over

[Anatole Kuragin]

A scumslip makes more sense to me, and would be more optimistic about your mafia prowess which you seem to feel is being threatened here, than that "reaction test" possibly having any town motivation behind it.

[reinoe]

Based on the last eleventy billion Pick Your Poison games the roles are almost definitely...

1 shot cop
innocent child
2 shot vig.

Anyone who doesn't claim one of these should just be lynched.

This is a really bad idea.

^ what happens when scum start fake claiming reinoe

It's precisely because of fake claims that anything besides those three roles should be hammered. Scum can fake roles not in this game without ever being countered. Those three roles are almost always taken.

What are your thoughts on this Krystal?

[Krystal Bald]

Could you collect all the relevant quotes into one post please? I don't really want to go digging.

Come on he has like 5 posts his iso takes literally 30 seconds to read.

A scumslip makes more sense to me, and would be more optimistic about your mafia prowess which you seem to feel is being threatened here, than that "reaction test" possibly having any town motivation behind it.

TIL that being unable to see why someone did something means they must be scum, ty for the lesson sir this will certainly help me become a master mafia prowesseur.

[Anatole Kuragin]

No, making what appears to be a slip, then trying to twist it into a "reaction test" with the intention of implicating a townie (or clearing them) for really shit logic means they're likely scum.

[Anatole Kuragin]

but yw for the lesson

[Krystal Bald]

Based on the last eleventy billion Pick Your Poison games the roles are almost definitely...

1 shot cop
innocent child
2 shot vig.

Anyone who doesn't claim one of these should just be lynched.

This is a really bad idea.

^ what happens when scum start fake claiming reinoe

It's precisely because of fake claims that anything besides those three roles should be hammered. Scum can fake roles not in this game without ever being countered. Those three roles are almost always taken.

What are your thoughts on this Krystal?

Just because a coin flips heads ten times in a row doesn't mean it's gonna flip heads an eleventh time.

[Krystal Bald]

No, making what appears to be a slip, then trying to twist it into a "reaction test" with the intention of implicating a townie (or clearing them) for really shit logic means they're likely scum.

OK so you're saying your entire argument is based in the fact that you think I made a slip. TY for admitting that, I must now direct you to my above post where I describe myself as not an idiot.

[reinoe]

VOTE: alchemist

Wrong choice.

VOTE: Reinoe
.

So you think Ankamius is more likely to be scum than Alchemist? If so why?

[Majiffy]

Could you collect all the relevant quotes into one post please? I don't really want to go digging.

Come on he has like 5 posts his iso takes literally 30 seconds to read.

And let me tell you how much I care.

Not 30 seconds worth.

Your

scumread,

your

case,

you

present.

So you think Ankamius is more likely to be scum than Alchemist? If so why?

No,

you

do.

Your logic necessitates Ank-scum independent of Alchemists' alignment.
Either he's scum bolstering his buddy's reads, or he's scum buddying a townie.

Your vote is on the wrong slot for your argument.

Hence why my vote is on you.

[reinoe]

So you think Ankamius is more likely to be scum than Alchemist? If so why?

No,

you

do.

Your logic necessitates Ank-scum independent of Alchemists' alignment.
Either he's scum bolstering his buddy's reads, or he's scum buddying a townie.

Your vote is on the wrong slot for your argument.

Hence why my vote is on you.

You've got it backwards. Al's reads are shit-posting. He's scum. Ank could be naive town who likes shit or could be scum buddy giving fake town cred.

[Randomnamechange]

Not liking reinoe here but I think he is town.

[Anatole Kuragin]

No, making what appears to be a slip, then trying to twist it into a "reaction test" with the intention of implicating a townie (or clearing them) for really shit logic means they're likely scum.

OK so you're saying your entire argument is based in the fact that you think I made a slip. TY for admitting that, I must now direct you to my above post where I describe myself as not an idiot.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

everyone makes mistakes, doesn't make you an idiot

[aphix]

Aphix, what made you change your mind on your opinion of Krystal's brilliant reaction test?

Nothing changed.

[notscience]

Pretty Picture

Working on thsi right now

1.04

With

13

alive, it takes

7

to lynch.

Majiffy(1)-

SXTLHGaiden

SXTLHGaiden(0)-

Fluminator

Fluminator(3)-

Doublade

reinoe(0)-

Matsumi Sisters, Majiffy

Alchemist21(0)-

reinoe

randomidget(0)-

Clusk92(1)-

Ankamius

Matsumi Sisters(1)-

Ankamius(0)-

Anatole Kuragin(1)-

aphix

Doublade(1)-

randomidget

Krystal Bald(0)-

aphix

aphix(0)-

Krystal Bald

Deadline

Deadline is September 29th at 12:30PM EST. This is in (expired on 2014-09-29 11:30:00)

Boring Mod notes

All VCs up to this one have had flavor inserted, go back for lols.

Rapunzel is the best Disney Princess.

[Alchemist21]

Vote Krystal Bald

I don't like all the inconsistencies from KB. The reaction test and sarcasm claims just seem like really poor cop-outs.

[Majiffy]

You've got it backwards. Al's reads are shit-posting. He's scum. Ank could be naive town who likes shit or could be scum buddy giving fake town cred.

Can town not have shit reads?
Is it more likely that scum is buddying a shit-reading town, or that town is LOLOKLOOKSGOOD about scum shit-posting?

[Ankamius]

Not liking reinoe here but I think he is town.

Can you clarify this for me please?

[Ankamius]

Now, that I'm pretty sure is an omgus vote.

Not liking this post.

[reinoe]

You've got it backwards. Al's reads are shit-posting. He's scum. Ank could be naive town who likes shit or could be scum buddy giving fake town cred.

Can town not have shit reads?
Is it more likely that scum is buddying a shit-reading town, or that town is LOLOKLOOKSGOOD about scum shit-posting?

It's not about the shit reads: I'm indifferent to those. It's that Al's entire post was just flinging suspicion at people. Even his town reads had subtle suspicions thrown around.

Read post 151 again and ask yourself: does this post have a town motivation or a scum motivation?

After you do that I'm sure you'll help lead the wagon on alchemist.

[Krystal Bald]

I don't like all the inconsistencies from KB. The reaction test and sarcasm claims just seem like really poor cop-outs.

explain inconsistencies plez

[Alchemist21]

Most of them have already been pointed out to you in this thread, because they've mostly stemmed from you defending your "reaction test." You also said at the start of the game you were going to sign your posts, which you've never done, and there have been times when I've been confused by it, because one head says something, and the other head (I presume) says something different immediately afterwards. It gets really confusing to see the heads talking to themselves.

After seeing the players' views on hydras here, I think a lot of people would agree with me that you should start signing your posts.

[SXTLHGaiden]

they never said they would sign posts. they just said "caps mean one head, non-caps is the other".
also, i don't like reaction tests.

[Alchemist21]

To clarify the first point in my post, I think it's inconsistent to say something is both sarcasm and a reaction test. Even rereading it I can't really see it as having a sarcastic tone.

[Alchemist21]

they never said they would sign posts. they just said "caps mean one head, non-caps is the other".
also, i don't like reaction tests.

That's pretty much the same thing since it's a way to ID the heads. Either way, they haven't done it.

[SXTLHGaiden]

check the iso, they do have capitalization differences.