InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Birds of Prey]

Of course, you would know that Kagami if you were town and had a shard.

[Kagami]

Where was it, where was all this "get all the shards" speculation?

And if anyone gets something from getting all the shards, it would assuredly be naraku.

[Kagami]

Of course, you would know that Kagami if you were town and had a shard.

I don't have a shard. It would be broken if I did.

[Birds of Prey]

Now why would it be broken if a vanillaizing puppet had a shard?

ProHawk has implied that. If you look through my iso. My thought is scum cannot get all of them.

btw, Kagami doesn't hammer me. Check Kagami tonight Goat. If she comes back positive, lynch her.

[Kagami]

You're claiming your an ascetic with a shard? No.

[Kagami]

Now why would it be broken if a vanillaizing puppet had a shard?

ProHawk has implied that. If you look through my iso. My thought is scum cannot get all of them.

btw, Kagami doesn't hammer me. Check Kagami tonight Goat. If she comes back positive, lynch her.

You still don't know my role? Boy, you're certainly going to a lot of effort to investigate my alignment.

[Lord Mhork]

Why is that a no, Kagami?

[Kagami]

Why is that a no, Kagami?

Because Prohawk and the goat are almost certainly town. A town shardholder ascetic would make no sense, as the ascetic aspect would primarily serve to thwart town power.

[Kagami]

If you're a supersaint I'm not okay with it

If shards pass via lynch hammer, then that presumably would be why NS would want to hammer. Guessing logically, that scum/vig kills can also steal shards. Otherwise, I cannot see two hammers and your role would be nonsensical. Having a townie pick who they want to hammer is logical.

In fact, we all probably should do that. Scum cannot pick a fellow scum or the possibility to chain lynch runs high.

Due to my claim, I probably shouldn't hammer anyone.

I also don't think this is terribly consistent with having a shard, though I can see an argument for intentional obfuscation.

[ProHawk]

There's been speculation for ages that scum get an ability when they get all the shards.

I just brought that fact up this game day I think...

[Birds of Prey]

I recall it much earlier. I have been hiding the fact I have a shard bc scum could kill me at any time and take it.

My pm specifically says scum get a power if they have them all.

If Kagami has a shard lynch her. Even before YnB.

[Young and Beautiful]

@Y&B - what do you think of my Bulba quote and how it relates to your theory that BoP is scum?

It is a solid quote.

Much as I hate to admit it, the evidence that you have presented is in favor of BoP. The only reason I can think of for the moment is that BulbaFenix was so disinterested in the game that he forgot his partners. But that is a weak reason.

However, considering that BoP calls the conf town 'scum', this reason might sound as legitimate as any other when compared to BoP's.

Really though, that doesn't discount that my explanation is poor.


I'd like it if you could find more posts and strong evidence. This is a good one. Unfortunately, it might merely be an exception; one post does not grant the scumbirds amnesty.

[Young and Beautiful]

I recall it much earlier. I have been hiding the fact I have a shard bc scum could kill me at any time and take it.

My pm specifically says scum get a power if they have them all.

If Kagami has a shard lynch her. Even before YnB.

And if kagami doesn't have a shard, she is conftown? Or are you making bad contracts?

[Birds of Prey]

No. Kagami is scum.

YnB suppose BB is scum, how are you conftown?

[Birds of Prey]

It is the degree of evidence. Anyone with a shard should know what I slipped. If Kagami has a shard, she shouldn't lack that knowledge.

[Young and Beautiful]

So Kagami is scum regardless if she has a shard or not? Then what was the point of making that statement. At best, if you're town, you're unreasonable. Of course, you're scum, so no surprise there.


Why should I assume that BB is scum? Violate Occam's razor?

[Young and Beautiful]

No. Kagami is scum.

YnB suppose BB is scum, how are you conftown?

That's why I tried to give my message to the towniest player N2, but scum shot her too.

And that's why I didn't give my message to scummy ones like shos or yourself. That's pretty stupid.

[Birds of Prey]

You should answer the question rather than weaseling. You have weaseled on who could be scum. You should realize you are confirmed town only to the extent BB is town. If BB is scum, then all you have is your shitty suspicious claim and tunnelling on town.

[Birds of Prey]

If you gave the message to scum and they denied it, you would have a 1 v 1. Doubly so if they denied it if you picked them twice.

[Birds of Prey]

If they denied once, they'd have to create a roleblocker where one doesn't exist.

[Young and Beautiful]

The odds of BB being town are pretty good, and odds that I am willing to take.

The only reason you are calling BB scum is because to fit your stupid narrative and tunnel on my slot, which is pretty dumb.


Since the odds of BB being town are much larger than he will be scum, I am conf town until proven to the contrary. That's right, my free pass is still valid.

[Young and Beautiful]

If you gave the message to scum and they denied it, you would have a 1 v 1. Doubly so if they denied it if you picked them twice.

I won't have the chance to do so because there are people like you who would have gotten onto me for failing three times in a row.

[Young and Beautiful]

If they denied once, they'd have to create a roleblocker where one doesn't exist.

A roleblocker doesn't exist? Is that a fact? SCUMSLIP?



The most probable scenario in a 30p game is that scum have a roleblocking role. There is no reason to believe the contrary... Unless you know that as a fact. You are desperate scum who has scumslipped. Game.

[Birds of Prey]

Nice flail. The only people who have claimed blocked are you and BB.

[ProHawk]

The most probable scenario in a 30p game is that scum have a roleblocking role. There is no reason to believe the contrary... Unless you know that as a fact. You are desperate scum who has scumslipped. Game.

Would you be willing to lynch Egg on that?