Open 569 ~ Hope + 1 ~ Game Over!

[notscience]

My entire case for you scum is

Wall fight whoever challenges you to induce apathy

Be aggro enough so noone wants to fight you

[notscience]

I really should just sheep bins tomorrow so she becomes a quadruple voter

[Sakura Hana]

Wall fight whoever challenges you to induce apathy

Be aggro enough so noone wants to fight you

so you're using the exact same arguments as tn now? I thought you had something original...

[Sakura Hana]

I really should just sheep bins tomorrow so she becomes a quadruple voter

Sure thing, i'm most likely going to die tonight tho. Unless scum rather keep me alive to give you the extra vote or unless you're scum.

[notscience]

I'm entirely unoriginal

And I am scum and we decided we're going to keep you alive the entire game

We preplanned the kills to be Pie GIF N1

Varsoon N2 if we can't get him lynched before then

Bins N3

[notscience]

This is me

being a cheeky scumfuck

What are you going to do about it

[Team 9]

Bert you have to wait til tomorrow for it becasue the tunnelfucks are running rampant today

notsci, let's look at it this way.
if you think Bulge is town, what's the problem with my argument?
I challenge you to find one bc I'm actually pretty confident about this. when GIF is telling me I'm on the right track, I know I'm being reasonable.

at this point, Bulge has contradicted himself several times, and he is continually deflecting and hiding behind a shield of "you still haven't proved xxx", as opposed to addressing the arguments against him. then, when I do provide evidence, he proceeds to completely ignore it (bc it's not for a point that is completely unrelated to the point I'm making, even though what I posted is exactly what he asked for - double negative intentional) and continues hiding.

-Rumia

[Team 9]

oh
@Sakura: while you're hear, why is Gaiden town?

-Rumia

[Team 9]

...*here

[Jakuzure Nonon]

VOTE COUNT

1.37

(1) tn5421:

X88B88

(2) SXTLHGaiden:

davesaz, tn5421

(0) startfromtheheart:

(0) X88B88:

(0) Varsoon:

startfromtheheart

(0) Sakura Hana:

(0) Thesp:

(L-3) The Bulge:

Thesp, Team 9, Sakura Hana, Varsoon

(0) Team 9:

The Bulge

(1) davesaz:

SXTLHGaiden

(0) Flubbernugget:

Bins

(0) notscience:

(1) Bins:

Flubbernugget

(0) No Lynch:

Not Voting:

notscience

With thirteen alive, it takes seven to lynch. The day will end on

Monday, September 8th, 2014 @ 11:34pm PDT,

which is in

(expired on 2014-09-09 02:34:00).

[Sakura Hana]

We preplanned the kills to be Pie GIF N1

This won't go through, I'll make

certain

that it doesn't go through.

oh
@Sakura: while you're hear, why is Gaiden town?

-Rumia

General playstyle, it's just that my gut is pretty good at reading Gaiden, but if the town cop doesn't trust me they are free to scan him and prove me wrong (or right).

[notscience]

Lololol

Really now

[notscience]

Pie

I don't disagree

I just trust bins

[notscience]

Because i figure she'd be the best at reading him

And she wouldn't have to misread him as scum because it could tip him off

[Sakura Hana]

Because i figure she'd be the best at reading him

And she wouldn't have to misread him as scum because it could tip him off

And what if they are both scum? Have you ever considered that?

[notscience]

Then I guess I'm up a creek without a paddle

[Sakura Hana]

There's another thing tho:
I currently don't think scum you would make such a bet knowing that Bulge would flip scum because it puts you at a disadvantage of losing 1 member + being someone else's double vote.
However if you think I'm scum and you're townreading Bulge then consider what does that do to help me knowing that he will flip town being your double vote.
And if you think that I know that he's going to flip scum then you should help me bus him.

[Team 9]

Hey notsci since when were you town reading bins?
I don't remember.

[notscience]

Sakura If you're trying to convince me to take it back I won't

Also, I'm back and forth re her

The frustration regarding you tunnelfucks was town though

[Team 9]

If you're talking about bulge rage, then that's a null rage.
You get pissed regardless of your alignment when your points doesn't go through.

[notscience]

meh

[Team 9]

Also no on the vote bet.
The whole point of the vote bet thing is to laugh at other for being wrong and that other person has an strong incentive to prove me wrong prior to the bet itself.
You don't even disagree with me as you said and you suggesting a vote bet for lulz is unacceptable.
So if you want to do a vote bet, make a town case on bulge. Otherwise, there's no honor in that.

[Thesp]

Bridge Day was a smashing success, House of Heroes was AMAZING, and my kids and boardgaming event was exhausting but good. Time to find some scum.

I am disappointed that Sakura Hana is the only person who took my game-breaking attempt seriously, and Varsoon only seems to have skimmed along with it without commenting further on it. Does one one else care about the possibility, is it something you think is tactically poor, do you not want to do it out of a sense of fair play, or what? (PPE based on startfromtheheart's VT claim in #1685 - lynching startfromtheheart may be a better play now, actually, if we decided to go down this route, but I'm beginning to think my few posts on this are going to be washed out in the midnight spam that seems to wash over this thread.)

My ongoing thoughts below the line, with specific questions to people highlighted in bold for ease.

---

I lied I'm not going to bed quite yet because I've been missing marathon weekends.

yea yea priorities, avoiding the thread, etc etc. No. Committing to a re-read and seriously playing a game is very different from playing a marathon. Especially when I'm ready to collapse from travelling.

my scum read on you is also based on POE, and the things you've done while you've been here (aka nothing)

town who lurk at least have some thoughts that they drop by during their limited time in the thread. scum who lurk try to fly under the radar, and generally don't post anything (which is what you're doing)

when they're called on it, they also tend to use "I haven't even done anything!" as a defense, as opposed to refuting the arguments against them (which is also what you're doing)

during your limited time in this thread, you picked up on the fact that MVP was an alt slip of this slot. you've clearly read the thread to some extent. what are your current reads?

-Rumia

This post is full of win. I'm really happy with my vote on The Bulge, and have found his posting since the beginning of activity to be lacking in town content.

---

Actually, I lied.

VOTE: Flubbernugget

Huh? (Oh - explained in 1648. Flubbernugget is actually the one of you all I think is most likely to be town. So I disagree with you here.)

---

I'm not sure I buy the PoE, at least not wholesale. If the only reason you have scum reads on people is that they're the only ones you don't have town reads on, it means the scum are improbably good. Unless the town is also unusually inactive, having all scum inactive/fluffy raises the odds that scum will be lynched early. I don't believe it's likely for all 3 scum to lay low. I think at least one of them would be active, and if they were active then they'd be making a case on someone who was town read by other players. Or the active scum is making a case on an inactive / lurker / contentless player.

Hmm, I had to edit that several times while writing it. Hoping it makes sense...

Make that a case on an inactive/apathetic townie. So either all scum are active, or Team 9 is at least a weak town read. (if one or more scum inactive then Team 9 would have to be bus reading -- not completely out of the question but IMO not likely this early)

From one of the least active players in the game, this feels very self-serving. A davesaz wagon wouldn't make me cry (even if I'm not keen on its current sole adherent).

---

The Bulge

, when did you begin thinking Team 9 was scum? Why?

---

Yeah you're town

I agree

notscience

, where does this come from?

---

Bins

, why do you think The Bulge is town?

[davesaz]

I'm not sure I buy the PoE, at least not wholesale. If the only reason you have scum reads on people is that they're the only ones you don't have town reads on, it means the scum are improbably good. Unless the town is also unusually inactive, having all scum inactive/fluffy raises the odds that scum will be lynched early. I don't believe it's likely for all 3 scum to lay low. I think at least one of them would be active, and if they were active then they'd be making a case on someone who was town read by other players. Or the active scum is making a case on an inactive / lurker / contentless player.

Hmm, I had to edit that several times while writing it. Hoping it makes sense...

Make that a case on an inactive/apathetic townie. So either all scum are active, or Team 9 is at least a weak town read. (if one or more scum inactive then Team 9 would have to be bus reading -- not completely out of the question but IMO not likely this early)

From one of the least active players in the game, this feels very self-serving. A davesaz wagon wouldn't make me cry (even if I'm not keen on its current sole adherent).

Not sure how you see it as self serving. I may be least active in terms of total post count, but that's because I'm incapable of posting fluff. Look inside my iso and you'll see .

[Bins]

I think Cop should decide to claim when they think they're in a situation where they need to claim. If that makes sense.