In post 1648, Bins wrote:He voted me for DOING NOTHING, as you can see... there's a lot of other people... more guilty in that offense.
"Hai there's a lot of ppl more guilty than me ergo i'm not scum"
Before we go down the road of who's more guilty let me remind you that there's more than 1 scum.
In post 1638, davesaz wrote:@Sakura: Punctuation (in particular periods) and line breaks are your friends.
First I should start off by saying that I'm not against the read per se, and have no desire to defend any individual. I'm just pointing out from a pure logic point of view that it is far more likely to be at least a little wrong than it is to be totally right. With that in mind...
The PoE is valid only if all the underlying town reads are valid. Worst case, 3 of the people read as town are actually mafia, and the 3 "eliminated" people are actually town. Best case it's 100% inaccurate and we only need to lynch the 3 identified people to win. I expect both edge cases to be false, and the truth lies somewhere in between. If Team 9 is town, then these 3 players are most likely to be 1 town 2 mafia, or 2 town 1 mafia. If team 9 is mafia, then all 3 of these players are probably town, or one of them might be mafia and it's a soft bus.
To sum that all up, we can't take the PoE for granted. But I think there may be 1-2 scum in those 3 players.
BTW, how would someone who is innocent defend against a PoE read anyway? I don't think I've ever seen one used this early in a game.
Just like PieInNatirasha (God that sounds horrible), My reasoning also started as some sort of PoE, tho my PoE was different from PieInNatirasha (It's more of Bins, Titus, Bulge from which only Titus is an actual scumread while the other 2 are from PoE due to being non-townreads) + Consensus because I wanted to see what would happen with the wagon, likewise I didnt like Bulge's reaction but the way he gave them a town read then suddenly dropped it and turned them into scum (While his original reason to scumread them was already bad enough) felt fabricated to me, which is why such read evolved into a scumread. So what's your current read on Team 9 and why do you think there's certain 1 scum but certain not 3 town or 3 scum on their PoE list? Do you have a town read on any of the 3?
In post 1648, Bins wrote:I think these people are town, and I think that is the geniune consensus.
Am I to assume you're townreading team 9 then? In which case what does this make you think of david's reasoning re:PoE.
Note @Team 9:
Tho I don't have an issue with your PoE, i still think Gaiden's town, and i'm not sure what to think of Bert keeping slinging mud towards him but not doing anything with his accusations.P-Edit:
In post 1649, The Bulge wrote:(my "I haven't done anything" defense that I'm still waiting to be quoted)
I don't what you mean by this, but if you want to people quoting you doing nothing then you're in for a flashlynch.
Disagree with the wagon, sure, but don't go possibly outing PRs