Open 569 ~ Hope + 1 ~ Game Over!

[Team 9]

I did it better than Rumia

-C

[The Bulge]

I lied I'm not going to bed quite yet because I've been missing marathon weekends.

yea yea priorities, avoiding the thread, etc etc. No. Committing to a re-read and seriously playing a game is very different from playing a marathon. Especially when I'm ready to collapse from travelling.

my scum read on you is also based on POE, and the things you've done while you've been here (aka nothing)

town who lurk at least have some thoughts that they drop by during their limited time in the thread. scum who lurk try to fly under the radar, and generally don't post anything (which is what you're doing)

when they're called on it, they also tend to use "I haven't even done anything!" as a defense, as opposed to refuting the arguments against them (which is also what you're doing)

during your limited time in this thread, you picked up on the fact that MVP was an alt slip of this slot. you've clearly read the thread to some extent. what are your current reads?

-Rumia

Just because I was reading along at one point doesn't mean I've read everything. I was never lurking, I was inactive. There's a difference.

Re:marathons, I was just mentioning that in case I said good night and then someone tried pulling some "He's posting in marathons! Lynch this lurker scum!" bullshit.

[Team 9]

yeah, as I thought:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?s ... r_id=24230

look at page 2. Bulge's explanation doesn't hold up. nice try

p-edit: ninja'd

-Rumia

[The Bulge]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

Do you know what PoE is?
Because I don't think you know what it is.
Let me explain it to you.
PoE stands for "Process of Elimination".
That means, by crossing out the unlikely, you reach to a solution.
Let's say that there are 3 options, A,B, and C.
You know that A and C doesn't work, so what's the one that works? B.
It's quite awesome, ain't it?

If you ISO me, you'll see that I called everyone except for those 3 mentioned town for at least some kind of reason.
My current "non-town" reads are all lurkers/contentless players by coincidence.
And as I mentioned, you using your contentlessness as a shield is scummy as hell.

I am very well aware of what PoE is. I was replying to your 1542 which I felt was an unjustified generalization. I wasn't replying to your scumread as a whole.

[The Bulge]

yeah, as I thought:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?s ... r_id=24230

look at page 2. Bulge's explanation doesn't hold up. nice try

p-edit: ninja'd

-Rumia

What's this about?

[Team 9]

Yeah. And I said I've seen scum hitting apathy before town before.

[Team 9]

yeah, as I thought:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?s ... r_id=24230

look at page 2. Bulge's explanation doesn't hold up. nice try

p-edit: ninja'd

-Rumia

What's this about?

Apparently sth about you posting in different non-marathon game.

[The Bulge]

Yeah. And I said I've seen scum hitting apathy before town before.

I saw it. Thanks. I asked for a justification, and you gave it to me. Done.

[The Bulge]

yeah, as I thought:

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?s ... r_id=24230

look at page 2. Bulge's explanation doesn't hold up. nice try

p-edit: ninja'd

-Rumia

What's this about?

Apparently sth about you posting in different non-marathon game.

I was waiting for one to start, which it is now.

Sorry for giving my other games as much attention as this one...

[The Bulge]

[Team 9]

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic

Well this whole thing is wrong here bc as I said I don't have them as scum because they're lurking but rather it is coincidental that my "non-townreads" happen to be lurkers bc I have a varying degrees of town on everyone else, hence my emphasis on "PoE".

[Flubbernugget]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

I don't understand step 3 of that circle.

[Team 9]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

I don't understand step 3 of that circle.

That's because step 1/step 2 is flawed.

[The Bulge]

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic

Well this whole thing is wrong here bc as I said I don't have them as scum because they're lurking but rather it is coincidental that my "non-townreads" happen to be lurkers bc I have a varying degrees of town on everyone else, hence my emphasis on "PoE".

Again, this is all in the context of my misunderstanding of 1542.

[Flubbernugget]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

I don't understand step 3 of that circle.

That's because step 1/step 2 is flawed.

No. Like "which happened to be scum in this game." Like we already know who the scum are? Fuck, I want to say this is a slip, but its too much gut for me.

[Team 9]

Dunno bc I can't find any correlation with the logic you posted and your misunderstanding.

[Team 9]

^
To the bulge

[Team 9]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

I don't understand step 3 of that circle.

That's because step 1/step 2 is flawed.

No. Like "which happened to be scum in this game." Like we already know who the scum are? Fuck, I want to say this is a slip, but its too much gut for me.

I don't believe in "scumslip" if you ask me.

[Team 9]

Just because I was reading along at one point doesn't mean I've read everything. I was never lurking, I was inactive. There's a difference.

Re:marathons, I was just mentioning that in case I said good night and then someone tried pulling some "He's posting in marathons! Lynch this lurker scum!" bullshit.

as I said, my scum read on you does not entirely come from the fact you were posting in other games and not here

most of it was POE, and the way you were posting

while you were here

in this game

just because you hadn't necessarily read everything, doesn't excuse you from at least giving some thoughts on the gamestate while you

were

here. you made at least 4 posts explaining why you were so busy, but you couldn't drop off any reads or thoughts on the game at all?

your overdefensiveness is noted though

-Rumia

[The Bulge]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

I don't understand step 3 of that circle.

That's because step 1/step 2 is flawed.

No. Like "which happened to be scum in this game." Like we already know who the scum are? Fuck, I want to say this is a slip, but its too much gut for me.

What? The post was meant to be from Team 9's POV. Let me reword using their wording.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
This game grew too fast that it tired them out and hit them with apathy before it hits town.
I can confirm this because my it's what's happening to my 3 scumreads.

[The Bulge]

Dunno bc I can't find any correlation with the logic you posted and your misunderstanding.

I wasn't thinking about experience, tbh. I thought you were just talking about this game. So the only logic I could possibly think of was flawed, circular logic.

[Flubbernugget]

your overdefensiveness is noted though

-Rumia

Unfair IMO.

[Team 9]

What I'm saying is you seem like you're saying this for the sake of justifying your scumreads, because you have no real way of backing that up.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
Which happened to the scum in this game
Because these 3 are scum

Circular logic is the only logic I can find here.

I don't understand step 3 of that circle.

That's because step 1/step 2 is flawed.

No. Like "which happened to be scum in this game." Like we already know who the scum are? Fuck, I want to say this is a slip, but its too much gut for me.

What? The post was meant to be from Team 9's POV. Let me reword using their wording.

These 3 are scum
Because they are lurky and apathetic
This game grew too fast that it tired them out and hit them with apathy before it hits town.
I can confirm this because my it's what's happening to my 3 scumreads.

You do realize that the third line is actually not my own reasoning but rather answer for Bin's question about "gimma a scenario where all scum would lurk", right?

[The Bulge]

your overdefensiveness is noted though

I'm not being overdefensive, I'm being active. ie, addressing everything that is addressed to me. Would you rather I go back to "lurking"?

[Team 9]

How far have you caught up?