Also, for the most part, BT did get the gist of the point I was trying to make. I suppose I should qualify/clarify what I meant about speculation on nightkills.
When it is the leading/only discussion or source of suspicion, I find it to be inherently scummy -- there are way too many factors which can go into determining how a player or a scumgroup chooses a kill. Heck, sometimes (me as Godfather in Caddyshack) an N1 kill can be chosen entirely at random. So
in and of itself, speculation on who would have incentive to kill somebody is not very useful.
That said, even in light of other evidence, it's not always reliable. (Yes, I'm downplaying my own point here, to a small extent.) BUT... the reason that I feel Albert's case is exceptional is because of his lamentation over the deaths. Jeep's common scumtells reflects this. (Though it is erroneously listed as a Day 2+ Tell -- I believe this is because Day Start used to be the norm, and so it was impossible to have this tell on D1.) I meant to emphasize
this
point, but it may have come out wrong, and Jack seems to want to harp on the "and he said he thought they were good" comment.
