Mini #406, Animaniacs! Water Tower Explosion! [Over]

[now a ranger]

Oops Fuldu wasn't on the list of people who want to claim, ouch I'm not in the right state of mind right now. I just triple posted because of my stupid computer which keeps crashing..

[Fuldu]

FULDU:
Your count is correct, but still 6 alive at the end isn't bad.
Why did you give Thesp as an example of all people? Do you seriously believe that Thesp could be lying? this seems like covered ground already.

I agree that you should prove yourself before the day's over, but that's only me.

Look at my numbers again. 6 alive assumes that the scum never kill anyone. If they do kill people, your plan hands them a win. The night after we've discovered that none of the three people in question was scum, they make a kill that puts the count at one scum versus one town.

I gave Thesp as an example because his situation was the first one I could remember that fit the possible lying criteria. It doesn't have anything to do with the likelihood of his lying; I just wanted to describe the scenario with a concrete example.

As for proving myself, I'm not clear how you expect me to do it "before the day's over." Either I do it before the blahgo situation resolves itself or I can't do it at all; something I think I've explained at least once already.

[now a ranger]

It's been 7 days since Blahgo replaced Ether, and he hasn't posted at all.


Fritz hasn't posted for even longer, I think.

[Foolster41]

Fuldu:
Calculating a scneerio where the scum doesn't kill anyone is useless then. It's best to chart the worst case scenerio. I realize i saw the number 12 at the bottom of the list assumed that there were 12 still alive, instead of 8.
Here's how I think it would play out worst case scenerio:
Day/Night: Lynch 1 (7 remaining), 1 killed from scum (6 remaining)
Day/Night: Lynch 1 (5 remaining), 1 killed from scum (4 remaining)
Dayt: Lynch 1 (3 remaining), We win.
Yes, if for some reason that one of the people who claimed was ltubg we would most likely loose. However, I ask the question again, isn't there a way that fritz and NAR can prove his role? And if you prove your role that just leaves Thesp, who as it was said before I find it hard to believe is scum. Once we make sure those who claimed are nhot lying with cross confirmations (including me proving myself) we can begin my strategy and be sure of a win out of pure elimination. Obviously if someone doesn't check out, we lynch them and win anyway.

I'm not talking about jumping blindly in to a lynch fest, but a systematic process after a careful elimination of suspects.

[Foolster41]

itubg is aparently code for lying. Or a bad typo.

[now a ranger]

I think Fritzler needs to investigate Thesp and see if he's really female like claimed earlier.

[Foolster41]

I persnaly think it would be a waste of investigation, but if it'll get you to shut up about Thesp being scum, then fine.

[now a ranger]

Better safe than sorry.

[JDodge]

Mod

: Can we get a prod/replacement for blahgo?

[now a ranger]

I believe I'll be a fat pig by the time this day ends.

[Thesp]

I think Fritzler needs to investigate Thesp and see if he's really female like claimed earlier.

I hope Fritzler has been investigating the females to check their genders. We'll get him to claim his investigation before the day ends. I'd also recommend we don't go running over the investigation possiblities, etc. until after everyone's claimed. Don't let the scum in on how we'll win.

[Fritzler]

@ foolster- ether and BJ (now NAR) never claimed, it wasn't lost

2.) NAR-(male chicken boo)
3.) Ether (rep. chamber)-none
4.) Foolster41-Male
5.) Fritzler-Nurse-human-confirmed (hello, nurse)
6.) Fuldu-Male-human (ralph)
8.) JDodge-Male
11.) Thesp-Not male-Confirmed
12.) VitaminR -Male

NAR never claimed (or more accurately blackjudge) but he claimed to be chicken boo so its pretty obvious
Ether should probably claim gender

in addition, if ether of you is non-male i can check you out at night and confirm you

also you will note that both thesp and i are confirmed, as fuldu has proven i can't be a warner as i am pro-town

in addition i can prove that thesp isn't a female proving he isn't the remaining warner brother (so thesp doesn't need to claim species as he can't be scum)

it would be beneficial for fuldu to investigate people that are humans so that he can confirm them

PS i wonder if fuldu investegated NAR if he would find out that he was a human

that would be really funny

bump

thesp is confirmed

come on guys

[now a ranger]

He's not confirmed. If he is scum, then we are going to lose if we don't make sure he didn't lie on purpose knowing what would happen on Day 2.

[petroleumjelly]

*sigh* Searching for a replacement for blahgo. What an exciting character

he

turned out to be.

[VitaminR]

I think it's safe to see Thesp as confirmed for the moment. There's 8 of us left, we have plenty of leeway here. I don't think it's worth pursuing the possibility that Thesp bussed two scumbuddies at this point in the game.

[now a ranger]

fine then.


Wow, blahgo's getting replaced. So much for a replacement. =D

[Thesp]

Here, waiting for blahgo.

[now a ranger]

Here, waiting for blahgo's replacement, as he is getting replaced. =0

[JDodge]

Also waiting.

[now a ranger]

Erm. I didn't see a thread asking for a replacement for Blahgo in this game.

maybe my eyes are too big?

Mod Note: Maybe you aren't looking in the "replacement" thread, where I

did

ask for a replacement for blahgo.

[VitaminR]

We could just lynch blahgo...

[JDodge]

No. Give me one good reason as to why that would be a

good

idea at this point, when we can potentially clear him and a few others

today

.

[VitaminR]

Tired of waiting? Plus, it does seem like a scum role.

But, yeah, bad idea.

[JDodge]

Tired of waiting?

Plus, it does seem like a scum role.

But, yeah, bad idea.

Can you clarify that a bit more for me?

[VitaminR]

It's nothing significant, I just referred to role because it seemed clearer than saying blahethber.