Where has MOS taken weak or nonconfrontal positions? Without examples, your statement is worthless.Quagmire wrote:1) what about all of the times in the game where he's taken weak and nonconfrontational positions?
2) we/i was called out before yesterday.
Do you still think myself or Thok (replacing Ibby) are scum?Coron wrote:Vote: MoS
FoS: Ibby, Mathcam
Bagged 3 scum for the price of 1.
What caused you to move Ibby and myself to the "not scummy" list, without giving any reason to stop suspecting us?overview of who's scummy and who's not.
Scummy: Oberon, mathcam, Uraj, armlx
Middle: Spectrumvoid, fuldu, MMoD, MBL, Yos
Not: Ibby, pooky, Coron, STD, H_P, MoS
Why did you make this post? Looking back on your own posts, you gave reasons to vote Mathcam yourself...Coron wrote:I don't remember exactly what happened but I remember a lot of people were voting Mathcam and he was very suspicious.
Vote: Mathcam
people were continuing to say, "first, let's lynch pablito, then quagmire."Thok wrote:Where has MOS taken weak or nonconfrontal positions? Without examples, your statement is worthless.Quagmire wrote:1) what about all of the times in the game where he's taken weak and nonconfrontational positions?
2) we/i was called out before yesterday.
Where were you called out before yesterday? Certainly, you haven't been forced to post at all before yesterday.
From what I can tell you mean Uraj, not pablito.Quagmire wrote:people were continuing to say, "first, let's lynch pablito, then quagmire."
Coming from you, this argument isn't exactly particularly convincing. If anything, mentioning page 67 isn't a good thing for you; it gives a reason why pablito might have been nightkilled [since he was one of the people suggesting a Quagmire wagon in that time period].MoS had no input into this, whereas many people agreed with the people who wanted my head chopped to pieces. He then decided to take pages 68-71 to post nothing but one-liners with little relevance to the game.
What other bandwagons were likely to happen that day that MOS was preempting? Moreover, MOS wasn't the first person to vote you that day; I was!He then decided, with a post that I made about not voting for Thok because he liked NCAA hoops (that didn't intend at first to be a trap-post, but in retrospect, was), that I was scummy. He then decides to speak up and create a bandwagon before anyone else does; that post of mine, obviously, was scummy.
You do realize that MOS was voting you the entire time, right?Page 73 is also good evidence towards my cause; he spends little time talking about me, the most popular lynch target, because he doesn't want to be seen as a bandwagoner. At least, that's what I get out of it.
He then abruptly changes his mind and decides I'm scum after not really paying much attention to the arguments against me.
That was made in Sep 06. I honestly cannot remember what else I was thinking.spectrumvoid wrote:Note the timing of HP's post. It came directly after Uraj said he's still alive. That's lurkerish.
...
You know what? I'm going to go ahead andvote: Harry-PotterBecause he's so lurky he's just not helping.
dunno.Mastermind of Sin wrote:Coron:
Do you still think myself or Thok (replacing Ibby) are scum?Coron wrote:Vote: MoS
FoS: Ibby, Mathcam
Bagged 3 scum for the price of 1.
I had a gut instinct that you guys might be scum, then later you acted in a way that made me suspect that you were town clearly, probably another gut reaction. I'm allowed to change my mind right?Mastermind of Sin wrote:I feel like I've referenced this before, but you said this in thread a while back:
What caused you to move Ibby and myself to the "not scummy" list, without giving any reason to stop suspecting us?overview of who's scummy and who's not.
Scummy: Oberon, mathcam, Uraj, armlx
Middle: Spectrumvoid, fuldu, MMoD, MBL, Yos
Not: Ibby, pooky, Coron, STD, H_P, MoS
How do you feel about this list now? Of your "scummy" list, all four were protown. One of your "middle" list was scum, and all of your "not scummy" list is still living save Pooky. ThAdmiral and SV are the two remaining people from your "middle" list.
Yes, this was just after we lost a few pages of game in which mathcam did suspicious things, and where I voted mathcam.Mastermind of Sin wrote:Why did you make this post? Looking back on your own posts, you gave reasons to vote Mathcam yourself...Coron wrote:I don't remember exactly what happened but I remember a lot of people were voting Mathcam and he was very suspicious.
Vote: Mathcam
I dunno how I feel about the quag wagon, but it seems to me either way ThAdmiral is probably scum.Mastermind of Sin wrote:Who do you think is scum right now? Do you approve of the Quagmire-wagon?
How do we know we have 3 scum left? Do you know something we don't?ThAdmiral wrote: Quite simply if quagmire was town and there was a scum yet to vote they would just do it, right? (This would mean mafia win I believe)
That is unless all three mafia have already voted him, but I find that hard to believe since two of the people I most trust to be town (MoS, and STD) are ones voting.
you act like jumping on a bandwagon of someone who it looks like is going to die anyway makes you less likely to be scum. This is a reasonably common thing to be done by scum.ThAdmiral wrote:More likely is that quagmire is scum and the people not voting yet are his scum-partners (except me, cause I'm ready to drop the hammer).
We did have an SK, so either 4 or 5 Mafia and 1 SK is not that unlikely; it's more of the certainty with which you asserted there were 3 mafia.ThAdmiral wrote:I assume there would be 5 mafia due to the size of the game. Is that unreasonable?
On the people I think are scum and the people I think are town: these are based on my overall feeling after reading through the game.
