InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[shos]

In very general points:
1. there's 7 heads in that slot, averaging 14 posts each in the entire 5373 posts of this game so far(all together are less than 2% of the game, unlike how we expected chaos)
2. the (I assume?) single head that is active doesn't seem to actually do something when he's not being thrown fire at, and even then, well, it's crap.
3. was a leading wagon D1 which crumbled in favor of a wagon on me, who eventually was the CW for a different scum
4. seems to jump on the easy wagon of the time (BoP, Y&B, xof, don't remember if shroomish too)
5. has no townreads
...

I need to go but I'll be here in a few hours and if you need further convincing I'll try and do some work


pedit: a sec

[The Goat]

well, how will the answer to this question help you? all I can see is how it helps scum - they know if he had a shard, and if he did,

they know who NOW has the shard.

that is immensely stupid.

So...you're suggesting if someone is lynched and flips town, scum WOULDN'T target the person who hammered them

ANYWAY

, just in case they had a shard?

What I'm suggesting makes everyone accountable. There won't be any scum able to hide in "Oh, I didn't know she had a shard, and I hammered. Oops. I have a shard now."

Regarding the bolded, believe it or not, I've thought about this. if a town player has a shard, and they're about to be hammered, whats the better option? Relying on luck and hoping that whomever hammers is town, or getting someone widely viewed as town to do so, and hoping someone can protect said person?

[The Goat]

^EBWOP^

[The Goat]

Shos, I will absolutely move to Abomination again, as that read is actually a stronger scumread of mine than xofelf...but it didn't seem like it was going anywhere the first time I was on it.

[shos]

well, how will the answer to this question help you? all I can see is how it helps scum - they know if he had a shard, and if he did,

they know who NOW has the shard.

that is immensely stupid.

So...you're suggesting if someone is lynched and flips town, scum WOULDN'T target the person who hammered them

ANYWAY

, just in case they had a shard?

What I'm suggesting makes everyone accountable. There won't be any scum able to hide in "Oh, I didn't know she had a shard, and I hammered. Oops. I have a shard now."

Regarding the bolded, believe it or not, I've thought about this. if a town player has a shard, and they're about to be hammered, whats the better option? Relying on luck and hoping that whomever hammers is town, or getting someone widely viewed as town to do so, and hoping someone can protect said person?

uh. why would you automatically assume that scum will always target the hammerer? if you give them 100% reason to, they probably will, but if you don't, they might not..? I can only assume that finding the shard is not *their wincon*, it just *helps*?

the idea is that NOBODY says if they have the shard. evenif you hammer and you get a shard, you don't say anything about it. at all. ever. until you die and after that too. there's no benefit for town for this.

we

can

decide to have someone who is widely viewed as town do the hammer, yes. that's a good idea.

[The Goat]

How about xofelf doesn't answer that question but we pick who hammers anyway and if someone else hammers, we treat them as confirmed scum

This would actually work as well...and it was my hope to see this as the end of the discussion.

But I wanted to have the discussion.

[The Goat]

well, how will the answer to this question help you? all I can see is how it helps scum - they know if he had a shard, and if he did,

they know who NOW has the shard.

that is immensely stupid.

So...you're suggesting if someone is lynched and flips town, scum WOULDN'T target the person who hammered them

ANYWAY

, just in case they had a shard?

What I'm suggesting makes everyone accountable. There won't be any scum able to hide in "Oh, I didn't know she had a shard, and I hammered. Oops. I have a shard now."

Regarding the bolded, believe it or not, I've thought about this. if a town player has a shard, and they're about to be hammered, whats the better option? Relying on luck and hoping that whomever hammers is town, or getting someone widely viewed as town to do so, and hoping someone can protect said person?

uh. why would you automatically assume that scum will always target the hammerer? if you give them 100% reason to, they probably will, but if you don't, they might not..? I can only assume that finding the shard is not *their wincon*, it just *helps*?

the idea is that NOBODY says if they have the shard. evenif you hammer and you get a shard, you don't say anything about it.

at all. ever. until you die and after that too. there's no benefit for town for this.

we

can

decide to have someone who is widely viewed as town do the hammer, yes. that's a good idea.

I suspect that there will be a point at which this information needs to come out. I do not know so, but at some point I think we're going to know what's been going on.

[Egg]

That discussion may have led to her claiming she has or does not have a shard though. It's better to get to that end result before anything dumb happens. And the longer we wait to lynch, the easier it is for scum to come on and say "uhhh L-1, is our hammerer here? Fuck it. Deadline hammer". And now they could have a shard.

I still like Mala for the hammer.

[Nero Cain]

Why Mala?

[shos]

I agree to mala. been a townread since I remember, despite lately she lost activity, I can't quite point to a better choice

[beastcharizard]

I vote me. Considering I am unpoiaonable and I think that is how the kill works. With that I can just stack up on shards and not die. Giving town the most power. Over the shards.

[Egg]

I vote me. Considering I am unpoiaonable and I think that is how the kill works. With that I can just stack up on shards and not die. Giving town the most power. Over the shards.

^no

Nero, mala because she's town.

[Nero Cain]

but Molla is the one that needs the shard.

+ I still have doubts about Mala and Neil

[The Goat]

That discussion may have led to her claiming she has or does not have a shard though. It's better to get to that end result before anything dumb happens. And the longer we wait to lynch, the easier it is for scum to come on and say "uhhh L-1, is our hammerer here? Fuck it. Deadline hammer". And now they could have a shard.

I still like Mala for the hammer.

I'm pretty sure Xof does not have a shard. (InuYasha Wiki is my friend.)

Your suggestion and points are valid. I did want to see how people reacted to that suggestion, though.

I would prefer NS to hammer all lynches, but I can see the danger of putting all of our shards in one basket, so to speak.

[shos]

In the manga, does it make you more powerful with each shard or onlu with all?

[Egg]

Nero, do we know Molla is town?

Goat, so you were hoping she'd be caught fakeclaiming one when she was about to be lynched anyway?

[shos]

If there's anyone on the xof wagon who is voting him for any other reason than the fishy claim, please tell me.

my thought is that fishy claims will HAVE to sort themselves out through the game because of its size and length. see: Y&B, xof, etc.

[shos]

evenme, actually`

[BBmolla]

Look, let's just focus all our efforts in lynching xof, there's still more scum but dividing our efforts is killing us this game

What should I be doing tonight?

[ProHawk]

Why is Xof scum Molla?

[shos]

Molla, what did you claim?
and why is that a full counterclaim to xof in a 28p game?

[Cephrir]

No picture for you, I'm V/LA. See you Tuesday (probably).

VC 3.11

xofelf 10 (BBmolla, ActionDan, Kagami, Serene2, Squirrel Girl, Oversoul, Egg, Young and Beautiful, neil1113, Abomination)

shos 5 (BulbaFenix, Majiffy, Lord Mhork, notscience, ProHawk)

Abomination 3 (shos, Squirrel Girl, Nero Cain)

Young and Beautiful 2 (HighShroomish, Birds of Prey)

HighShroomish 1 (The Chamber of Kittens)

Not Voting 4 (beastcharizard, penguin_alien, xofelf, The Goat)

13 to lynch.

Deadline: August 20, 3 PM EST.

[Majiffy]

I can't even this game anymore.

Day fucking three and we haven't lynched obvscum Shos.

[Lord Mhork]

Ugh

what
the
hell
has happened to my shroom wagon

what the fuck guys?

I might be up for an Elf wagon, but i really want shroom roped.
If elf does flip scum;rope Y&B.

~Mala

Shroom is town though~
Why xof before YB?

[Lord Mhork]

Shit that was supposed to be copy pasted into my catchup post