Post 17 (game thread, mind, not his 17th post): After looking at it again, he didn't ask if Net was the cop; he asked if he WASN'T. Not that that changes much, though, because that still feels really fishy...roleguessing on the first page. (Though the fact that cop is a relatively common role makes it slightly less suspiscious...)
Posts 61 and 62: Reexamination on my part reveals not power role hunting, but more of a roleguessing spirit. See my feelings about 17. However, the posting of the Wiki entry on Net a mere minute later still doesn't sit well with me. Smells like attention diverson.
Post 69 - Rampage's comment about laying low struck me as odd. Also,
That's a pretty scummy assertion. And a funny one to make when Nocmen and Net were the only ones voting for you. If you wanna claim, then claim; if you don't, then don't mention your role.Post 69 - Rampage wrote:3. I think that voting for me, while not an unreasonable action given the circumstances, is a mistake. I firmly believe I will be useful if I stay connected to the server.
Post 88 - Now that I look at it, just going by Net's "someone watching over us" post didn't really make it seem like he was referring to himself as a doc, though it wasn't exactly "PAINFULLY clear." Also, I believe the possibility of him being doc wouldn't have been brought up if Rampage didn't roleguess right there.
Post 99 - The vote bargaining is EXTREMELY odd. I don't know whether I attribute this to town or scum, though, so I'll leave this point alone...for now.
Posts 135-137: Roleguessing again. The question posed to VanDamien: I feel it was a reasonable one at first, and that VanDamien gave a reasonable (albeit intriguing) answer. However, Rampage pushed for a simpler answer than the one given (false dilemma/excluded middle, anyone?)...post 143 does not allay any bad vibes from these posts.
I didn't catch much noteworthy in the arguments between VD, Rampage, and Nocmen that hasn't already been brought up. But the roleguessing, the bits of craplogic, and the vague hinting at his role are making me keep my vote on Rampage.
Notes I gathered on other players:
Nocmen: It appears to me that Nocmen is the one that actually started the rolehunt (post 66). My faith in his current doc claim is down a bit.
TonyMontana: He seems to be posting sparsely and cotributing little.
FoS: TonyMontana
I'd like to see what you think of everyone else so far.DYH: It's been a few days now; could you please answer my question?
