Mini 436 - Game over - Mafia wins with no casualties!

[Albert B. Rampage]

Shit! I was going to ask for a doc protect but the hammer fell while I was at work!

Good luck, town!!

Mod edit
Votecount:

Not voting: everybody, this day just started.

With 9 alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

[Paradoxombie]

Shit! I was going to ask for a doc protect but the hammer fell while I was at work!

Good luck, town!!

What? According to the Lawrencelot you ARE the doctor!

[ryan]

Shit! I was going to ask for a doc protect but the hammer fell while I was at work!

Good luck, town!!

What? According to the Lawrencelot you ARE the doctor!

I think he means he was going to protect himself

[StallingChamp]

I think he means he wanted to ask for Doc protect to make the scum less likely to kill him, in fear of a protected kill.

[Paradoxombie]

ah, that makes sense

Fortunately(or unfortunately), even if ABR had lived we'd have probably wasted alot of effort discussing him. Not that it has any bearing on the game at this point.

[vollkan]

I'd definitely say unfortunately. Aside from the fact that it would mean we would still have a doc, it would allow us a discussion point from which we could gain a better understanding, based upon how people behave to ABR and everything. Everything to this point has been pretty much centered around ABR.

[VanDamien]

Okay, Snichken disappeared after being under some suspicion, and Poison Ivy hasn't posted (at all?) since replacing. Looking wayyyy back though, Snichken still reads pretty scummy to me, but it would be nice to get some contribution from that role.

I hope ABR learns from this experiment that acting like scum when you're town screws us over.

vollkan's desire for approval before hammering Katy bugs me a bit right now.

Twice in the closing moments of day one, SC seems to be coaching ryan.

Those are my thoughts for now.

[StallingChamp]

2 questions for Damien:

- When do I seem to be coaching Ryan?

- Even if we were scumbuddies, why the heck wouldI be coaching him in-thread?

FoS: VD

[VanDamien]

Posts 421 & 425, 425 less so, but as it's the second time you quote him and try to bring out the vote, it reads a little differently, especially with Katy being town.

Why? You tell me. A slip, frustration, thought it was disguised?

[StallingChamp]

Why? You tell me. A slip, frustration, thought it was disguised?

-You may not discuss this game outside the topic, unless your role says you can.

If your role says you can talk outside this topic, you can do so during day

, night, via msn, aim, PM, or whatever you wish.

Emphasis mine.

[vollkan]

vollkan's desire for approval before hammering Katy bugs me a bit right now.

I just wanted a consensus, hence my post 427. I didn't want to rush it if people had a good reason not to. Miztef raised the issue of the suicidal role. I didn't think it was likely, but I wanted to wait to see if people felt otherwise.

Snitchkin, Tophat and PI really need to start posting.

Now,

VanDamien wrote:
Why? You tell me. A slip, frustration, thought it was disguised?

Rules wrote:
-You may not discuss this game outside the topic, unless your role says you can. If your role says you can talk outside this topic, you can do so during day, night, via msn, aim, PM, or whatever you wish.

Emphasis mine.

Interesting. VD accuses Stalling of coaching Ryan. Stalling rebuts by quoting the rules which state you can talk outside the thread IF YOUR ROLE PM SAYS SO (which he bolded). Stalling appears to be under the impression that the scum can talk outside the thread. I'd be very interested to know what gives him that idea.

[StallingChamp]

Scum can ALWAYS talk outside the game...The rule I quoted says that those roles that CAN talk outside the game (scum, masons, etc...) can do so any time, not just at Night. That's my interpratation of it, at least.

[vollkan]

My interpretation was that you could talk outside the game during day, msn, etc. if your PM specifically said so. Reading it again, I think I misinterpreted and your view seems more likely. In which case, my concerns regarding your interpretation are overcome.

[Lawrencelot]

Looking for a replacement for Poison Ivy, and prodding TopHat. Just to be clear: every role that may talk outside the thread can also do that during day.

[Lawrencelot]

TrustGossip replaces Poison Ivy, who replaced Snichkin. Thank you.

[VanDamien]

@StallingChamp: I never noticed the part about communicating during the day outside the thread also; so that suspicion is hereby withdrawn. I don't think you're foolish enough to coach in thread when you could have PMed him to vote.

So, PI has been replaced, welcome TrustGossip! But dies this mean TopHat has picked up the prod and continues to lurk?

[TrustGossip]

Reading over the thread soon.

First impressions: We're in deep s***.

[TrustGossip]

What did I replace into??!!!

Read everything.
Feel incredibly sick.

We have an SK.

Most probably scenario: 2 Mafia, 1 SK.

Still sick.

[vollkan]

Welcome Gossip.

We have an SK.

Most probably scenario: 2 Mafia, 1 SK.

Is there any particular reason for you thinking that there is an SK and 2 scum?

And I wonder when TopHat will join us...

[TrustGossip]

Two deaths.

I just think it'd be a little overtaxing on the town if there were two full mafia factions.

A vig wouldn't have killed dogmom, she was so overwhelmingly helpful. And I had thought everyone had come to some sort of agreement to let albert get to Day 2 at the least.

[Miztef]

Two deaths.

I just think it'd be a little overtaxing on the town if there were two full mafia factions.

A vig wouldn't have killed dogmom, she was so overwhelmingly helpful. And I had thought everyone had come to some sort of agreement to let albert get to Day 2 at the least.

It's possible the vig killed albert because he/she was against albert right from the start and believed he was lieing. As stated eariler in the thread, the safest way to kill albert is at night, and maybe the vig felt this was his/her chance.

I personally don't see why an SK would want to kill Albert, maybe an SK would kill DogMom though, and the mafia killed albert.

[ryan]

Two deaths.

I just think it'd be a little overtaxing on the town if there were two full mafia factions.

A vig wouldn't have killed dogmom, she was so overwhelmingly helpful. And I had thought everyone had come to some sort of agreement to let albert get to Day 2 at the least.

It's possible the vig killed albert because he/she was against albert right from the start and believed he was lieing. As stated eariler in the thread, the safest way to kill albert is at night, and maybe the vig felt this was his/her chance.

I personally don't see why an SK would want to kill Albert, maybe an SK would kill DogMom though, and the mafia killed albert.

Very good points. DogMom was a big loss to the rest of us as she brought up good questions/points and we really need that kind of discussion again

[StallingChamp]

Two deaths.

I just think it'd be a little overtaxing on the town if there were two full mafia factions.

A vig wouldn't have killed dogmom, she was so overwhelmingly helpful. And I had thought everyone had come to some sort of agreement to let albert get to Day 2 at the least.

From my experience, the "Standard" set-up, is 3M/1SK/8T.

[vollkan]

From my experience, the "Standard" set-up, is 3M/1SK/8T.

Then how come DogMom, for instance, said it was reasonable to assume that we had 9 town (7 now) and that there were 3 scum?

[TrustGossip]

From my experience, the "Standard" set-up, is 3M/1SK/8T.

Then how come DogMom, for instance, said it was reasonable to assume that we had 9 town (7 now) and that there were 3 scum?

I'm pretty sure she wanted to make the numbers easier. If she factored in an SK into the mix, it would have led to much more pessimistic results.