InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Majiffy]

Xof's claim was over 2000 posts ago, why are you just now questioning the thematic congruence?

Yes. What part of "I'm not familiar with the theme" is unclear?

Again: I saw the question posed. I did not see an answer. I wanted one.

Were you more familiar with the theme 2000 posts ago?

Stop dodging the question.

I just want to say that seeing the phrase "thematic congruence" in a mafia game made my day.

I do what I can.

[Moogle Dance Troupe]

The thematic incongruence of xof's claim is that foxfire as an investigative ability is ridiculous. It's also crazy that shippo would be an investigator at all.

The play incongruence is that it is not a town mindset that commutes in the situation she was in. She should have had no fear of an NK (or be happy to be NKed given the suspicion on her slot). If she really believed she was a super likely NK, she'd also have expected protection and proceeded to do something useful. It would be reasonable maybe to hold back on using a really good ability for fear of a roleblock, but then she'd have done something that would have indicated to her that she was blocked (which would also have given us more information on Y&B).

[The Goat]

Xof's claim was over 2000 posts ago, why are you just now questioning the thematic congruence?

Yes. What part of "I'm not familiar with the theme" is unclear?

Again: I saw the question posed. I did not see an answer. I wanted one.

Were you more familiar with the theme 2000 posts ago?

Stop dodging the question.

I just want to say that seeing the phrase "thematic congruence" in a mafia game made my day.

I do what I can.

I'm not dodging any questions. Stop misrepresenting what I'm doing.

I was not familiar with the theme 10 minutes ago, 200 posts ago, 2000 posts ago, when I was a teenager, or a toddler, or an embryo. How is that even remotely related to me wanting to see an answer to a question that someone else asked?

[The Goat]

Oh.

I misread the first question above. Apparently multiple times. I read it as "Xof's claim was over 2000 posts ago, but you're just now questioning the thematic congruence?"

[The Goat]

More appropriate answer: I'm questioning it now because I saw BBMolla's post, and it made me think about it further, and ask about it. When I saw xof's claim, it seemed a little...disjointed...but I didn't really give it a whole lot of thought as to whether it made sense as a town role...because I have no familiarity with the theme.

[Majiffy]

I'm not dodging any questions. Stop misrepresenting what I'm doing.

I was not familiar with the theme 10 minutes ago, 200 posts ago, 2000 posts ago, when I was a teenager, or a toddler, or an embryo. How is that even remotely related to me wanting to see an answer to a question that someone else asked?

It still doesn't compute that the claim was 2000 posts ago and you had no questions about it

then.

So yes, you are dodging. And no, I'm not misrepresenting anything.

Oh.

I misread the first question above. Apparently multiple times. I read it as "Xof's claim was over 2000 posts ago, but you're just now questioning the thematic congruence?"

Even if you read it that way, you dodged the question...

Which you still aren't answering, by the way.

p-edit need another post for this one.

[The Goat]

I'm not dodging any questions. Stop misrepresenting what I'm doing.

I was not familiar with the theme 10 minutes ago, 200 posts ago, 2000 posts ago, when I was a teenager, or a toddler, or an embryo. How is that even remotely related to me wanting to see an answer to a question that someone else asked?

It still doesn't compute that the claim was 2000 posts ago and you had no questions about it

then.

So yes, you are dodging. And no, I'm not misrepresenting anything.

Oh.

I misread the first question above. Apparently multiple times. I read it as "Xof's claim was over 2000 posts ago, but you're just now questioning the thematic congruence?"

Even if you read it that way, you dodged the question...

Which you still aren't answering, by the way.

p-edit need another post for this one.

I have no idea why I didn't question it then. Would you like me to make something up for you?

[Majiffy]

More appropriate answer: I'm questioning it now because I saw BBMolla's post, and it made me think about it further, and ask about it. When I saw xof's claim, it seemed a little...disjointed...but I didn't really give it a whole lot of thought as to whether it made sense as a town role...because I have no familiarity with the theme.

So your storyline is such:

Xof makes a claim.
You don't question the thematic congruence.
2000 posts later, Molla makes a not-entirely-serious post regarding the town being full of JOATs.
You make a rolefishy post about if JOATs even fit the theme.
I ask why.
You mention "a couple of JOAT claims"
You would like to know, specifically, if Xof's claim fits the theme.

The claim from 2000 posts ago.

No.

[Majiffy]

I have no idea why I didn't question it then. Would you like me to make something up for you?

No, you're scum, it's ok.

[Majiffy]

Claims summary for those who don't read:

MDT: Abi (D)- Ninja enabler/ tracker miller (puppet). Additional mystery power. Can vanillaize self.
Jiffy: Ryujin (D)- Ninja enabler/ tracker miller (puppet)
NS: Kohaku (H)- Ninja enabler/ tracker miller (puppet)
Xofelf: Shippo (D)- 9-ability JoAT with protective and investigative abilities. One named "Foxfire" that investigates undead. Claims commuted N1.
BBMolla: Unknown- Something that CCs xof
shos: Inuyasha (D)- Self-watching race detector. "Empathic Vig." Claims to have visited jiffy, learned that jiffy is a demon.
Y&B: Jijenji (D)- Friendly neighbor, claims visited always (blocked)
Lemniscate: Jakotsu (U)- scum non-consecutive ninja. Claimed Kocho (U)- Mason.
BoP: Hakudoshi (D)- Ascetic
AIR: Ryukotsusei (D)- Vanilla
ActionDan: Unknown- Something that implies multiball and references the band of seven somehow.

Hey does a VT fit the theme?

What about a ninja?

Holy shit are there friendly neighbors in the show?

Why are you only questioning the JOAT, Goat?

[The Goat]

I have no idea why I didn't question it then. Would you like me to make something up for you?

No, you're scum, it's ok.

I can't tell if you're trying to badger me for the sake of badgering me, or if you're genuinely being a jackass.

[The Goat]

Claims summary for those who don't read:

MDT: Abi (D)- Ninja enabler/ tracker miller (puppet). Additional mystery power. Can vanillaize self.
Jiffy: Ryujin (D)- Ninja enabler/ tracker miller (puppet)
NS: Kohaku (H)- Ninja enabler/ tracker miller (puppet)
Xofelf: Shippo (D)- 9-ability JoAT with protective and investigative abilities. One named "Foxfire" that investigates undead. Claims commuted N1.
BBMolla: Unknown- Something that CCs xof
shos: Inuyasha (D)- Self-watching race detector. "Empathic Vig." Claims to have visited jiffy, learned that jiffy is a demon.
Y&B: Jijenji (D)- Friendly neighbor, claims visited always (blocked)
Lemniscate: Jakotsu (U)- scum non-consecutive ninja. Claimed Kocho (U)- Mason.
BoP: Hakudoshi (D)- Ascetic
AIR: Ryukotsusei (D)- Vanilla
ActionDan: Unknown- Something that implies multiball and references the band of seven somehow.

Hey does a VT fit the theme?

What about a ninja?

Holy shit are there friendly neighbors in the show?

Why are you only questioning the JOAT, Goat?

Because I saw BBMollas post about it, searched for an answer, and didn't find one. I did not read it as non-serious.

That's really all I have for you.

If you'd like to go more in-depth about the friendly neighbors and ninja, that'll be awesome.

Regarding the VT part, your sarcasm is weak and needs polishing.

Would you also like to discuss the aforementioned proposition that not all of the demon puppets are town, or would you like that conversation to disappear amongst a slew of silly questions about minutia?

[Majiffy]

I've already addressed that it makes no sense for a puppet to be scum.

Whether all the claims are legitimate is a different story.

[The Goat]

I've already addressed that it makes no sense for a puppet to be scum.

Is it okay with you if I go try to take a look at it? Or did it happen too many posts ago?

[Majiffy]

Flail harder.

[The Goat]

Flail harder.

You misspelled "antagonize."

[The Goat]

All this aside, I'm sticking with one of my original gut scum reads.

[xofelf]

The thematic incongruence of xof's claim is that foxfire as an investigative ability is ridiculous. It's also crazy that shippo would be an investigator at all.

The play incongruence is that it is not a town mindset that commutes in the situation she was in. She should have had no fear of an NK (or be happy to be NKed given the suspicion on her slot). If she really believed she was a super likely NK, she'd also have expected protection and proceeded to do something useful. It would be reasonable maybe to hold back on using a really good ability for fear of a roleblock, but then she'd have done something that would have indicated to her that she was blocked (which would also have given us more information on Y&B).

Hey, I didn't write my role. If you think that shit is ridiculous, talk to Ceph about it. It's all part of my role.
And how is me dying helpful to the town? And why on earth would i be happy to do it? I much prefer to be in the game than out of it thank you very much. And no, with the wagon that happened on me D1, I was NOT expecting anyone to protect me. I explained the reasons I commuted, but I guess you don't think that's good enough? Sorry I'm not playing my role the way YOU would.

[The Goat]

The thematic incongruence of xof's claim is that foxfire as an investigative ability is ridiculous. It's also crazy that shippo would be an investigator at all.

The play incongruence is that it is not a town mindset that commutes in the situation she was in. She should have had no fear of an NK (or be happy to be NKed given the suspicion on her slot). If she really believed she was a super likely NK, she'd also have expected protection and proceeded to do something useful. It would be reasonable maybe to hold back on using a really good ability for fear of a roleblock, but then she'd have done something that would have indicated to her that she was blocked (which would also have given us more information on Y&B).

Hey, I didn't write my role. If you think that shit is ridiculous, talk to Ceph about it. It's all part of my role.
And how is me dying helpful to the town? And why on earth would i be happy to do it? I much prefer to be in the game than out of it thank you very much. And no, with the wagon that happened on me D1, I was NOT expecting anyone to protect me. I explained the reasons I commuted, but I guess you don't think that's good enough? Sorry I'm not playing my role the way YOU would.

What's utterly terrifying to me is that I was just in a Werewolf game as the head BG, (claiming an Indy role) and responded to someone with "Hey, if you don't like the way something is worded in my role, talk to the mod."

It didn't work out well.

[Birds of Prey]

Hey guys, there's 3 days left.

Noted that Goat is not voting and his pattern.


Reads please Goat.

[Moogle Dance Troupe]

Why did you expect a night kill, but did not expect protection?

[ActionDan]

I think as town with being suspected yesterday you would have an awareness that there would be certain expectations town would have of you which, if up to snuff, you'd attempt to fulfill or face a threat worse than a NK; i.e. getting lynched.

[Birds of Prey]

Majiffy, I am seeing something different with Goat. They are unlikely to be lynched today though. I need to discuss what I saw with PV what I saw. Just in case I die, a crumb for you/Mala. Read Goat as if I subbed in from Day 5 or later. Do my first usual step.

You should see what I see.

[Birds of Prey]

Majiffy, if you do not get what I am saying, I am sure Mala should get it. Just keep quiet till tomorrow as I am not sure how damning it is until I talk w PV.

[The Goat]

Hey guys, there's 3 days left.

Noted that Goat is not voting and his pattern.


Reads please Goat.

Pretty sure I'm voting Mist. (Am I not voting for Mist?) I believe that is the way to go.

I am currently town reading Majiffy, shos, Y&B, Always.
I do not understand NS's hostility (as I perceive it). It's making me think he is chainsawing.
I am believing xofelf less and less.

I think some wonderful data will be available from the D1 and D2 wagons.