Mini #406, Animaniacs! Water Tower Explosion! [Over]

[JDodge]

I think it's possible.

I just don't think it's that likely of a situation.

[now a ranger]

Who do you think is scum then?

[now a ranger]

that question is directed to everyone.

How about we just lynch Thesp and see? lol

[JDodge]

Who do you think is scum then?

Quite frankly, I'm unsure. For some reason, I keep thinking that Foolster is suspicious, but I need to do a reread before I can say for sure.

[now a ranger]

Well, I guess I'll wait for Ether's replacement and maybe Fritzler's.


We seriously need a replacement for Ether since she is supposed to claim first. I didn't see any news of anyone seeking a replacement in 406 Animaniacs.

[petroleumjelly]

They're Ani-mani,
Totally insane-y,
Presidential Campaign-y:

ANIMANIACS!

These are the Facts:

Fuldu – 1 – VitaminR
JDodge – 1 – Ether
Thesp – 1 – now a ranger

With

8

alive, it takes

5

to lynch!

Not Voting – 5 – Foolster41, Fritzler, Fuldu, JDodge, Thesp

As I

previously

mentioned, I have prodded Ether. Seeing as I am

scum-chatter

, I know she posts when she can, and I know she's been having internet troubles. I was trying to hold off on replacing her, and I was going to give her a week deadline which ended today. I am currently searching for a replacement.

[petroleumjelly]

blahgo replaces Ether, effective immediately.

[Foolster41]

Nowaranger: The problem is Thesp voiced concerned about SJ FIRST and pointed out a leginitmate reason to be suspcious. You don't just bring up info on your scum buddy and EXPECT it not to lead to preasure or ultimatly a lynch. This I think is the biggest problem with your case thus far.

The only 3 people I think can be scum are Ether, JDodge and VitaminR. I have maybe a slightly higher tell on VitamanR, but I don't have any definite reasons, just gut which I admit doesn't count for much.

[Thesp]

Welcome, blahgo!

Claim human/not-human. Now. Read thread later.

[now a ranger]

I second the claim request.

[now a ranger]

*poke*

[Thesp]

Blahgo?

[petroleumjelly]

...

<- Gives a deadpan, nonplussed stare.

Prods are going out. It seems like I have to give another prod for this game to somebody every other day. Deadline imminent.

[Foolster41]

I got my prod, but mainly we are waiting for (ironicly named) Blahgo.

[VitaminR]

Heh.

I'm here.

[now a ranger]

Me too. I'm using dial-up with my labtop in an apartment at the moment.

[Fuldu]

I'm here. However, I largely won't be for most of the remainder of the holiday weekend. I'll check in as I can.

[JDodge]

I'm here.

[now a ranger]

*poke again, still waiting for blahgo.....*

[Foolster41]

I want to hear from Bhago too, so I'm not saying we should rush to do anything before gthen, but while we're waiting might as well discuss ideas.

The way I ssee it, because of claiming there are only 4 people who could be scum:
Ether, JDodge, VitaminR and myself. I have a role that I believe will be provable enough to clear me (and would do so at the begining before this plan would take effect naterualy.) .

Thst leaves 3. By my calculations if we line up each one and lynch them in a row (allowing a claim from them to gather information, lynching if they refuse) we will have 7 people at the end even if they make a kill every ngiht and the last on is the scum.

So, discuss thoughts on this idea. I don't see how at this point we can loose unless the mod has screwed us and one of the people who claimed is scum.

[now a ranger]

I think maybe Fritzler or Fuldu or both lying about their role is probably one way I think of at the moment that could mean that none of those people you mentioned could be scum.

[Fuldu]

Thst leaves 3. By my calculations if we line up each one and lynch them in a row (allowing a claim from them to gather information, lynching if they refuse) we will have 7 people at the end even if they make a kill every ngiht and the last on is the scum.

I think your calculations are seriously off-base. For one thing, there are only eight people alive right now, so even if no kills were made, the first two lynches would bring us down to six.

Here's what I think you're suggesting:

Lynch A (seven alive)
Night kill (six alive)
Lynch B (five alive)
Night kill (four alive)
Lynch C

That's all fine, provided no one has lied about anything. But imagine, for example, that Thesp has lied about his gender. This wouldn't in any way be the mod screwing us (and frankly, I'm not quite sure what you meant by that), but it would mean that it's possible that Thesp would be scum still alive at the end of the process you've described (and with a successful night kill, would win). Because of the way we're handling gender/human claims, the same could be true for either Fritzler or myself (which is why I remain somewhat personally wary of not proving myself now, while I can).

[Foolster41]

I don't think I am so far off base.

NOR: One question. Is there a good reason WHY we should NOT believe Fritzler or Fuldu, after the information they provided/will provide? Can't their abilities be proven beyond doubt now? That was what I mean by the mod screwing us, since by all appearances they look like they are not scum, or at least put themselves where thje lie will find them out, but the mod could be fooling us.

FULDU:
Your count is correct, but still 6 alive at the end isn't bad.
Why did you give Thesp as an example of all people? Do you seriously believe that Thesp could be lying? this seems like covered ground already.

I agree that you should prove yourself before the day's over, but that's only me.

[now a ranger]

Foolster, I just don't think anyone here should think that one of those people you mentioned (you, Fuldu, Blahgo, and VitaminR) is scum for sure. There could easily be a person lying in this situation.

[now a ranger]

Anyone, including Thesp, Fritzler, and Fuldu.

And JDodge I think was mentioned as a person who needs to claim I think.