Ika, Unsight, Honey Bee, Grib, Stigmata, Citrus and I are all town, kiddies. Look outside of that group.
I was going to say, let's solve this game in record time. But then days are 2 weeks so no records to break here. I'm going to continue to diverge from your read on Stigmata for now.
Citrus wrote:Stigmata, care to reveal who you are? You don't have to, but the fact that you voted for 'Citrus' over 'MadCitrus' means you've played with me before, since on all other forums I'm 'Citrus'.
I'm
Delphine
, which should give you some needed context. Anyway:
In post 126, Stigmata wrote:Why? (Not disagreeing that ika's town, but I don't understand how that makes Citrus town)
Your first couple of posts were (obviously) null to me and basically content-less, so her townreading you as strongly as she was, was what stuck out to me in her reads list. I was curious whether she had a good reason for doing so. Firstly because it helps me read you, and secondly because I've only played with fontisian on IRC; I'm not particularly good at reading her, but one way I've caught her before is that she'll put her buddies in her townpile on a really weak basis and will just keep saying that they're town over and over again until it sticks.
In post 63, Atum wrote:I'm more curious as to why font's first post was basically her opening from the last Witchhunt, though less abrupt and more conciliatory. I'm also still don't understand fully why town would volunteer information to the scum team, which has more in the first place.
On the other hand at least there's something interesting to talk about pre-game.
Fontisian, is there a reason you're interested in Rubicon's post along the same lines but not Atum's #63?
Doubt-casting Fontisian
I did phrase that kinda weird (obv she had a reason and I wanted to know what it was) but am not really sure how that's doubt-casting, just wanted to get a better read on her.
Spoiler: (3)
Citrus wrote:Hmm What're you trying to do here fontisian eh?
? Explain.
Not particularly impressed by your 'catch-up.'[/quote]
No thanks. That was addressed to Fontisian and I'll explain when she asks me to (or I change my mind).
In post 199, Stigmata wrote:I don't really have anything to add that's not in my iso; he's pretty boring and UTR thus far. I guess as far as #183, I'm not sure what kind of answers he was looking for about meta? Seems too vague to be productive.
48 hours into the game (including pre-game), sorry I have IRL stuff during the weekend (note: not sorry). I'm waiting on more responses to my meta question before I explain why thanks.[/quote]
Okay, this is frustrating to me since both those questions kinda read to me as empty posting (at least out of context) but I'm not scumreading you for doing so (I believe that you believe it's pro-town for you to not.) I don't think you should have to be sorry for being busy but I don't think it's unreasonable for me to have pressure voted you here, either, as I'd like to get you out of my null-slight-scum pile since I think I can p quickly?
Spoiler: (4)
In post 197, Stigmata wrote:I asked Grib because he made an off-handed post implying he thought there were 4 scum in this game; there were 4 scum in the Witchhunt game linked, but there are 3 in this one. Does anyone who was in both games think he'd have made that post as scum here?
VOTE: Citrus
Wrong forum bro, I'm madcitrus here. Why don't you make up your mind yourself? Or would you like us all to come to a consensus and then you can sheep it for towncred?[/quote]
I'm townreading him for it due to to not expecting faking a townslip to be in his scum repertoire, but there are other people in this thread that would know that better than I would. I'm also self-aware of the fact that I tend to townread people that I am emotionally attached to outside of the game with all things being equal, so.[/quote]
HIIIII!!
Hmm, your reveal makes me more and less intrigued by your opening - something did feel off about the amount of focus I was getting.
1) They were indeed content-less. Wanna know why? Because scum can coordinate during pre-game.
2) The phrasing felt like doubt casting -> "is there a reason...but not" is subtly saying her lines of reasoning are flawed, like I-am-asking-for-a-reason-because-here's-proof-you-probably-don't-have-one.
3) It felt a lot more like a "ooh let's lynch this guy for being inactive at the beginning" rather than a "pressure him to develop my read." But that came from the odd focus, which makes sense as I said above.
4) Bringing up something like that is extremely characteristic of you as any alignment from what I can remember of IRC, the testing the waters part was what stuck out to me. But ok.
You said your reason for voting fontisian was different from mine in Post 196. What is it?
Also, what about MadCitrus makes him scummy? Did you just want to make him orange?
I somewhat address my vote on fontisian pre-game but I will elaborate. Like I said before, the first thing is her opening to this game matching the linked WH, with a different tone and more explanation up front. She explained this as circumstances present in the beginning of that game and looking back I see that this appears to be a fairly standard opening. Still rubbed me wrong. The bigger issue now is that her reaction to me calling her scum is off. And when she got called on it (partially) the reason was garbage.
As for Citrus, for starters his town list is ugh. His clear on Unsight makes since if she's town, but at the same time scum GD is also unlikely to be too pleased to be pressed for a role claim so early on. The fontisian explanation has merit though. One issue with Citrus is the on-going Stigmata thing, especially since he's been performing some of the same behavior, i.e. doubtcasting. Plus he's pointing out the behavior but not really saying who he thinks is or is not scum. It feels like he's forcefully copying town play. But tone-wise his D1 posts have been much more aligned with the scum FM game I've played with him than the town one.
Not sure what you mean with this question. Someone asked whether Grib would purposefully 'confuse' the setup in a post to make it appear as though he didn't know the number of Devils. That I wasn't sure about. The second quote from my readlist is just my read, largely based on meta, though I can't recall a Grib scum game.
Hi ABR!
