Mini 436 - Game over - Mafia wins with no casualties!

[Albert B. Rampage]

HurriKaty, please make an adequate post of what you think is best to do now

Mod edit
Votecount:
Albert B. Rampage 2 (Paradoxombie, ryan)
Paradoxombie 2 (vollkan, StallingChamp)
Poison Ivy 1 (Miztef)
StallingChamp 1 (Poison Ivy)
ryan 1 (Albert B. Rampage)
Hurrikaty 1 (DeathSauce)

Not voting 4: DogMom, Tophat, VanDamien, Hurrikaty

With 12 alive it takes 7 votes to lynch.

There will be a deadline for D1: the 3rd of June. The number of votes needed for a lynch is still the same.

[Miztef]

This is a doozy for sure. However, it is good to know that even at worst possible case, if we lynch albert today, we wont auto lose.

And after all that, I say waiting until tommorow to *maybe* lynch albert is our best bet. I'm sticking with Ivy until he/she posts.

[StallingChamp]

But DogMom, are you willing to let him coast until endgame because he might have made a powerful and scary claim?

[Albert B. Rampage]

In light of DogMom's analysis, I feel the need to repeat this:

If I were scum, I wouldn't have any powers, because I would never claim.

So if I'm lying scum, your safe to lynch me day2 without consequences.

If I am what I say I am, then lynching Ryan or Parax would be the safest choice.

What I meant here is that if I was scum, I would be lying. Hence if I am confirmed scum by a cop, let out some major slip, etc. there will be no consequences to lynching me.

But if I am who I am, or who I say I am rather (its confusing, bear with me), then there will be massive ramifications to lynching me.

That's why giving the time for a cop investigation, more discussion, the possibility of another scum turning up is the best town move in my own humble opinion.

If you fail to see the logic I'm using, please feel free to reply to this - I really hope you do.

[ryan]

So in your opinion sending me or Paradoxombie to die is the best move for the town? Even if Paradoxombie is the cop (which isn't out of the question) and what if I'm the cop? OR what if this game doesn't have a cop? Than what ABR? Than we give you all the power and that my friend is something I'm not willing to do. The power should go to the rest of us townies not one player.

[Albert B. Rampage]

No, if the town runs out of options, then I'll eventually be killed.

But for now there is plenty that can help stall for time before my lynching, including finding other scum and cop investigations.

It seems, ryan, that you have given up on finding other possible mafia. Very scummy behavior.

[ryan]

I've kept my finger firmly pointed at you ABR, just waiting for you to slip up again and show the rest of the game that you are scum. As to who are your partners........I'm starting to wonder if Paradoxombie could be one of your scum boys.

[vollkan]

This is a doozy for sure. However, it is good to know that even at worst possible case, if we lynch albert today, we wont auto lose.

Doozy is a good way of putting it. DogMom really outdid my feeble attempt at numbers analysis. I think waiting for Ivy is our best bet, since it will give us more information in order to potentially make a more informed lynch today.

Also, has DogMom's wall of numbers altered the stance of the "Lynch ABR today" people?

[Lawrencelot]

I'm going to give you guys a deadline, but don't worry, it's not a tight one. Deadline for Day1 is now June 3rd. There are still 7 votes needed for a lynch or no lynch. If this amount is not reached before the deadline, no lynch will occur.

[StallingChamp]

Meh, with a deadline looming, I think we might as well pressure a lurker.

Vote: Poison Ivy

[ryan]

It would also be nice to hear from the people not voting

[DogMom]

Heh. At least I'm entertaining. I hope.
Anyway, I'm in favor of letting ABR slide

tonight

. If he's not lying, then we've managed to take away any "oops factor" we had. Hopefully our cop, should we have one, can investigate him tonight and see what's what, so at least someone will have better info to work with.

My take on it is: either way, we're

much

better off not lynching ABR today. If he's not lying, then lynching him would be lynching a townie. If he

is

lying, well, we can't get all the scum tonight anyway, so let's see if we can find scum elsewhere for now, shall we?

[VanDamien]

I must say I'm quite satisfied of the turn of events.

If I were you, I wouldnt be satisfied yet.

From what I've gathered, 3 people still want you dead, and from what I remember, thats not a good thing when you're playing mafia.

*obvious statement*

Which means you are still refusing to contribute. Popping in to ask for someone else to give you a summary and perhaps guide you into popular opinion, and further active lurking by posting again with as you call it, an obvious statement, seems very scummy to me.

I still don't believe Al, and hate that our cop could have to claim day 2 after only one investigation. I reiterate my willingness to hammer.

Until then

Vote: Hurrikaty

as its the next best lead.

[StallingChamp]

Yeah, apon further review, HurriKaty is actually lurking, Ivy could have forgotten about the game.

Unvote, Vote: HurriKaty

, but

IGMEOY Ivy

[DogMom]

Ooohhhhh KAAAAAATYYYYYYYYY....
Where aaaaaaarrrrrreeee yooouuuuuuuu????

More wordy stuff from

moi

.
Katy's posts, to date:

Random vote for DeathSauce because DeathSauce sounds kinda deadly.
"the only way to get information this early is by random bandwagoning"
Says she's been lurking, tends to lurk day 1 due to not having anything to say, points out her name is HurriKaty
Followup
Can't understand how ABR will be "the last one laughing" if we lynch him.

My thought: interesting; she doesn't use the word "lynch", she uses the word "kill". Townies lynch, Mafia kills. I've seen that slip up scum before, and led to a successful scumlynch in a game.

Very

weak, though.

Unvotes DeathSauce, says she has to get her act together
Forgot about MafiaScum, requests a one-post summary of the entire day
Responding to DeathSauce's post
The "obvious statement" post.

So. That's it. 9 posts in 17 days.
I think that sounds like lurking to me.

Vote: HurriKaty

Subject to removal should she start posting, of course.

[HurriKaty]

Wow, I find it hilarious that you've all voted me because I dont post, and am "lurking" when I've posted more in the past few days than I have in the whole game.

I wasnt lurking early on. I was just plain not paying attention.

I am RIGHT HERE. I've been right here for the past few pages. This would have been really nice, oh, say last week when I wasnt paying attention, but when you do it now that I am, its really frustrating.

I cant believe this is happening again. I'm always damned if I do, damned if I dont in these things.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote, vote: HurriKaty

Subject to removal should she start posting something

useful

, of course.

[Miztef]

I'm not going to vote katy, but I do agree that more productivity is needed from her. As DogMom pointed out, she has posted very little content throughout the game.

I'm still waiting to hear from Ivy though, until something changes that (ivy posts, is replaced, reason for not posting explained) I will keep my vote on Ivy.

[DogMom]

Wow, I find it hilarious that you've all voted me because I dont post, and am "lurking" when I've posted more in the past few days than I have in the whole game.

I wasnt lurking early on. I was just plain not paying attention.

I am RIGHT HERE. I've been right here for the past few pages. This would have been really nice, oh, say last week when I wasnt paying attention, but when you do it now that I am, its really frustrating.

I cant believe this is happening again. I'm always damned if I do, damned if I dont in these things.

Honestly, please post something useful / game-related. I'll give you "not paying attention" a week ago. Now that you're "RIGHT HERE" and have been "for the past few pages", can you read the posts, and post some analysis? Please?
Heck, I just subbed in 5 days ago and I had time to read the thread, and do at least

some

analysis.

[DeathSauce]

An appeal to emotion as a reaction to a lurking charge? That is just not an appropriate response.

My initial vote was just to try to get you to participate, but even though you've "posted more in the past few days", you haven't added anything of substance.

[ryan]

A few questions as I was reading back through the past few pages.

HurriKaty. It seems as though you have vaulted into the lead when it comes to votes but have yet to vote anyone, who do you think deserves to go on Day #1?

Albert B. Rampage: You seemed to be pretty hot on the lynch Para and now have kinda switched to HurriKaty, do you believe that Para and HurriKaty are scum together?

Miztef: What would the difference (in your opinion) be on Poison Ivy's activity compared to HurriKaty's? I say that because HurriKaty seems to be getting the brunt of the vote while Poison Ivy has yet to post anything of substance either.

[Miztef]

@ryan: My vote on Ivy is not really because I think he/she is scum, it is because I want some content from Ivy before I lynch someone.

Snichkin was the first person really suspected in this game, and I don't think letting Ivy lurk the entire D1 is of any help to the town. I dislike Hurrikaty's lurking, but I'm getting the feeling she will post content soon anyway, I don't feel there is a need to pressure her more at this time.

[DeathSauce]

Hurrikitty has said little to add to the contributions, but meh, I don't think she's lurking.

I understand your reasoning behind voting katy, but I'm not jumping on that bandwagon yet.

I do not agree with tophat's post. It is possible that ryan/hurrikaty are mafia, but your evidence does not "confirm" it.

I severly dislike tophat's post about hurrikaty and you being mafia

I don't like hurrikaty's lack of posts, but I'm not gonna lynch her over it at this time at least.

Hurrikaty is 'ok' in my books

I dislike Hurrikaty's lurking, but I'm getting the feeling she will post content soon anyway, I don't feel there is a need to pressure her more at this time.

Miztef, you spend an

awful

lot of energy in defending Hurrikaty. Any particular reason for that?

[StallingChamp]

Unvote, Vote: DeathSauce

Way to take all of that way out of context!

[DeathSauce]

Okay, explain how any of those statements is "out of context"?