[I started typing this 10 pages ago, so there's a chance this post will seem a little time-displaced
]
Of the possible lynch candidates, from the X-ternals hood I think Eek would indeed be the best choice, given the objectives and info. I have town reads on both Titus and Brian and I feel good in general about Feu and bork. As for the Outcasts, I have a town read on Rubik and a positive impression on Rogue, Pere is absent and that leaves Toogeloo and Cloud9.
After going through Toogeloo's ISO, I don't think I'd mind his lynch. I can't really tell what it is but there's something about him that makes me lean scum, I think it's the tone of his posts and his approach. The spoiler wall feels odd, as if he's trying to fit in. Then there's this post:
In post 665, Toogeloo wrote:Are we even playing Mafia anymore? If we policy lynch, we are putting all our faith in power roles winning the game for us and relying very little on our abilities to hunt scum.
By conceding a PL, all we've done is state that no one gives a flying fuck to figure out scum, scum are more than welcome to jump aboard without reason, and we'll just try to let our Night Actions give us direction down the road.
In post 655, Ultimate Life Form wrote:Also if this posting rate continues at this speed tomorrow I will have to slow down my posting rate cause I will have to check all the shit on the computer.
This is part of the reason I stopped playing big games. Starting on a Saturday morning hurts as well. Weekends are my worst times to get involved in Mafia.
Seriously? Is this a roll over and die post, or an appeal to emotion? I didn't want your lynch today, but your attitude towards being lynched feels so numb, so you're either town trying to do what you (stupidly) think is the right thing to do even though there is plenty of time still to change opinion, or you are making a shoulder shrug post hoping that it appeals to people that you are doing what I just formerly posted.
Where's your fight?
The first and second paragraphs verge on those "look at me, I'm town" kind of posts. Then I don't like his reaction to Eek's self-vote. It's like he's trying to turn something that actually looks good into something bad. And the wording "I didn't want to lynch you today but... this makes me want to lynch you". He doesn't say exactly that but it is implied that he changed his mind about not wanting to lynch him and that it was caused by Eek's reaction to his possible lynch.
-----
Cloud Nine seems worse than I remembered. First of all, they have an overly aggressive tone, which I don't really like. I also don't like how he went against SKOT, he accuses him of being either scum or a dumbass, but I can't tell where the line between those two is. I mean, he makes that differentiation but he seems to be pushing stupidity and bad play as a scum tell.
I got two scum reads now. Yay!
