InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Cephrir]

Votecount 1.31

xofelf 6 (Egg, ActionDan, AngryIcerink, Moogle Dance Troupe, BBmolla, Young and Beautiful)

Lemniscate 5 (Squirrel Girl, Svenskt Stål, ProHawk, Nero Cain, geists)
shos 5 (BulbaFenix, Majiffy, Venmar, Lord Mhork, TSO)

Young and Beautiful 4 (Abomination, Mist7676, Lord Mhork, Lemniscate)

Nero Cain 2 (Squirrel Girl, neil1113)

Abomination 1 (Katsuki)
Always 1 (beastcharizard)
BBmolla 1 (Always)
Moogle Dance Troupe 1 (Birds of Prey)
ProHawk 1 (HighShroomish)

15 to lynch.

Not Voting 2 (The Goat, xofelf)

Deadline: July 18, 2 PM EST.

This is approximately 96 hours from this post.

[Moogle Dance Troupe]

The Y&B wagon is disbanding in an unnaturally slow way that makes me think that players who were on it don't have a good wagon to jump to.

Wow this is very interesting, tell me more. No seriously, tell me more. I want to know precisely who on this wagon is scummy for not knowing where to put there vote after the claim. Full claim in your next post please.

I would think this would be pretty easy for you, since you've got them all in your scumlists: {BoP, xof, lemniscate, mist}. They have the option to either jump on shos who is clearly town, or their buddies, or do nothing. They've chosen the latter.

[geists]

@ceph whoo! I'm a double voter!

I should run a game where catching the mod's VC errors is a mechanic.

[Cephrir]

notscience replaces T S O.

[AngryIcerink]

I would think this would be pretty easy for you, since you've got them all in your scumlists: {BoP, xof, lemniscate, mist}. They have the option to either jump on shos who is clearly town, or their buddies, or do nothing. They've chosen the latter.

I'm not going to hold your hand; you made a very blanket statement about people on the the Y&B wagon not knowing where to go. You

implied

this was scummy of them but didn't say it. I dislike blanket statements like "Oh X is town because the wagon on them is so fast", but I can sort of see it. The point you made, however, should DEFINITELY have been aimed at individual people that you observed doing this rather than simply throwing a general off-handed accusation out there that requires parsing of individual posts to validate on an individual level for everyone on the wagon. TL;DR: This point looks like you are making baseless generalizations and not really putting thought into it.

In your followup, you mention that this is explicitly scummy because people don't want to vote shos (why?) or bus a buddy (seriously these are the only options?). This is a false dichotomy. A player's options are unique based on what they have posted so this generalization continues to be bad.
~I'm out of celebrity birds to sign with.

[AngryIcerink]

it

I think this sentence was a little confusing. By "it" I mean I can at least understand SOME general statements like the one I provided as an example.

[Venmar]

The awkward resistance to the shos wagon and the counterwagons against it does make me feel better about being on shos tbh.

[AngryIcerink]

The awkward resistance to the shos wagon

This is mostly just me and mastin chanting about how Show is town loudly and repeatedly. I'm pretty sure you trust mastin at least.

[Venmar]

Me and Mastin disagree on a bunch of reads this game so meh. If you guys could kindly back off of Shos, I would be swell.

[AngryIcerink]

Counterpoint: can we compromise lynch someone?

[geists]

lemniscate.

[Abomination]

It feels like the xof wagon has been at the same point for forever, can the people on it tell me why they're on it and what they've done to push that wagon? (Egg, ActionDan, AngryIcerink, Moogle Dance Troupe, BBmolla, Young and Beautiful)

VOTE: Nero Cain

I might go to BoP since I didn't like his reaction to the YaB claim, but I'd rather not lead a whole new wagon.

- Axxle

[geists]

VOTE: Nero Cain

I might go to BoP since I didn't like his reaction to the YaB claim, but I'd rather not lead a whole new wagon.

- Axxle

Your thoughts on lemniscate?

[shos]

Guys.

it's D1.

80 pages.

[Cephrir]

Prodding Egg, Lemniscate, beastcharizard.

[notscience]

Noone said hi to me

I hate you all

Geists, BPC/Who heads of Abomination, and Majiffy all should give me a rundown of what happened thus far.

Most accurate/best told story gets my vote.

[geists]

You replaced into a slot that I am leaning town on. Please don't fuck that up if you're town.

[notscience]

that's not a story

fwiw I'm leaning town on my slot too

[notscience]

I'm going to start reading when I get back from dinner.

I will kill you all if it's pages of walls.

[Nero Cain]

So like, SG claims to have a town read on Abomination. I then ask her her read on Abomination and says that she has no read on him. I point this out and SG ignores me. Why? Well she says that she forgot and it should have been obvious. That's bullshit.

But like any good lie it contains a kernel of truth. SHE IGNORED ME. She ignored me 'cause she hoped it would go away.

So when she replies after I press more she immediately OMGUS votes me 'cause its scummy of me to point out a logical flaw? This is angry outted scum. If she was town she just would have said that she forgot. And now she's screaming for my blood 'cause she wants me mislynched so her team doesn't have to waste a bullet on me.

I know you guys think this is town but its not.

Why did it take you about three days to figure that out?

I don't particularly enjoy arguing with scum and it usally backfires anyways (TSO and Giests are town reading you. Maybescum Mastin doesn't count but she is townreading you.) So when someone else was voting you and then both Shos and Mastin expressed some iffyness for you I said "HEY TRACTION!" but yeah...still think you being fussy over someone expressing suspicion of you is more like scum you then town you, I DO think you were making up that Abomination read 'cause I don't think its very likely that you "forgot" that read.

Pbpa of all posts is a red flag and not that town of hs.

Why is this? Links please.

don't really like this that much.

I would also pleadingly point out that Nero came through in the middle of all this, told a joke (that was pretty weak, as long as I'm judging) and then scampered off.

Y'know, like *town* do

Wich is ignoring the context. I made a post that said I was v/la until I got my computer fixed, Jiffy asked me if that was Nero and I responded to him. Since I'm not going to (and no one else should) buy that you didn't see my v/la post (I'm not buying it 'cause my v/la post was on the same page just a few posts above one of yours and you'd have to be blind to have not seen it.) So I think its safe to assume that you are playing revisionist. Remind me why town would EVER distort facts to fit thier agenda?

[Abomination]

VOTE: Nero Cain

I might go to BoP since I didn't like his reaction to the YaB claim, but I'd rather not lead a whole new wagon.

- Axxle

Your thoughts on lemniscate?

The slot is pretty solidly null, why is your vote on her again?

-Axxle

[Abomination]

BPC/Who heads of Abomination

I've killed all the other heads

-Axxle

[geists]

I don't like to tell stories and I don't think town replace-ees should rely on stories.

Y&B was run up over 10 votes iirc and claimed friendly neighbor.

Bird of Prey's push there, especially the reaction to the claim is interesting. Nati thinks lemniscate is scum and I've moved our vote back there for now.

Look at the isos of lemniscate, mist7676 and Xof. If you've played with any of them I'm curious what you think.

Majiffy's scumreading Xof and pushing that wagon hard. SG and Nero are scumreading each other. Other stuff happened.

[geists]

Sorry Majiffy's pushing Shos not Xof.

[Abomination]

Most accurate/best told story gets my vote.

This is a pretty perverse incentive.