InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[Squirrel Girl]

This is all good analysis and correct but, wouldnt a townie jist answer 'i forgot'? Instead of analysing what benefit the other may have from recieving an answer? Town has no reason not to be fully clear with mates?

I supplied the analysis because I was calling Nero scum for trying to use it as a scumtell on me - because there is no logic to calling it scummy in the first place. Basically he accurately identified that I forgot something, and then just declared i a scumtell...because!

Why do you think it's a valid scumtell, since you're apparently on the same wavelength here? Like, why would scum have done that (the forgetting the read on Abomination thing)?

I'm also not going to flavor claim unless there's an actual reason to - and I don't see one. I also can put my votes on the same person if I wish.

[Squirrel Girl]

Did you even read the whole thing? I mean, I specifically end my analysis with an (unaswered) challenge to Nero to explain how it was a scumtell. Why are you even asking why I did the analysis?

[shos]

well because you DID avoid giving a straight out answer, and usually when I'm town I firstly answer a question, and then elaborate on whatever.

I sorta~ agree with jake on the fact that it needs to be looked at. I don't think it's a scumtell per se, but inconsistency is a great grand super hyper duper tool to use against scum, and he caught your change of heart withing ~50 posts(?) so that isn't far enough...you'd wonder what happened in those posts that made you change your mind(unless it's a reaction test, but this clearly isn't). problem is that this game is HUGE, and I have a hard time remembering even my strong reads, so forgetting is perfectly legit.

either way - I think scum DV is very powerful so I automatically lean town on you, even if this game is so huge, and with multiball so DV doesn't matter that much..whoops missile gtg

[Squirrel Girl]

I would rather you forget that I'm a double voter and address the issue if you think it's actually scummy. Maybe I am just a really powerful scum role lol-ing it up in your face.

[Lord Mhork]

The fuck is with this xolef cw to obvscum shos?

Xof is massive scum because she defended someone, got defensive, and then let a wagon happen while she was V/LA

[Majiffy]

oo la la

VOTE: xof

[Majiffy]

VOTE: shos

Dumb fucks.

[Lord Mhork]

But majiffy xof didn't answer her wagon before her internet cut out!

[geists]

The fuck is with this xolef cw to obvscum shos?

Xof is massive scum because she defended someone, got defensive, and then let a wagon happen while she was V/LA

This has fuck-all to do with why I'm voting xof. The only phrase that even resonates is "got defensive', but I doubt we'd even be talking about the same posts.

If I could see a good reason for a fellow-scum to stick their neck out this far and for this long, I'd probably be voting you right now.

[Lord Mhork]

Why are you voting her then, geists? I don't understand this case at all.

[AngryIcerink]

If you don't understand the case, then why re you vehemently attacking the votes on her rather than trying to figure out the case??????????
~AP

[Lord Mhork]

Because what I do understand of it is stupid

[Cephrir]

Prodded Mist.

[Squirrel Girl]

If you don't understand the case, then why re you vehemently attacking the votes on her rather than trying to figure out the case??????????
~AP

Because what I do understand of it is stupid

[geists]

Why are you voting her then, geists? I don't understand this case at all.

I should just yell at you to read my iso.

yes, you

So do you no longer scumread Abomination? Or is the AngryIce read in addition to that?

What the hell is this crap where you and Mist act like its odd to have multiple scumreads?

Still think Abomination is scum.

I was actually seeking clarification, since you called out the scum on your wagon and only indicated Furious Frozen Water. Do you honestly think it's 2 scum and 1 town currently on you? Meh. I'm pretty happy with my vote on you.

@Geists - what's the xolf case?

This is what I've posted:

I haven't called you out. You've posted enough that I have a tentative read.

That's fine, but I am here (but not caught up), so lets bounce reads. I see you voting xofelf, walk me through that.

46 - felt off as a reaction to an rvs vote.

73 - contradicts 46 in that xofelf says she doesn't react to rvs votes after reacting to one.

119 - feels a little defensive. I probably wouldn't be concerned about it if not for the way 46 and 73 struck me.

She's also soft-defended Abomination argued against a policy lynch, but the concern looks premature, maybe contrived. Overall she feels jumpy and defensive.

Klick townreads her for something that I don't understand, and I don't think he's explained it yet.

Correction: 46 was a response to a comment from Action Dan about the tags possibly being voteworthy.

The relevant part below bolded.

Ffer

town reading me because the timing of my vote raises an eyebrow. This woman is notoriously hard to charm.

1. scummiest thing to hit the thread at that point in time gets posted
2. somebody puts a vote down on the person who posted the scummiest thing to hit the thread
3. ffery picks up a tentative town read.

Something like that happens in nearly every game I play. Sometimes the tentative town read even lasts the game day.

This is the second time you've done a drive-by soft-fos. If you have a concern about me why aren't you trying to sort me?

I'm curious why you asked someone who's made recent comments about her given a few people voted recently with no trajectory at all.

[Lord Mhork]

But 73 is only relevant if 46 is. You literally just said it wasn't an RVS reaction, therefore there's no contradiction, therefore 119 shouldn't cause you concern?

[geists]

But 73 is only relevant if 46 is. You literally just said it wasn't an RVS reaction, therefore there's no contradiction, therefore 119 shouldn't cause you concern?

The post she was reacting to was this (note the bolded):

I'd only vote her for not using proper bracketing.

Guys let's all vote for ActionDan please thanks.

Doubling down on cheek.

I'll raise you 40 zorbucks.

And her reaction was this:

I'm so sorry that I prefer

over VOTE: ?
Am I not allowed to have a preference? I'm used to using

for things and VOTE: being a typo soo I dunno man. Muscle memory and all that.

That's an overreaction to something in RVS that wasn't a vote - was even less than a vote. And that looked like a joke to me.

So yeah, overreaction in RVS.

[shos]

VOTE: shos

Dumb fucks.

baby

if you keep at it I'm gonna dayvig you

[Birds of Prey]

Geists, why are you voting xof? The wagon composition at the end just hopped from shos? We have two on Y and B. Throw your weigh behind and we have three. Young and Beautiful is doing no real scumhunting. All the vote parking, you know, is suspicious as fuck. Now let's lynch scum.

- VFT -

[T S O]

but if it's a hydra, why is it inactive?

Wow. You are just looking for any excuse to scumread mastin and it stinks.

oh, yes AP, very good! When multiple players are playing together and yet there's still no posting, that's not suspicious at all! Well done!

Be quiet unless you have something intelligible to say.

And at last I see the light-
UNVOTE:
VOTE: shos
-and it's like the fog has lifted!
- y -

I didn't see anything that would make you vote shos recently, so what the hell are you talking about?

Iec+AP, what do you think of majiffy and neros push. Is it worthy of a scumread? I already haveone on NC but maybe maj is tickling kagome with a sword too.

why are you asking people whether you should scumread others? why is it not possible to actually make that decision yourself?

TSO I'm torn about, leaning town. shroom really hasn't got into my memory

What makes you "torn" about my play again?

So Shos, what you're saying is that you're InuYasha, who is undead and somewhere demon is mentioned?
Uhhh... In my fairly limited theme knowledge(Provided Ceph is even sticking to it for everything) Inuyasha is far from undead and never gains that status.

lol hun read the game please, what is this nonsense.
I'm InuYasha, demon. that is all I've said.
somewhere in my pm is mentioned undead and demons in another context, in a way that to my understanding supports a theory where one group of scum is undead and another is made of demons.

didn't you say earlier that you -specifically- had not mentioned being a demon?

why the hell would you do that and then claim demon? what benefit could this plan possibly have?

Aleays is just so town. His reference to my LotR game lately is a reaaaaalllly good thinking. I mean really.

How the fuck would Always randomly referring to a game you played in be "reaaaaaaalllllllly good thinking" and make him "so town"?

Lord Mhork - he is being alittle odd but i remember a few posts that made me genuibely think he is scum. He lurked alot like most players and when he came back his cobtent was fine (wrong, but fine). So lean toen
2. geists (Natirasha & fferyllt) who?
3. Shos
4. ProHawk - in this game?
5. BulbaFenix (Bulbazak & EddieFenix)* scumread from ages ago but he hasnt posted in yearz
6. Katsuki* who?
7. Sakura Hana Squirrel Girl - can anyone link me to her answer to NC? That was a nice catch and i dont remember.
8. beastcharizard niet
9. T S O meh
10. Rhaego Wake88 wtf
11. Birds of Prey (anonymous hydra) town from latest posts
12. Iecerint AngryIcerink (Iecerint & AngryPidgeon) obvtown consistently
13. ActionDan in this game???
14. Moogle Dance Troupe (Kagami & Kazekirimaru)????
15. Svenskt Stål*?????
16. Majiffy probtoen but get outta the tunnel pr shelob would find ya
17. Nero Cain probscum
18. Always (mastin2 & Malakittens) more town than even me
19. Young and Beautiful (anonymous hydra) scumread goes here
20. Clyton neil1113???
21. Abomination (Who, Axxle, Haylen, MTD, T-Bone, ika, & BipolarChemist) considering the amount of llayers in here, WTF.
22. The Goat MEEE. Wut
23. Venmar null yet
24. BBmolla scumread
25. kdowns Mist7676??????
26. xofelf* must go over why this one is scum i dont remember shit
27. Egg is tasty
28. Klick HighShroomish null yet.

Sigh

I think this is the shittiest readslist I've ever seen. Usually when you give a readslist, ??? is not a read. You seem to think it is, though, given it's the main tell of the list.

[T S O]

Don't you worry, guys, I will be responding to Always and Venmar in a separate post later tonight, and I promise you, I am going to enjoy this.

[Lord Mhork]

Fun fact about xof: she gets super defensive whenever she feels like anyone is trying to impose their way of thinking on literally anything. As far as xof goes, that's not an overreaction. But feel free to judge her by your standard of behavior. I'm sure that will work out well

[geists]

Geists, why are you voting xof? The wagon composition at the end just hopped from shos? We have two on Y and B. Throw your weigh behind and we have three. Young and Beautiful is doing no real scumhunting. All the vote parking, you know, is suspicious as fuck. Now let's lynch scum.

- VFT -

I'm voting xof because I think she's scum.

[Lord Mhork]

Geists what if she's not scum? Who's scum then?

[Cephrir]

bump