InuYasha Mafia (Game Over)

[T S O]

oh, there we go!!!

[geists]

The timing of your request looks a little odd given how things are shaping up with Mastin and the Iece slot.

And my request is directly in response to Mastin's response to Iece. It was certainly the intention that I wished to convey.

Please explain how it is "a little odd".

- b -

The fairly significant replace-in did not make an impression on me;

I would say that it is irrelevant to my post.

Indeed, Mastin should be copped in any game, preferably earlier so she gets less time to pull strings as scum, and perpetual safety as town.

This is Day 1, and reasonably early in the game. I find nothing wrong with the timing of the post.

- b -

I think you need to explain some more. Right now it looks like you're contradicting yourself.

[geists]

Odds are he's Town, he has no reason to withhold reads as scum - it's still annoying as fuck.

If you point to any single random player, odds are that they'll be Town rather than Scum. Basic probability.

geists, how confident are you that AP is Town then? 100%?


Do you think you can read AP with 100% certainty then?

Answer yes and you might be a candidate for a scummie!~

- b -

If you've paid any attention at all to my posts, then you should have a pretty good idea of my read on iece.

[Young and Beautiful]

You've got like 2 posts to convince me you aren't multi-scum this game (I am correct in stating this is multiball?; for some reason I think it is but UI havent really read).

Fuck

no.

You've got it rat's-ass backwards. I owe you absolutely nothing.
NOTHING.
Of the sort.

This game.
This game.

It's

you

the burden is on.

Your entry was null-at-best.
BEST.

One post down.
One to go.

You try pinning your scummy-ass BoP on me, I'm speedlynching you.

This post in particular sparked my response.

That is all there is.

What do you wish to accomplish from this line of questioning?

- b -

[geists]

You've got like 2 posts to convince me you aren't multi-scum this game (I am correct in stating this is multiball?; for some reason I think it is but UI havent really read).

Fuck

no.

You've got it rat's-ass backwards. I owe you absolutely nothing.
NOTHING.
Of the sort.

This game.
This game.

It's

you

the burden is on.

Your entry was null-at-best.
BEST.

One post down.
One to go.

You try pinning your scummy-ass BoP on me, I'm speedlynching you.

This post in particular sparked my response.

That is all there is.

What do you wish to accomplish from this line of questioning?

- b -

I wish to develop a read of you.

What in particular about that post sparked the cop request?

[The Goat]

Oh, hi!

[The Goat]

I am on vacation until Sunday, at which time I will read and make comments and judge people unfairly.

Until that point, please carry on while I drink and fish.

[Young and Beautiful]

You've got like 2 posts to convince me you aren't multi-scum this game (I am correct in stating this is multiball?; for some reason I think it is but UI havent really read).

Fuck

no.

You've got it rat's-ass backwards. I owe you absolutely nothing.
NOTHING.
Of the sort.

This game.
This game.

It's

you

the burden is on.

Your entry was null-at-best.
BEST.

One post down.
One to go.

You try pinning your scummy-ass BoP on me, I'm speedlynching you.

This post in particular sparked my response.

That is all there is.

What do you wish to accomplish from this line of questioning?

- b -

I wish to develop a read of you.

What in particular about that post sparked the cop request?

Nothing in particular. The fact of Mastin being impossible to read with 100% certainty requires that she be copped very early.

At best, I can only do 99%

- b -

[geists]

You've got like 2 posts to convince me you aren't multi-scum this game (I am correct in stating this is multiball?; for some reason I think it is but UI havent really read).

Fuck

no.

You've got it rat's-ass backwards. I owe you absolutely nothing.
NOTHING.
Of the sort.

This game.
This game.

It's

you

the burden is on.

Your entry was null-at-best.
BEST.

One post down.
One to go.

You try pinning your scummy-ass BoP on me, I'm speedlynching you.

This post in particular sparked my response.

That is all there is.

What do you wish to accomplish from this line of questioning?

- b -

I wish to develop a read of you.

What in particular about that post sparked the cop request?

Nothing in particular. The fact of Mastin being impossible to read with 100% certainty requires that she be copped very early.

At best, I can only do 99%

- b -

And yet, you didn't make the request sooner, though you say that it's a requirement she be copped very early.

Here are the problems I have with your posts.

- Directing hypothetical PRs always catches my attention, particularly from a player I don't know has a tendency to do that sort of thing. You're an anonymous hydra so this box is checked, and not with a fine point pen.

- If you are town, and scum think a hypothetical cop will take you up on your suggestion, then you've painted a target on Mastin if she's town.

- If you are scum, then this could be an opportunity to point town PR attention at someone who's not on your team, and possibily making your team's night action choices less complicated.

- Of the two players, in that interaction, Mastin looks a hell of a lot more town. And, the slot became far more dangerous if scum with the addition of AP. And you are drawing attention to the more town looking player in the interaction.

- There is still a huge question in my mind about why that interaction and that post would have been the one to spark the request.

IMO telling town PRs what to do when data is still quite thin is bad play if you're town, and I question why town-anybody would do it. There are times when giving town PRs advice makes sense. Right now doesn't feel even close to such a time.

[Young and Beautiful]

I'm not fishing for a PR claim, nor am I trying to get them to respond to me. Whatever any hypothetical PR wishes to do with their night action is entirely their responsibility.

At the very most, I can give them incentive... with a smooch :*

I don't want to get involved in mafia discussion. Mastin, however, may gladly accommodate you. She can discuss mafia theory with you as a player; regardless if she is town or scum

I'm only interested in finding scum.

- b -

[geists]

I'm not fishing for a PR claim, nor am I trying to get them to respond to me. Whatever any hypothetical PR wishes to do with their night action is entirely their responsibility.

I've neither said nor implied that you did.

At the very most, I can give them incentive... with a smooch :*

Incentive which IMO is advantageous to scum if they take you up on it.

I don't want to get involved in mafia discussion. Mastin, however, may gladly accommodate you. She can discuss mafia theory with you as a player; regardless if she is town or scum

Right now, you have my interest considerably more than Mastin does.

I'm only interested in finding scum.

- b -

Which is something that even scum can probably say with conviction in this game.

[Young and Beautiful]

Okay then.

I kindly request for a change of this line of questioning.

Would you like to sort me with other topics of discussion/questions?

- b -

[geists]

No. I mostly sort players organically. You're on my watch list. I have no further questions for you atm.

[ActionDan]

I would appreciate it that if a vig is considering shooting Rhaego tonight they instead pick someone else.

[Rhaego]

Cop Mastin

Result: Town

oh, there we go!!!

What just happened here? Explain.

[ActionDan]

nothing. it's fake.

[Lord Mhork]

You are silly and sharpest is gone

VOTE: Rhaego

For serious what are you doing with all your holding questions?

Also Mastin isn't difficult to read, guys ._.

[Lord Mhork]

I'm a dumbfuck and these games are really similar in player lists.

The point remains you're being weird Rhaego. Why?

[Rhaego]

Do my questions bother you?

Why?

VOTE: Lord Mhork

[AngryIcerink]

You try pinning your scummy-ass BoP on me, I'm speedlynching you.

I just had to be sure of your alignment, mastin, chill. I recalled thinking you were townish for that one opening post and Iec thinks you are too (I think? lol). This response is a little soothing. Apparently I came across differently than I intended to. I told Iec that I thought you were town as I replaced in and he accused me of lying in the post I made because I was hinting you were scum. Not my intention, was merely trying to interject myself into the game as fast as possible . Also I was apparently mistaken that this game is openly multifaction, there was just a post from someone saying it probably was.

And, the slot became far more dangerous if scum with the addition of AP.

<3. I do swear I'm not scum though. Has all this been Natirasha or fferyllt? Actually, I guess I don't care; at first I thought that your recent posts looked town if from ffery, but I think its just town either way in all probability. I also sort of like Y&B on this page.. I need to revisit that a little, but I do like both people involved in the mastin debate. I see passion, I see hard-headedness, I see decent points being made on both sides that would be a bit ... pedantic? (not exactly, but something along those lines) for scum to be making.

TSO is not someone I think is town after reading the last page. Not scum either. Well ok, maybe a little bit. Everything he is doing is sidelining right now.

P-edit: Dan you are gonna have to be super obvtown for me if you wanna play that card btw.

[AngryIcerink]

I just read P1-6. I'll give some feelings about my read through every few pages as I catch up (wont be all at once here).

Spoiler:

Townish:
Dan - I liked his soft claim, doesn't feel overly direct, appears to be playing the game. Doesnt feel like L4D.
mastin - soft claim, appears vested in scum hunting. My ONLY concern here is that this game being multifaction makes my read on mastin way less valid than it would otherwise be. Buuuut I think shes town nonetheless. I do want her to explain why she wanted scum in this game though.
Majiffy - Feels open, posts don't feel over explained, doesn't radiate defensiveness or guilt.
---GAP---
Katsuki - Well then. I'm not exactly sure what to say about that entrance. Is activity a scumtell for you? . Seriously though, it feels a little town to me.
Venmar - Eh.
Clyton - Mechanical as always, but I he feels different than what I've seen of him before and I've only seen him as scum before. Kinda bad description, but its there. Weak read.
Mhork - hesitant to list him as something other than null, but I did like his post where he voted Dan. Well, not really. It read really bad, but bad in a town way. So weak read.

------
Scummy (weak reads, but eh): Klick, Xofelf, NeroCain, TSO, Kdowns

[ActionDan]

I'll play the card where it's ridiculously easy to figure out what Rhaego is trying to do. If I have to play a card?

[Venmar]

Oh hey AngryPidgeon, it's good to know you hydra'd into a town slot!

[ActionDan]

still too early

[geists]

Has all this been Natirasha or fferyllt?

No nati posts yet.