bjc- Shinobi (L-6)
Shinobi- Boonskiies (L-6)
Not Voting: I Love Fairies, Drew-Sta
With 12 alive, it takes 7 votes for a lynch.
(expired on 2014-07-03 00:22:00)
I wasn't really buying his multiple "whoops totally didn't see that" excuses, but. I'm waning. He's probably town.In post 86, KittyMo wrote:By the by, thoughts on Drew at this point? You're still pow-powing him with them doublevotes.
You called?In post 93, OkaPoka wrote:Grib is going to be one major/scary player if he is scum.
This might go down poorly.
Lets hope he is town.
Unless I get shot toNight, or god forbid, lynched. Fingers crossed.In post 104, OkaPoka wrote:We all love RVS don't we?
I just want to point out Grib will be major in the game, but I yet to feel sure in Grib scum.
So do something about it? I'm right here.In post 105, Boonskiies wrote:I have a big town read on Grib. That's why I'm so worried...it's almost too big.
I kept pointing out things you apparently missed. Stop missing things, is what I meant. In a gentle way.In post 92, Drew-Sta wrote:@ Gribre 62
You posted this:
Can you clarify? I don't understand.Gotta start opening your eyes, child.
Re post 80 - My spidey sense picked up on that too (the'I'd rather we not lynch a townie just to confirm my alignment.'comment by ILF). Still thinking it over.
My emphasisIn post 43, KittyMo wrote:snip->
Hm? I mean I think it's defensive of her (not opportunistic) to only really pay attention to the reasonless votes that are on her and not be looking at Boon or Shinobi, but I know from mystalking of the whole playerlistskimmingthat she's never been lynched in a game before and I doubt she's been under much lynch pressure, let alone under these circumstances, so it's not surprising? Though she also has no completed scum games and so that could be a source of "I have no idea what I'm doing" as well.
I'm curious about what people think of her first post. Would you expect that from town or scum?
And why the 180 on Shinobi?In post 86, KittyMo wrote:Snip->I found one instance of a game in which she was town and uses townie as a general term (in her first paragraph) though she does generally use it in the traditional way from what I've seen. By the by, thoughts on Drew at this point? You're still pow-powing him with them doublevotes.Grib wrote:Tell me that wasn't a slip. Don't make this too easy for us.
Snip->
In post 86, KittyMo wrote:
Re: Shinobi, he certainly didn't put much effort into defending Fairies so I'm not sure why that's the main thing being read into about him. I didn't like that as votes were becoming less random (people at that stage were starting to make votes that were at least vaguely game-related and he made no attempt to keep us moving out of the RVS and made an avatar-related vote) and everything else he's done so far has been boring. elk's latest post rubs me the wrong way though.
I also don't like all the IIoA in that post.In post 96, KittyMo wrote:Snip->I was trying to sort whether I found him or Shinobi scummier before revoting and I'm happy with this.
In post 29, Grib wrote:Snip->
Hey elk, would you say it's OMGUS if you vote for someone voting you, 100% all the time, regardless of context?
Why?In post 38, I Love Fairies wrote:->I didn't say I thought Kitty to be mafia necessarily, just that I find her slightly more likely to be mafia than anyone else in the thread.
Two things wrong with this post.In post 115, Boonskiies wrote:Well, he keeps trying to put Grib on the spot. If Grib is town, we obviously want to keep him because of the second vote. Other than that, I don't think anyone else is outstandingly scummy. It doesn't make sense for a townie to lynch a town role with two votes.
That he is a dashing specimen of humanity! Such wit! Such charm! Such poise!In post 116, Boonskiies wrote:So what's everyone's thoughts on massive?
The real question, though, is "who benefits from wanting this information?"In post 94, shinyskarmory wrote:My mistake-I thought I posted an answer to that question but it never went through.
I wanted to see how the "double vote" was handled-for example, if the second vote is publicly counted with the name shown on both votes, then his role claim is instantly cleaned, which makes him significantly more likely to be town. If the other vote wasn't publicly displayed or was counted but not displayed, that would make him more likely to be mafia because he would only be partially cleaned (in that his role was confirmed to exist, NOT that he was confirmed to have it) and it's generally kind of crappy hosting to publically clean a mafia member.
1. How do youknowGrib is a town role?
2. What has Shinobi done to clear himself? You've gone from I think he's scum to your view that no one else is outstandingly scummy, Shinobi hasn't posted anything that would cause a change of mind between these two posts.