Event Card Mafia (Game Over)

[ActionDan]

Also ActionDan failed to say who he targeted.

Mnemonicdevice and magua

[Juls]

And no results on both?

[farside22]

The reasons are retarded though but ok juls. Unless "no result" means didn't visit anybody I was roleblocked

Who did you target and considering it was double action which 2 did you track?

[farside22]

Sorry ignore my question

[ActionDan]

And no results on both?

Yes. >_>

[Papa Zito]

Room Five - TheIrishPope (I am going to assume this was a gift to talah. I hope that Zito led this though. I would like some details of the conversations here)

I didn't even get a chance to post in mine. It was closed by the time I got to it Sunday evening. I'm conflicted if that's entirely a bad thing because the thread was an ungodly green color. Anyway here's a breakdown.

Post 1: zoraster's instructions
Post 2: TiP noms Prof Fridays without comment
Post 3: Prof Fridays noms TiP, complains about the color (VALID)
Post 4: Prof Fridays complains that I'm gonna nom him
Post 5: Prof Fridays unnoms TiP, says he wants to look at Metal Sonic as a candidate
Post 6: Prof Fridays re-noms TiP and talks about BROseidon's claim vs Metal Sonic's claim
Post 7: Metal Sonic noms TiP with no real comment

And that was it.

Did any group NOT complete the nomination process? Did scum pick any of these?

Also I dunno what cards are best to pick.

[ZZZX]

Followup to Oversoul and ZZZX because lollockedthread: Your plans are bad and you should feel bad.

Oversoul, the knowledge you claimed, if true, you should absolutely positively under no circumstances do anything with.

PEDit: Nevermind on that last bit.

The Plan I discussed didnt look bad to me. How did it look bad to you?

[farside22]

Quick note: Ideal card submission is Split Universe (allows for double lynch) + Always On.

Always On could be swapped for Black Light, but it's a matter of known town advantage vs unknown.

Always on is okay. Sure talk to x all you want. My issue is I'm paranoid about most people and with the convo I had in our thread very frustrating.

Followup to Oversoul and ZZZX because lollockedthread: Your plans are bad and you should feel bad.

Oversoul, the knowledge you claimed, if true, you should absolutely positively under no circumstances do anything with.

PEDit: Nevermind on that last bit.

Really curious why you were nomed

[Juls]

I have submitted 2 modified saviors

[Juls]

What metal sonic and bro claim? Damn this 100 page game!

Also, I suspect mafia is killing with blue goo. I tried to search muffins posts for a crumb of blue goo meaning and didn't see one. And mod wouldn't verify one way or the other for me. I don't know what blue goo means however

[Juls]

Oh nvm...same person

[Papa Zito]

BROseidon claimed Yellow Goo and Metal Sonic has claimed PGO.

Is that a thing? I have never heard of a "Goo" mechanic.

Sounds like an AIDS mechanic that I had as a 3rd party in another game. Might go towards someone's wincon, or may just be a flavor thing (Blue Goo vig?).

The description I got is actually exactly how that spread, except that we have multiple colors of Goo in this game (I have yellow)

I am a pgo don't visit me ok town

[farside22]

Also ActionDan failed to say who he targeted.

Mnemonicdevice and magua

Why did you target those 2?

[Juls]

Oh right, I forgot about that. I remembered the PGO. I assumed he didn't want visits though and didn't take that as a for-serious claim.

Also, Aronis admitted his day vig was fake

[Aronis]

For what it is worth, I'm not Blue Goo or any of that and I submitted Always on Rules and Modified Savior.

[Magua]

Always on is okay. Sure talk to x all you want. My issue is I'm paranoid about most people and with the convo I had in our thread very frustrating.

None of them are as good as DDLM, but, shrug. The rare cards are all antitown crap, and the common cards are the gamut from bad to meh to only slightly town (Split Universe being the best, in that category).

So seems better to submit 1 sliiiiightly town card (Split Universe) + 1 actually useful town card (Always On / Black Light).

I think Always On's value can't really be overestimated, especially since it lets people claim things to people they trust (eg could do a massclaim to a trusted townie ie Juls who could then direct actions).

Really curious why you were nomed

Because

Oversoul scumreads me in every single game we've ever played together

I'm not reading the thread, which is obviously a scumtell for me.

The Plan I discussed didnt look bad to me. How did it look bad to you?

Your plan in #16 in our nomination thread is pointless, so just contributes noise without value. The bad plan was Oversoul's in #14 (third paragraph from the bottom).

[Juls]

Always on isn't bad

[Papa Zito]

Aronis, what was the point of your fakeclaim, and why did you decide to retract it now?

[Iecerint]

I submitted 2 results and 1 of them was not a null-result. So, that means I wasn't blocked.

I can claim now, or I can claim after other claims happen.

If only talah and I remain to claim, no reason not to claim now IMO. (We didn't claim to one another in our room.)

[farside22]

I like the split universe mostly because (1) card is cheap (2) getting a new thread with less people (3) 2 lynches for the win!
I like black light. I know the word generally is in there but so is town.

[Iecerint]

I think I'm going to select Black Light and Vote For Event unless someone tells me that it is a bad thing to do.

[Juls]

Iec, unless there is a reason not to out your results, out your results.

[Iecerint]

Oh, I missed that Split Universe also gets two lynches. I like that.

Are the two Universes Private topics?

[Iecerint]

Looks like yes. Too bad.

So we can't share results across universes. But not the end of the world.

[Juls]

I have changed my selection to 1 Modified Savior, 1 Always On