Peter's posts break down to four categories:
a)Throwing suspicion at me in any way possible.
b) Appearing to be useful by pointing out something that we all should have read.
c) Saying that is is
d) Throwing more suspicion at me whenever possible.
His first meaningful post was on page 4, and he didn't really get going until page 9, until he saw someone (me) who he could (continue to) pounce on. He posted maybe once or twice wishing that Avi would lurk less or that mustafa would stop voting like I do, but his posts really show the patterns I mention above.
After realizing that pointing out 'useful' information is really just WIFOM, and can be a scum trait, Peter went from being least scummy to kinda scummy then to most scummy for me.
And really, in any game, it is definitely in the scum's best interests for townies not to believe role claims - get close to lynching a townie, then he role claims power, and then gets lynched anyway.
Also, I find it great how when I point out that I'm not really misrepresenting him and that I in fact genuinely disagree that towns shouldn't play to survive, he decides to agree with the two or three posters who think that the argument should be dropped.
And for him, here, it's a great reason to ask that we drop the subject, but then he attacked me earlier for taking Vel's and gorckat's advice on how to play the game. So basically, what is scummy for me, is natural for him to do?
For these reasons and more, I
I find Ichigo (zombie, now) still as being suspicious, and possibly Avi and Occult... but Peter is really not looking like a town to me.
And, as a funny aside: wagon him, and see if he still agrees that it is in the town's interest for him to die. Or that he shouldn't try and live. Or whatever diction he would prefer we use.