Event Card Mafia (Game Over)

[ActionDan]

That's all there is to it

[zoraster]

Day 1

ActionDan ( 1 )

Iecerint

[/color]

(L - 12 )

Agar ( 2 )

xReckonerX

Juls

[/color]

(L - 11 )

Aronis ( 7 )

mnemonicdevice

talah

Agar

Papa Zito

Bulbazak

Aronis

Tony PF

[/color]

(L - 6 )

Juls ( 1 )

qwints

[/color]

(L - 12 )

KingdomAces ( 1 )

DeltaWave

[/color]

(L - 12 )

Kublai Khan ( 3 )

Venmar

Oversoul

zMuffinMan

[/color]

(L - 10 )

mnemonicdevice ( 2 )

KingdomAces

ActionDan

[/color]

(L - 11 )

Prof Fridays ( 1 )

farside22

[/color]

(L - 12 )

talah ( 1 )

TheIrishPope

[/color]

(L - 12 )

Tony PF ( 1 )

Prof Fridays

[/color]

(L - 12 )

xReckonerX ( 1 )

Kublai Khan

[/color]

(L - 12 )

Not Voting ( 4 )

Brian Skies BROseidon GuyInFreezer DeathNote

Total Votes ( 25 )

Needed to Lynch [ 13 ]

Deadline

Deadline is April 27 at 20:00 EDT --- Time Until Deadline: (expired on 2014-04-27 20:00:00)

Current Active Event:

Geography

Tomorrow's Event:

Double Action

[qwints]

I don't get the reference for any of this. Can you include the name of the players you are refering to for the first half.

Given that this was a direct response to your question of

VOTE: Juls for voting someone for voting for a self-voter.

Why is that even scummy?

I don't think you should need the help. But for others:

Juls voting for Tony PF (who had a good reason for a vote in the early stages)[Tony PF voted Anonis for self-voting] is scummy enough for me to vote Juls.

[TheIrishPope]

TIP, can you just state the point that you are trying to make?

Muffin, well I don't get it.

Those posts were made when I was a Cult Leader. I questioned everything and everyone to appear town. it worked. this is what talah is trying to do. he's scum.
Tony PF is his partner. Quote this when they nightkill me.

While I agree asking a bunch of questions is possibly to look town has possibly the lowest threshold of any potential fake town-tell, Talah's questions did help move the game forward. You have to wait until later in the game to make a fairer judgment on Talah's motives for asking so many questions.

Good analysis of Talah's actions, but a little bit premature in your conclusion.

Qwints, what false dilemma is farside "propounding'?

You see it as premature, I see it as not wasting time.

[Juls]

@qwints - I think voting for a self-voter is stupid. Self voting is stupid, its not a scum tell. We are taught when learning to play Mafia to always vote a self voter but I don't buy it. It is a vote for a stupid person, not for a scum person. Similar to what Agar is proposing. It was a weak attempt/reason to jump on a bandwagon. But I respect your reasoning for voting me. It's a good reason.

@TIP - Do you think talah and qwints can be scum together? Hint: I don't. I can't see scum-qwints defending scum-talah.

[Venmar]

Slam dunk woopidy doo!

Vote: Aronis

[farside22]

Qwints, what false dilemma is farside "propounding'?

pro·pound
transitive verb \prə-ˈpau̇nd\

: to suggest (an idea, theory, etc.) to a person or group of people to consider

This is the false dilemma farside suggested (emphasis added):

Self voter is

either

scummy looking for AtE results

or

frustrated town.

Or I have seen it from both factions.
I asked how do you read it. Obviously you have only read self voters as ??? scum (assuming from you reaction to Tony's vote).

TIP, can you just state the point that you are trying to make?

Muffin, well I don't get it.

Those posts were made when I was a Cult Leader. I questioned everything and everyone to appear town. it worked. this is what talah is trying to do. he's scum.
Tony PF is his partner. Quote this when they nightkill me.

While I agree asking a bunch of questions is possibly to look town has possibly the lowest threshold of any potential fake town-tell, Talah's questions did help move the game forward. You have to wait until later in the game to make a fairer judgment on Talah's motives for asking so many questions.

Good analysis of Talah's actions, but a little bit premature in your conclusion.

Qwints, what false dilemma is farside "propounding'?

You see it as premature, I see it as not wasting time.

I like you. What do you think of Kindom? his comments read to me as asking general questions, not providing much info in his reads and something I can't explain that looks off.

[xRECKONERx]

[

VOTE: Prof Fridays

Why did you make this vote? Because you realise OMGUS is a terrible scumtell usually asserted by scum, right?

No. I voted him because I thought his "in-character" posting was obnoxious.

I've retyped this line because I keep re-interpreting what you said here, so let's play a "Choose Your Own Snarky Comment" game:

If you meant, "Why did you OMGUS Professor Fridays", turn to option (1)! If you meant, "OMGUS is usually performed by scum", go to option (2)! If you meant, "OMGUS is stupid and scum try to push people for it", go to option (3)!

Spoiler: Option 1

are you literally fucking high he was not voting me

Spoiler: Option 2

No. No it's not. Holy fuck no it's not don't ever fucking say that OMGUS is a stupid fucking scumtell please never say that again you are fucking retarded

Spoiler: Option 3

Yes, thank you captain obvious.

[xRECKONERx]

Looked over the last two pages. Aronis looks pretty scummy.

UNVOTE: Prof Fridays

VOTE: Aronis

Aronis (which my ipad will inevitably auto correct to Adonis and I pre apologize) is dumb for the self vote but you are bandwagoning my friend.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Tony PF

Shit. Gotta sheep Juls.

VOTE: Tony PF

[Juls]

Mafiascum needs a like button for posts

+Like on Reckoner's #132

[farside22]

I can tell this will be the best game I have had in a long time. Thank you Reck. I need the laugh.

Damn you people for getting in my way of posting too!

[xRECKONERx]

@qwints - I think voting for a self-voter is stupid. Self voting is stupid, its not a scum tell. We are taught when learning to play Mafia to always vote a self voter but I don't buy it. It is a vote for a stupid person, not for a scum person. Similar to what Agar is proposing. It was a weak attempt/reason to jump on a bandwagon. But I respect your reasoning for voting me. It's a good reason.

this is fantastic, ilu

[xRECKONERx]

Juls voting for Tony PF (who had a good reason for a vote in the early stages)[Tony PF voted Anonis for self-voting] is scummy enough for me to vote Juls.

how is this scummy

seriously, I'm curious why one vote on someone (one justified with thoughtful reasons) is worse than a vote on someone because of bullshit site meta lynches

[TheIrishPope]

@TIP - Do you think talah and qwints can be scum together? Hint: I don't. I can't see scum-qwints defending scum-talah.

What town would defend caught scum with such bad reasoning?

[Venmar]

welp

Vote: Tony PF

never tell me the odds

[farside22]

@TIP - Do you think talah and qwints can be scum together? Hint: I don't. I can't see scum-qwints defending scum-talah.

What town would defend caught scum with such bad reasoning?

A VI?!

*audince cheers "good answer!"

In all seriousness I agree with Juls. I don't think qwints defending Talah is scum together clue. People have beliefs that are not always the same as others.

welp

Vote: Tony PF

never tell me the odds

What did you see that switched your vote?

[qwints]

@reck, it's scummy because Juls looked to be trying to derail an early wagon with a bad reason. That's scummy. I'm about to try and do that with a good reason.

Vote:aronis

Vote: Kublai Khan

Slam dunk woopidy doo!

Vote: Aronis

welp

Vote: Tony PF

never tell me the odds

VOTE: Venmar

[qwints]

In case it's not obvious, voting someone for wagoning tends to defer others from wagonning. And wagonnning early on day 1 is a good thing for town. On a somewhat related note, how many n's does wagonnnning have?

[qwints]

EBWOP: *deter* others from wagonnnnning.

[Juls]

how many n's does wagonnnning have?

2-6 depending on if it's a leap year.

[Venmar]

you're brilliant

A+

Genius

[xRECKONERx]

@TIP - Do you think talah and qwints can be scum together? Hint: I don't. I can't see scum-qwints defending scum-talah.

What town would defend caught scum with such bad reasoning?

[xRECKONERx]

Can someone tell me if qwints is literally saying that scum

purposefully stop wagons from forming D1

and that's why he voted Juls

[TheIrishPope]

qwints being a VI doesn't hold ground since the account's from 2008?

[Venmar]

Oh god, not the date joined = skill level BS again.