NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[kabooooom]

Wait, I'm thinking the same thing as kaboom? No I'm really paranoid...

[Huntress]

Vote Count 5.7

petroleumjelly (4) - Thor665, Aegor, inHimshallibe, HighShroomish
Rainbowdash (4) - Thesp, petroleumjelly, kabooooom, emeraldemon
Thesp (1) - Rainbowdash

Not voting (1) - Sotty7

With ten players alive, it takes six votes to lynch.

Deadline for Day Five is Monday, 14th April 20.00 BST, (in (expired on 2014-04-14 19:00:00)).

[Aegor]

Wait, is an RBD wagon forming? I am totally down with that, too.

VOTE: RBD


That is L-1.

[HighShroomish]

PJ has provided plenty of content. We have other content to examine if PJ flips town, and we are nearing deadline.

I would like someone to hammer unless there is a strong objection.

I'd like to first see kabooooom and Sotty7 answer the question HighShroomish is specifically asking them (even if I haven't the slightest clue why he wants it answered):

@everyone not on the PJ wagon
Say for a minute that the person you're voting is actually town. At this point, do you believe that there is scum on the PJ wagon.

(I think there's an implied answer from kabooooom, but would like confirmation.)

I'm not asking them... I was asking people not on the PJ wagon who were voting someone. sotty was(and still is)n't voting any one, and kab was on the wagon.

[Rainbowdash]

Yeah im not going to play blatant self-preservation here

In order lynch:

Thesp
Thor
Sotty

That should win it, probably tomorrow.

[Thor665]

Why do you town read PJ? PJ is openly admitting to slow and awkward play and his defense is that he'd look better if he was scum - did you know this about him already? Really believe his explanation? Or what?

[Rainbowdash]

Why do you town read PJ? PJ is openly admitting to slow and awkward play and his defense is that he'd look better if he was scum - did you know this about him already? Really believe his explanation? Or what?

To an extent I do believe him about that.

Also I don't think he attacks me and then defends Thesp because if he is scum that feels like a losing strategy. He would be my #4 pick, but I would vote Thesp, Sotty and you over him, and if nothing else I am going to make a point.

If I am reading him right and vote him and he flips town, im basically dead and then especially if its your or Sotty I don't like the position it puts us in. I would rather at least try and make a point, if im right, it may help. If im wrong, we already won either way.

[petroleumjelly]

Unvote: RainbowDash

1.)

Hmph. RainbowDash, can you please convince me you are Town? If you would prefer not to go that route, could you lay out a case for your suspicions?

Also, who are your Townreads and why? I normally do not like to ask players about Townreads in particular, but I tend to recall you focus on Townreads more than you focus on Scumreads.

I know I disagree with you on the Garmr case at the very least. While I

do

think the Bulbazak-Garmr interactions seemed strange/strained, it felt to me more like they had some sort of rivalry that was playing out in this game more than it felt like they are paired in this game. Remember, too, that Garmr actually replaced out (apparently due to his annoyance with Bulbazak).

Finally, how exactly did you miss the modkill on Matias? I have serious troubles believing that, and I think you may well be claiming you missed it because you are aware that had you admitted to seeing it, your lack of argument for No Lynching suggests you purposefully did not bring the subject up because you knew it would help the Town.

2.)

Maybe this is off topic, but I have to ask, is this really the meta you want to set for yourself? As I understand it you're saying that if you seem confident and directed on a replace in, you're probably scum? I will say that the large number of "hard to read" players in your list does you no favors in my eyes, but I'm guessing you don't actually want "can't sort the players" to be a towntell for you.

My "meta" has long been set for myself, and I know how I play.

I can replace in confidently in either alignment, but I can only replace in confidently as Town when (i) I have read the game and/or (ii) I have strong feelings on alignments or current discussion.

[Sotty7]

Sorry - V/LA until tomorrow.

[Thesp]

Rainbowdash, What changed your opinion of me becoming more scummy than Thor? What happened to your suspicion of kabooooom?

[Aegor]

VOTE: PJ

[Rainbowdash]

Rainbowdash, What changed your opinion of me becoming more scummy than Thor? What happened to your suspicion of kabooooom?

Will try and get other things done tonight or tomorrow but these are easy one liner answers because the answer to both is the Bulb flip.

You sitting on his wagon and then trying to bail from it when I started getting votes is why I think you are scum here. The flip didn't make me think Thor is town but you just more scum.

Kab I think is town because I don't see Bulb trying to push a Aegor wagon when the wagons at that point is kab-ABR. I think he just takes one of those wagons and tries to use "it was a counterwagon" to make whoever lived look good and being on a scum lynch to make himself look good. Funny part is typing that out made me more sure of my town read.

Similar reasons as to why Aegor is town.

[kabooooom]

prod dodge. just in case.

[kabooooom]

so times is running out. whom do we lynch. i m not feeling confident in rainbowgul's wagon either.

[HighShroomish]

It's more than likely not gonna be anyone else. Lynch PJ. Plz. He's at L-1.

[kabooooom]

Lets see..

[kabooooom]

Lets see..

[Thesp]

Ummm...you're voting for Rainbowdash.

[Aegor]

OMG please someone hammer.

[kabooooom]

Ummm...you're voting for Rainbowdash.

lets see..

[kabooooom]

[kabooooom]

I actually meant yes I know my vote is on rainbowdash.

[Thesp]

I feel silly - I read HighShroomish's post as if it were yours. That will teach me to play by phone.

[kabooooom]

I feel silly - I read HighShroomish's post as if it were yours. That will teach me to play by phone.

such problems will occur more in phone.

[Huntress]

bump