In post 642, farside22 wrote:Second question: If he was manipulative as scum in a game you were in why would you question his behavior and entrance in the game here?
What are you asking here? For the life of me, I don't get it.
Read the game. I know it's a novel concept and maybe difficult.
Sarcasm is just a way of saying how stupid you think someone is but in a more polite way.
In post 642, farside22 wrote:Second question: If he was manipulative as scum in a game you were in why would you question his behavior and entrance in the game here?
What are you asking here? For the life of me, I don't get it.
Read the game. I know it's a novel concept and maybe difficult.
Well, to me, it's fairly obvious why he questions AJ's behavior and entrance into the game based on his past experience. Perhaps I'm incorrect, but if someone plays a certain way as scum in a game we play together, and exhibits the exact same behavior in a future game, I will likely question it.
In post 642, farside22 wrote:Second question: If he was manipulative as scum in a game you were in why would you question his behavior and entrance in the game here?
What are you asking here? For the life of me, I don't get it.
Read the game. I know it's a novel concept and maybe difficult.
Well, to me, it's fairly obvious why he questions AJ's behavior and entrance into the game based on his past experience. Perhaps I'm incorrect, but if someone plays a certain way as scum in a game we play together, and exhibits the exact same behavior in a future game, I will likely question it.
Private:
Tier stated the following about AJ
In post 637, TierShift wrote:I'm not doing a case. I'm just hammering whoever I think has more chance of flipping scum.
It's just, I'm quite against deadline wagons and I don't think AJ's strong manipulative stances would make much sense as a scum replacement.
I played with AJ once, here: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=35974. He was scum and I was the only one reading him correctly, but I was third party. I can't read him based on meta or something tho.
I think he's being quite manipulative here which he did in the scumgame but might do as town as well.
Tier never questioned aj entrance. He in fact thinks that he would not make an extrance like that as scum. Yet Tier's experience with Aj states that aj was muniplative as scum in a prior game. My point is Tier should have questioned aj's motives more then just fluffing it off.
Sarcasm is just a way of saying how stupid you think someone is but in a more polite way.
Hmm, AJ's play of attacking someone with two votes on them and then WK'ing another player who could potentially vote said player is just too similar to a scum agenda.
VOTE: AJ
If he flips scum, either micc or pri is the partner, leaning PrI with the jklash post I quoted.
So, I'm done with my Comprehensive exam (I passed) and am finally back, so my V/LA is over.
You guys hammered AJ. I guess I'm fine with that, since he's my second highest scumread. I'd still prefer the obvious PrivateI lynch, since HE'S CLEARLY SCUM, WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU GUYS THINKING?
Jklash's english seems very basic to me and usually foregoes commas. That quote just didn't fit, like somebody wrote it for him. But well, I was wrong.
Okay, judging from the day 1 yiley wagon we probably have a privateI-someone team or a farside-absta team. Don't give me shtick for thinking about scumteams, I will anyway.
I got very bad feels from farside's late day 2 play and I'm gonna figure those thoughts out.