Mini 417: Dueling Gods Mafia Over

[Elias_the_thief]

um, we're almost at LYLO videoguy...your willingness to lynch an easily replacable lurker is borderline scummy

Vote Count

As of post 262

Nocmen (2) - Sage, Utnut
Kison (2) - Nocmen, Squirrels
Not voting (4) - The rest of you

Five to lynch!

[Kison]

Unvote

Good point, though. Where is Nocmen? Even before the crash, I don't recall him posting very much.

[videoguy]

That's why I didn't vote, I am just frustrated by the fact we're in D3 and there's someone still unconfirmed. He is replaceable, but he's been replaced once already and nothing happened.

[Great Sir Utnut]

Because he's so underfire, I don't think nocmen would be lurking. I think he's like me, not able to get on a computer all that often. That doesn't change my view about him, though.

We need a replacement for SPandy

[Sage]

I'm here. I have nothing to add.

We should either lynch Nocmen or replace Spandy. Replacing Spandy is probably the higher priority, since Nocmen will still be guilty no matter how long we delay.

[Nocmen]

Actually, I was posting quite alot since before the crash, about the issues that had popped up that still are actually on the thread.

What was on them I cant quite remember, but my memory isnt always the greatest.

[Kison]

Well, I don't recall, then. What I recall is arguing with Elias about his miscounting of votes, and figuring out that the MOD made an error with the vote count at the top of the last page.

[Elias_the_thief]

I agree with kison about that, I dont recall Nocmen posting much before the crash, (twice or thrice at the most) and my recollection of the events before the crash (about our argument) is what I recall as well.

[Sage]

Mod: Replacement please?

[Elias_the_thief]

come on guys, this game is falling apart. I'm still reluctant to lynch Nocmen, but you guys seem set on it. I'd like to at least see some more posts before I place my vote simply for the purpose of advancing the game.

[Kison]

Well, I had wanted to hear more, myself. I was thinking an alternative to Nocmen was feasible, however, given the lack of participation I seem to see myself standing on similar grounds as you.

[Great Sir Utnut]

He may be scum as long as we wait, but the longer we wait, the more damage he'll do. Killing him will be better than replacing him, since then we don't have to worry about an inactive replacement. And why not lynch him.

[Elias_the_thief]

He may be scum as long as we wait, but the longer we wait, the more damage he'll do. Killing him will be better than replacing him, since then we don't have to worry about an inactive replacement. And why not lynch him.

How will waiting for him allow him to deal more damage? Unless he can daykill, then I dont understand your post. The idea is that we want conversation to get a read on other players.

[Elias_the_thief]

by the way, im sorry for my recent absense guys, ive been sick for a while and I still am. After I post this I will return to bed. But you can expect me back in 1-2 days.

[Nocmen]

He may be scum as long as we wait, but the longer we wait, the more damage he'll do. Killing him will be better than replacing him, since then we don't have to worry about an inactive replacement. And why not lynch him.

As Elias just stated, how the hell am I going to do damage as the cop? I dont have any ability to kill, I just go and see if someone is clubs each night. The only damage I can do is prove a clubs guility, and are you saying your clubs and you dont want me finding you guilty?

[Elias_the_thief]

That wasnt exactly the point of my comment. I meant that there was no reason to end the day quickly even if you are mafia, because I highly doubt daykill capabilities. I find Utnut's eagerness to end the day suspicious.

[Great Sir Utnut]

I didn't mean kill him quickly

today

. I meant don't let him survive the night. We don't need to rush our decision, but we should kill him.

[Kison]

Despite my heavy suspicion of Nocmen, Great Sir Utnut just took it to a whole new level(see below). If we decide to make him the play for today, I would be willing to allow Nocmen one more day to get a guilty investigation. I don't see a strong enough reason to go for anyone else over Nocmen, however.

He may be scum as long as we wait, but the longer we wait, the more damage he'll do. Killing him will be better than replacing him, since then we don't have to worry about an inactive replacement. And why not lynch him.

Nocmen had made a post

five

above his. When Elias and I had said something about his activity, it was about

before

the crash, not after. So, as sad as it is that I am defending Nocmen, this is a baseless reason to rush a lynch on him.

I didn't mean kill him quickly

today

. I meant don't let him survive the night.

You don't think we should kill him today, but not let him survive the night. That implies that you think

we

as a

group(?)

should

kill

him tonight. You do realize that only SCUM can kill during the night, don't you?

Oh Lord...

[Great Sir Utnut]

To put what I meant briefly. Don't rush the desicion, but I still think he should be lynched.

[Kison]

And what of you trying to lynch him for inactivity when he wasn't inactive?

[Sage]

I don't believe our mod has posted in the replacement thread for Spags/Sandy.

Mod: Still need replacement. Almost 300 posts and we still have an unconfirmed player

[Great Sir Utnut]

My comment on his inactivity was in response to someoneelse's. It was completelyunrelated.

[Elias_the_thief]

This game is really going nowhere. I might be happy of a deadline at this point, just to get some discussion going. Anyways, I find Utnut more suspicious than nocmen at this point.

vote: utnut

[Great Sir Utnut]

What happens if there's a tie for who gets lynched at the deadline? I'm wondering this only because I want to know how hard to push for nocmen's lynching. If both are lynched, I don't care (I know nocmen's mafia, and I doubt kison is town), but I don't want to let nocmen survive, so if neither are killed, I would really need to push to kill nocmen.

[Elias_the_thief]

i think it results in a no lynch. but refer to the rules, it would probably say there. Im going to after I finish writing this.