NY 168: (GAME OVER) The Mod is Dead, Fire and Ice Edition

[RachMarie]

Vote: Aptil

It was a crappy hammer.

Now, who had Maxous pegged as scum day1?

Also, Merry belated Christmas to everyone!!

Why are crappy hammers scummy?

They are not, always. It depends on how it's done.

Do you really think ice-scum announced their Maxous scumreads and then murdered him? That doesn't seem like good multiscum play to me.

Well, I think a player found Maxous scummy, and said it in the thread. Probably only once, maybe twice at the most. When they realized they couldn't get him lynched, they shut up, because they then figured they would NK him instead.
Granted, this is only speculation, and maybe it was an Ice member that Maxous called scum instead. But, it's a criteria to look for.

Vote: Desparado

Sorry you got a scum role this game.

You are telling me someone suggesting they don't know it is multiball makes them town. I am saying that actually scum wouldn't come into the game acting like they know it is multiball.

But isn't it a distinct disadvantage for scum to come into a game advertised and titled as multiball and act like it isn't? At best it makes them stand out; at worst it makes it obvious they're only hunting for one opposing group.

Vote: Desparado

Sorry you got a scum role this game.

This is the first non-RVS Desperado vote all game. Explain it.

Vote: Desparado

Sorry you got a scum role this game.

How did you come to that conclusion ?

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?a ... 9&sr=posts

You are telling me someone suggesting they don't know it is multiball makes them town. I am saying that actually scum wouldn't come into the game acting like they know it is multiball.

But isn't it a distinct disadvantage for scum to come into a game advertised and titled as multiball and act like it isn't? At best it makes them stand out; at worst it makes it obvious they're only hunting for one opposing group.

Vote: Desparado

Sorry you got a scum role this game.

This is the first non-RVS Desperado vote all game. Explain it.

Vote: Desparado

Sorry you got a scum role this game.

How did you come to that conclusion ?

http://forum.mafiascum.net/search.php?a ... 9&sr=posts

This is a very bad way to answer a question . You are trying to be a smartass here .
What posts made you feel like he is scum ? What contents from a post ? Is it that you feel every word of his was scummy ?

Not being a smartass, but I thought it was self-evident.

Deparado's last post in this game was 5 days 5 hours ago.
Over the course of that time he made 41 posts in 5 other game threads, and 2 non-game threads.
One of those threads is also in New York.

So either he "forgot" about this game over the course of one day, or he's ignoring the thread because he's scum and is hoping to not post.

Of course, there is also other reasons also, which you may now present as to why the above postings have taken place elsewhere but not here.

Hey people, I should be caught up soon. Let me know if there's anything in particular you want me to address.

scum Deparado
scum Yuni
scum Gamerantz

Mastins alignment

Points at Des mostly for posting in other places on site but not in this game. Sounds like bussing a bit to me.

Especially with the next few posts.

[RachMarie]

feel pretty good about PA and Slaan being town.

This makes Rach Firescum just so everyone knows.

From Firescum perspective when Pacman is confirmed Icescum I look very town because I am not Icescum with Pacman (obviously). Firescum know I am not Firescum (again obviously) hence Firescum will view me as town when they can see I am not Ice which is what has happened here as we get my name lumped in with PA's in her townreads out of nowhere.

You had me at Rachscum.

Vote: RachMarie

Back and not much to change this. Would also vote Desp.

As for Pere his reasoning to vote for me was based on some statements Slaan made early on, sheeping him just on that even though Slaan had not even voted for me just made statements.

So yeah feel pretty good about Aptil and Pere being scum.

Not even sure what this means, but pretty sure that's not the reason you're scum.

But, let's talk about Desp instead. Is he town, ice scum or fire scum?

Why are you white knighting Aptil so much Slaan?

That is not what he said. Yes I did talk about hammers but I did not only complain about hammers. I also did one of the hammers.

Meanwhile I still think Aptil is scum I also think Pere is scum.

Pere as for who is fire and who is ice I really dont know that yet, other than the flipped read. I am just trying to find scum cause whether they are fire or ice they are still scum and we need them gone. Do you have anything else besides Rach is scum and asking me about Des?

I have to find scum one at time.

I suspect one of them might be you.

I suspect another might be Desp.

I'd like to hear what you think about Desp.

He might be, I am not sure because I have misread him every time I have played with him save for the time we were both scum together, then I knew his alignment.

So, when you are scum together, you knew he was scum, so didn't have to read him.

And otherwsie, you are saying he was the opposite of whatever you read him?

Then, problem solved! You give us your Desp read and we will assume the opposite.

Unless of course his play matches the time you were scum together.

Sweet, sweet hammer.

If Desp flips scum then RachMarie is on his team.

Vote: Desparado

Fire would give us a few extra days.

ok

Don't suppose you want to share your team's ICE suspects?

Then TSO is conf. town. He neighborized me n1.

I'm guessing since TSO did not refute this, this is true.

That really leaves Bulba, Rach, and NJAC for scum.

@TSO- Thoughts on Bulba from QT posts please.

Re: Rach- I was thinking fire scum from her Desp stuff from before.

re: NJAC- I didn't have much a scumread (or townread for that matter), but I know others did yesterday.

re: Bulba- leaning town, but want to hear from TSO before cementing this read.

Still leaning Rach, but I kind of want to look at the NK to see why each team picked who they did.

Vote: RachMarie

I stand by my vanished posts.

@Rach

- thank you for again for the time-warped happy scumday wish!

A lot of back and forth on me and Des, like bussing and distancing from him and at the same time trying to pin it on someone else hoping Des did not get lynched.

The whole fire comment seemed odd too, from a town PoV, scum is scum and it does not matter if it is ice or fire scum they are ALL scum and to be lynched.

Tries to make far more of what was clearly my dry sense of humor about not being able to read Des for shit.

Asks about Ice suspects not Fire suspects.

He seems to care more about lynching Ice than Fire.

yep I was right

VOTE: Pere

[RachMarie]

Sorry about the walls there was a lot of stuff to go through

[Bulbazak]

Vote: Aptil

It was a crappy hammer.

Now, who had Maxous pegged as scum day1?

Also, Merry belated Christmas to everyone!!

Why are crappy hammers scummy?

They are not, always. It depends on how it's done.

Do you really think ice-scum announced their Maxous scumreads and then murdered him? That doesn't seem like good multiscum play to me.

Well, I think a player found Maxous scummy, and said it in the thread. Probably only once, maybe twice at the most. When they realized they couldn't get him lynched, they shut up, because they then figured they would NK him instead.
Granted, this is only speculation, and maybe it was an Ice member that Maxous called scum instead. But, it's a criteria to look for.

The sum of Antihero posts were to vote Dry fit and accuse Toomai.

Why does that earn him death?

Also, slowbrain now, but Maxous' group was the one that shot Antihero.

Pere's interactions with or about Maxous.

Not much here but it does seem odd that he was asking so much about who found Maxous scummy instead of focusing more on living players.

Pere is town and has been scumhunting both teams equally.

[Bulbazak]

Ugh.... I ignore that quote in my post. I was going to respond to it and then decided to just respond to everything in general.

[RachMarie]

Where did everyone go?

[RachMarie]

Mods could we have an updated VC and could you prod NJAC he seems to have gone missing

[Bulbazak]

I'm trying to decide how likely it is that Rach would skip the Garmr entrance into the day and subsequent modkill and flip. I'd hate for her to win by feigning ignorance.

[PeregrineV]

Where did everyone go?

See, here's my issues.

me- got a town PM
TSO- confirmed neighbor by Bulba. Since I think it's 3/3, confirmed town.
Bulba- Didn't have out TSO and thereby confirm him, Very most likely town.

That leaves

NJAC- who I think is scummy, but it's more overall play instead of anything specicifc.
you (Rach)- Your distancing from Desp was the most telling thing to me.

So, pretend you are me. My choices are NJAC and you. Why would NJAC be scum over you?

You make a case for that, and we'll talk. Otherwise, quoting my posts doesn't do anything for me.

[T S O]

I'm trying to decide how likely it is that Rach would skip the Garmr entrance into the day and subsequent modkill and flip. I'd hate for her to win by feigning ignorance.

I thought it seemed a little desperate when she made a PV case, then went straight back and made an NJAC case.

[T S O]

mmmgh, I have a flu and it's not even funny how badly I'm feeling atm. I'll try, but it could be a while til I'm back.

[RachMarie]

I made a case on BOTH of them TSO, but I felt that NJAC was more likely to be ice than fire which is why I went back to Pere, when I realized I screwed up on the number of Ice (due to mixing Garmr and Zek up).

Zek BTW has been banned for his nonsense. And without going into detail in an ongoing game, I was dealing with Zek in TWO games, plus I am used to Garmr playing better than that. I am sorry I got them mixed up.

[RachMarie]

Pere I made a joke that is all I was not distancing myself from Des if you want I can find the link where we were scum budz

[RachMarie]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=30724 Xenogears Both Des and I were scum here.

[Bulbazak]

Why did NJAC have to be ice scum?

[JacobSavage]

Votecount 6.1

0

1

2

3

RachMarie [2]

- PeregrineV, Bulbazak

[L-1]

PeregrineV [1]

- RachMarie

Not Voting [2]

- T S O, NJAC

With 5 alive, it takes

3[/i]

votes to lynch.

Deadline falls on 10^th March 2014 at 1000 GMT ((expired on 2014-03-10 10:00:00))

Prodding NJAC

[PeregrineV]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=30724 Xenogears Both Des and I were scum here.

I'll look through it, time permitting.

Unvote.

JIC

[JacobSavage]

Starting to look for replacement for NJAC in (expired on 2014-03-07 17:18:00)

T S O has been prodded and has (expired on 2014-03-08 17:51:40)

[RachMarie]

oh this is peachy bah


I have been sick but basically my case on NJAC seemed to fit better as ice scum, bulb.

However I am more than willing to vote for him, because I do realize that I may be missing something, he still feels like scum so could be fire scum.

VOTE: NJAC

[Nomen Nescio]

/confirm

[JacobSavage]

Bulbazak has been prodded

[Bulbazak]

I'm still good with a Rach lynch. That is all.

[T S O]

hi yo

[RachMarie]

Come on guys this is absurd I have been sick and I have posted more.

Are we getting a replacement for NJAC?

Bulb why would you be ok with lynching me? Do you have something like a case?

I feel pretty good about you and TSO being town.

I still feel its likely the last scum is tween Pere and NJAC/Replacement. NJAC seems to be a stronger read and as I said I may have made mistakes about him being more icy than fire.

I know I am town.

[JacobSavage]

Are we getting a replacement for NJAC?

Yes you are, searching currently