Mini 415 - Basic Mafia -- MOD ABANDONED

[IH]

FoS:Lowell

Seriously man. Logic process is needed.

[Lowell]

Prod received. Nothing to add at the moment. Give me a few days.

[King of Mud]

Kinkster, Riverwind, you both asked for my proof and here it is:

Page 1: Voting for each other; partly random, partly OMGUS, but they both make a fairly big deal about it.

Page 2: Right after I said I was confused they both posted saying they were confused. They then both attack Theo when he goes after Kinkster. The two even have the same trouble closing their quote tags.

Page 3: Kinkster attacks Brewski when he accuses the two of being scum, Riverwind attacks me.

Page 4: Nothing tying the two together.

Page 5: The two attack my theory for lack of evidence. Kinkster incorrectly claims it's based "primarily" on his original vote.

So, either these guys are just a case of great minds thinking alike, or they're trying to reinforce each others points while appearing to distance themselves with the original bussing. That's why I'd be happy lynching one or the other today.

[kinkster]

Page 1: Voting for each other; partly random, partly OMGUS, but they both make a fairly big deal about it.

its a random vote thats about all i can comment on as it was nothing more than laying vote down.

Page 2: Right after I said I was confused they both posted saying they were confused. They then both attack Theo when he goes after Kinkster. The two even have the same trouble closing their quote tags.

I was actually agreeing with you noone else so if anything page 2 links me with you. And as for the quote tags thats just ludicrous

Page 3: Kinkster attacks Brewski when he accuses the two of being scum, Riverwind attacks me

So were linked because we attcked different people,, erm sorry really dont get that

Page 5: The two attack my theory for lack of evidence. Kinkster incorrectly claims it's based "primarily" on his original vote

Before this post I had nothing else to assume, of course I'm going to coment on an accusation that you hadnt justified. At the time there was a lack of evidence on your part.

Also if you attack 2 people you have to expect 2 people to defend themselves. If you had of attacked just me and Riverwind would have jumped in then that would have been sus, but you attacked both of us so expect both of us to comment.

I get the feeling your genuinly trying to peice together info for the greater good at the moment. But on the same token you also seem to be trying to shoe horn it together to make it sound feasable.

[King of Mud]

Page 2: Right after I said I was confused they both posted saying they were confused. They then both attack Theo when he goes after Kinkster. The two even have the same trouble closing their quote tags.

I was actually agreeing with you noone else so if anything page 2 links me with you. And as for the quote tags thats just ludicrous

Except that Riverwind posted right after you also saying he was confused. That timing seems like he's following your lead. And don't forget him counter-attacking Theo for you.

Page 3: Kinkster attacks Brewski when he accuses the two of being scum, Riverwind attacks me

So were linked because we attcked different people,, erm sorry really dont get that

Division of labor. If Alice and Bob launch attacks on Craig and David, you expect C to defend himself against A and B and D to defend himself against A and B. However, you focused exclusively on Brewski and Riverwind focused exclusively on me until y'all got Brewski on the defensive. That indicates you and Riverwind split up this job, that is that you conspired.

Also if you attack 2 people you have to expect 2 people to defend themselves. If you had of attacked just me and Riverwind would have jumped in then that would have been sus, but you attacked both of us so expect both of us to comment.

So, how do you explain Riverwind attacking Theo on page 2, and you guys splitting up your counter-attacks on page 3?

[Riverwind23]

wow. that is the biggest load of bs i've ever seen. i applaud your illogical thinking.
wait no i don't.

kinkster said he was confused about a post(agreeing with you i might add) and i was confused about wth was going on in the game in general. i get on once a day during normal weeks, if i post after him it is because

that's when i get on

i don't even understand what that has to do with anything.

theo is incredebly illogical, much like yourself. if someone spews crap(like yourself) then you call them down for it.

FoS: king of mud

for making up completly irrelevant evidence that never existed in the first place.

[theopor_COD]

theo is incredebly illogical, much like yourself. if someone spews crap(like yourself) then you call them down for it.

Erm page two I tend not to worry about logic too much, but that's just me, my actions on the first pages were totally random. I'd need to re-read the thread to decide what I think of this little argument.

[Jules]

Ixnayonthehombre has read PM but hasn't responded. I'll be looking for a replacement if we've not heard anything by the time the weekend's over

[Riverwind23]

theo is incredebly illogical, much like yourself. if someone spews crap(like yourself) then you call them down for it.

Erm page two I tend not to worry about logic too much, but that's just me, my actions on the first pages were totally random. I'd need to re-read the thread to decide what I think of this little argument.

uh, it wasn't an argument. i was just trying to make a point.

[theopor_COD]

well,

i am tired of the day dragging

. I still have a feeling that kinkster is guilty, but i am to tired right now to do a reread and vote count to see where he is at. I would like to hear from him what his defense is against the accusations that he has recieved.

I will post tomorrow

after a reread, and hopefully, that will get the game moving, and will show why i think that we should lynch kinkster. Till next time...

Brewski's last post. 9 days ago. A few points I've bolded for easy to read sake. Now I'm not sure if this current wagon is on scum, but his dissapearance is slightly alarming, which makes me think it may well be on scum. Either way this game is slower than me in 110m hurdles. Brewski pls pipe up infact can everyone do something interesting.

[King of Mud]

I'm tired of this Kinkster-Riverwind thing and I'm going to drop it if no one else is going to comment. It's really annoying to post all my reasons and evidence, and have to respond to them just saying "Nuh-uh!" over and over. What's especially annoying is they never addressed all my evidence, they just picked out a few things to which they could offer reasonable explanations. I'm switching to Brewski just to get this over with.

Unvote

Vote: Brewski

[Riverwind23]

that should never be your motive for a lynch. back up any vote with evidence( it doesn't matter who came up with the evidence, just use it.)

[theopor_COD]

You know 1) I'm not really into this game 2) I don't like that vote from KoM one bit.

Being as Brewski's dissapeared we ought not to lynch him without hearing from him. I'll

unvote, vote KOM

. I'm still pretty wary of Brewski but switching a vote to get it over with is incredibly scummy in my eyes.

[Lowell]

Good move theo. You'll see.

[King of Mud]

Unovte

I apologize, that was just a frustration vote. I've got no reason to suspect brewski.

Lowell, people have been asking for you to explain yourself for about a week now, would you care to do that soon? I'd at least like to be able to be able to argue against your accusation.

[Jules]

Vote Count

brewski (3): kinkster, IH, Ixnayonthehombre

kinkster (1): Riverwind23

King of Mud (1): theopor_COD

Not voting (5): brewski, Eldarion, Nocmen, bird1111, Lowell, King of Mud

11 alive, 6 to lynch

[King of Mud]

Mod

I've

unvoted

.

[Jules]

Skruffs replaces Ixnayonthehombre

[Skruffs]

Ooooh crap. It's me.
howdy.

[kinkster]

Ooooh crap. It's me.
howdy.

welcome

can we have some prods and maybe even a deadline 1 month to get through day1 is a tad slow.

[Skruffs]

Gimme at least a day to read through
Teh great stuff about newbie scum is that they make sooo many mistakes

[IH]

Yo Yo Skruffs!

I'm suddenly interested in this game!

Good move theo. You'll see.

Secret scumtells suck.

unvote, vote:Lowell

[Lowell]

All right to appease the masses. Here's my reason for being right about KoM...


ALL HIS POSTS ARE SCUMMY!!!

Look at them in isolation and tell me that guy isn't scum. Seriously, people.



IH, pretend secret scumtells suck worse. Vote someone else.

[bird1111]

Lowell, examples?

Vote: Brewski

; still think he's our best shot at scum

[Skruffs]

brewski, kinkster, king of mud.. are we at a frat party or something?

riverwind seems like town, if he's scum i think he is with kingster... brewster is playing passively and watching others.. eldarion is maybe scum... king of mud seems to base a lot on perceived 'slips' - looking directly at what people say, not so mcuh what the people are tryign to accompolish...
Theo strikes me as something but I don't know what yet.
IH is IH.
I'm liking Nocman.