Mini 1537: ATTACK ON TITAN (Game Over!)

[Kazekirimaru]

But I want to hear his fakeclaim D:

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

I just don't think you-BRO is going anywhere. You're town and Bro's up in the air and there's nothing he could say that will change that.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

Where the fuck is mastin anyway. He hasn't checked in from day start.

[Paschendale]

I'm not fucking scum, pie. I'm never fucking scum and you're always fucking wrong when you read me. Get the fuck out of my face and push someone worthwhile before I find some way to reach through the internet and tear your fucking eyes out.

oh no I'm really scared
srsly, why so defensive? it's literally just me and Pasch (who you think is scum) on you and it's not looking like anyone else wants to lynch you today

like does anyone else think this post seems fake or is it just me

Kinda, yeah. Especially since the next sentence in it was a call to analyze stuff from day 1, which Kaze has not actually done. He seems quite content to vote just based on Bert's hammer and ignore everything else. This seems like a scum move to me. Get everyone to react emotionally on a single piece of information and ignore anything that might be helpful in making a more informed decision. That's actually really scummy.

Also, I'm really not interested in all this lovers and who's confirmed to who stuff. I'd rather evaluate based on actual evidence, rather than just off of who I think is telling the truth about vague claims.

Bro's comment that Tammy usually AtE's as town is probably the most compelling thing out of this whole argument, and it's a lousy bit of meta, and I don't like those.

I don't like the idea of the massclaim, as I've been against all this willy nilly claiming already. I've never really seen a massclaim sway the game for town. Maybe I've just been really unlucky in games where it's happened, but it looks like it does more harm than good to me.

Peedit: Fine, massclaim. Maybe then we can stop talking about roles and scumhunt.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

You're not going to enjoy me Pasch. Day two mass claim is like my bread and butter.

[Tammy]

Bro's comment that Tammy usually AtE's as town is probably the most compelling thing out of this whole argument, and it's a lousy bit of meta, and I don't like those.

that actually is lousy meta and not compelling at all.

[Kazekirimaru]

Kinda, yeah. Especially since the next sentence in it was a call to analyze stuff from day 1, which Kaze has not actually done. He seems quite content to vote just based on Bert's hammer and ignore everything else. This seems like a scum move to me. Get everyone to react emotionally on a single piece of information and ignore anything that might be helpful in making a more informed decision. That's actually really scummy.

I haven't analyzed what happened Day 1? Are you serious?

[Paschendale]

Bro's comment that Tammy usually AtE's as town is probably the most compelling thing out of this whole argument, and it's a lousy bit of meta, and I don't like those.

that actually is lousy meta and not compelling at all.

I know. It feels like everyone is doing everything but trying to find scum.

[pitoli]

VOTECOUNT 2.3

Kazekirimaru (2):

pieguyn, Paschendale

Tammy (1):

: BROseidon

Bert (3):

Kazekirimaru, kthxbye, Kagami

Mastin2 (1):

Rancid Broderick Drake

BROseidon (1):

Tammy

Not Voting (3)

: mastin2, Brian Skies, Bert

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2014-02-01 00:00:00)

Mod Comments:

[Kagami]

Pasch, do you not realize the extent to which your claim has found scum? Do you really think you were role-blocked?

Roles are apparently superbly important here for finding scum. From what we can tell, many players "know" each others' alignment, though a large number of them don't want to reveal why for ~reasons~. If all the claims are to be believed, there are a set of best friends, as well as a one-directional best friends, all on top of a JoAT and a flavor cop, all on top of 8ish one-shot commuters, which is absurdly town-sided, even if the neighborhoods/neighborizer is given zero town-weight. Something is amiss.

[Kagami]

@mod: if, hypothetically, a player with an active ability were to fail because of a roleblock, would that player receive notification that the ability were blocked? What if it failed due to the target being an ascetic or commuter?

[Kagami]

as an aside, I think both tammy and kaze are town.

[pieguyn]

what do you think of how he asked why neither of the pseudo-masons died then when I gave an explanation he didn't seem at all interested in it?

and you think the F-16 wagon was entirely town driven?

[Kazekirimaru]

You never gave an explanation. You just quoted my question and said something like "HAH GOTCHA" or whatever.

[pieguyn]

also that NK seems weird as hell. Dan probably crumbed a PR somewhere and scum found it. and who saw it?

Dan Town. Mostly a gut-read and because a little birdie told me so.

dingdingding

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

as an aside, I think both tammy and kaze are town.

Do you think there is scum in our neighborhood?

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

@BRO,

Aaaaaaaaaargh, I be a bit disappointed in ye. Ye had the makings of a fine sailor, but ye been veering off course towards the storm when yer Cap'n tell ye, "HARD STARBOARD!"

[Kagami]

as an aside, I think both tammy and kaze are town.

Do you think there is scum in our neighborhood?

I would have guessed so, but it's not unthinkable that 3 town were in the neighborhood with flavor or whatever leading you guys to suspect each other as a form of negative utility. So far, I don't have scummy feelings coming from the neighborhood.

[Kagami]

what do you think of how he asked why neither of the pseudo-masons died then when I gave an explanation he didn't seem at all interested in it?

and you think the F-16 wagon was entirely town driven?

Yes, I think mastin is very likely scum, and the wagon on his slot was town-driven.

[Kazekirimaru]

also that NK seems weird as hell. Dan probably crumbed a PR somewhere and scum found it. and who saw it?

Dan Town. Mostly a gut-read and because a little birdie told me so.

dingdingding

Alright, cool? There were plenty of "I know this guy is town"s in more obvious fashion yesterday. I don't understand why Dan got killed over the louder two "conftowns" yesterday. Still.

[Kthxbye]

Bro and I are not lovers but we are linked similarly. Thing about our link is, it makes less sense and would be more imbalanced than lovers if we were scum-town pair....at least I think so. Will explain in more detail when popcorn comes our way. Speaking of, do we have a list going of all the claims and who's up next yet?

[BROseidon]

@BRO,

Aaaaaaaaaargh, I be a bit disappointed in ye. Ye had the makings of a fine sailor, but ye been veering off course towards the storm when yer Cap'n tell ye, "HARD STARBOARD!"

1) I hate your stupid pirate schtick. It makes me want to ram a rusty nail up my urethra.

2) I'm apparently the only one trying to find scum and not circle jerking around in circles.

3) Tammy, that is valid meta on you and you fucking know it.

[BROseidon]

mastin's up next, although at this rate he'll get replaced...

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

1) I hate your stupid pirate schtick. It makes me want to ram a rusty nail up my urethra

Aaaaaaaargh, I'd not do that if I were ye. You might get an infection, and me crew has no medical cover. Well, I mean, we have rum, but I'm not sure it works well as medicine. But it can make ye forget about the rusty nail in yer third peg leg.

2) I'm apparently the only one trying to find scum and not circle jerking around in circles.

Good luck with that, skipper. I have faith ye'll win the game for us.

[Bert]

Aaaaaaaaaaaargh, ye pirate speak is growing on me, although me stay here is nearing its end

I like ye pirates, can I join yer crew?