Mini 1524: Olympian Gods Mafia - Game Over

[shos]

Either way before we lynch eagle shpuld say his target on case he survives. I suggest nacho.

[shos]

Or me lol what am i thinking

[Desperado]

Mirari, Kise, Bald, Fitz all town via claim

+

Nacho and Whiskers town via play

= shos/Titus scum

Ok this vote is just bad and you should feel bad. Shos is OMGUSing, but your theory requires me to A) push ika hard and then push my other scum buddy hard in the same day to possibly no benefit of being confirmed town. There was no one else I wanted to really push yesterday. Your theory sucks major.

My theory has almost nothing to do with you or your play, so if you're going to try and discredit it, you either need to: case Nacho or Whiskers as scum, or tell me which pair of claims is fake. Otherwise, my hands are pretty much tied.

[1baldeagle1]

Alright, I'm assuming that we are doing the plan tonight and I'll start thinking of some possible people to target for tonight.

Feel free to tell me some suggestions.

[Kise]

I recommend eagle targeting Desp or Nacho tonight. If he's scum and we somehow go on a mislynch train, eagle will end up alive with 2 out of Nacho/Desp/Whisker (maybe shos if you don't get killed) being his targets in 2 days and thus proving they aren't scum but he is.

shos could be lying but I dunno, I like his role and the way he went about claiming it. Doesn't seem like the mod spoon fed him a fake claim, and he just doesn't seem like the type to come up with something complicated. It doesn't matter much because eagle will end up dying or living with too many people he cleared.

Before Titus is hammered, eagle needs to announce his target just in case he and someone else dies tonight. If only eagle is killed, scum decided to waste their kill by framing someone.

pedit, I say one of Nacho or Desp. Desp seems confident Nacho is town so he's probably more likely the scum out of those two. I'm not that high on Nacho > Desp, but yeah Desp.

[Elyse]

Votecount 3.02

Kise - 1 - havingfitz (L-4)
Titus - 3 - shos, Desperado, Whiskers (L-2)

Not Voting - Kise, Nachomamma8, Titus, 1baldeagle1, Mirari

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Deadline: (expired on 2014-01-25 22:00:00)

Interesting Fact #41: Achilles accidentally killed Chiron, his centaur instructor, by shooting him with an arrow.

[Nachomamma8]

Since we are claimed I want a mass claim stat.
Nacho first and then desperado.

Shos, it is Day 3, where is your night 2 information?

I'm a bomb; will take whoever kills me during the night to the grave with me.

PoE leaves me with Kise or Nacho.

Didn't you read the mason claim...?

[Nachomamma8]

But yeah, masons make this game extraordinarily easy.
shos's claim sticks out pretty harshly, though; everyone else seems to have a pretty straightforward ability and then boom, shos. I agree that it would be the weirdest fakeclaim that I've ever seen, though.

[shos]

why does it stick out to you? it's really not that extraordinary.

It seems like there's a concensus of eagle targetting nacho tonight. I'd rather not have des because via poe he could definitely be scum. eagle dying tonight WITH a mason death withh give us a confirmed scum, but itll also reduce to 6 players, meaning that we lynch scum - they kill another mason - it's 4p mylo with 1 conftown(I think).

TLDR I agree to a nacho investigation. disagree to des investigation.

[Kise]

Well if Titus is scum and eagle's death confirms the next scum, that's game. Or do you not believe Titus will flip scum?

[shos]

If titus is scum then its pretty sure eagle will die anyway.

[Kise]

ok but the way you made this post doesn't relay that you're accounting/believing Titus will flip scum

It seems like there's a concensus of eagle targetting nacho tonight. I'd rather not have des because via poe he could definitely be scum. eagle dying tonight WITH a mason death withh give us a confirmed scum, but itll also reduce to 6 players, meaning that we lynch scum - they kill another mason - it's 4p mylo with 1 conftown(I think).

You don't want eagle targeting Des because he'd probably die. You say we lynch Des (confscum via eagle dying) and we're in 4p mylo. If Titus is scum and Des is scum, there is no mylo.

See?

[shos]

You make me smile.

Imo if titus is scum this game is over. All the further specs are for the case he is not. How can we lose if he is? If he dies then scumpartner shoots eagle. Three conftowns not Including me, seven alive, so i have no hesitation.

[shos]

And if eagle doesnt die then he clears up people and if he confirms everyone then he is scum. Reaaaal easy. The only problem is uf *I* am lynched, lol.

[Titus]

Since we are claimed I want a mass claim stat.
Nacho first and then desperado.

Shos, it is Day 3, where is your night 2 information?

I'm a bomb; will take whoever kills me during the night to the grave with me.

PoE leaves me with Kise or Nacho.

Didn't you read the mason claim...?

What mason claim?

There is probably nothing I can do here given my busy schedule. Yet this train is not based in play or reason at all. I handed the group ika.

Nacho's claim is a scumclaim explaining why he is alive so long.

I will provide more tomorrow if not lynched.

[shos]

Omfg titus read the game please.
And you cant take credit for ika, you were hardly the cause for his lynch. I was probably the only one townreading him.
Re:nacho- are you suggesting that scum would have killed him by now? Last i checked they killed watcher and qtcop, why shoot an unclaimed unconfirmed?

[Whiskers]

I was pushing Ika's slot since before you were BORN.

[shos]

^^^is true but lol at BORN

[shos]

can we wait, though, before titus is bussed, to get a confirmation from mirari that indeed they are masons?

[shos]

remember there's an option that the masons are scum together in a preplanned idea...remember they have daytalk..

[Desperado]

Why the fuck would the remaining two scum claim masons together when they still need three mislynches to win? There's no way they'd be able to explain why they're both still alive three in LYLO.

[havingfitz]

OK...catching up from Monday:
 
@Titus...no shit someone pushing Mala was scum.  D1 there were 7 people pushing Mala.  Don't recall who pushed her D2 (if anyone).  Who's scum?  Agreed shos is suspect...but not sure I suspect him more than Titus...or even Eagle.
 
@Desperado...so Nacho is town because he was wrong about scum....and you're ok that he was wrong about penguin (D1) and me (D2)?  Worst town annointment ever.
 
Eagle....why the fuck didn't you protect Mala?  Question to all.....how did scum know Eagle wasn't going to protect Mala?  If they had shot Eagle then I would have been square in town's crosshairs today.  How do you know you weren't RB'd Eagle?  On that note...why would scum RB Eagle and kill Mala when they could have just as easily RB'd Mala and killed Eagle...thus implicating me. 
 

tl:dr;

I think Eagle is probably scum.
 
shos claim looks legit to me.
 
So if Kise and Mirari have a QT
and Wisdom was ascetic
and Whiskers, Titus and I are all neighbors
and Eagle is a virgin
and penguin could commute
....that only leaves two people (three is penguin had chose not to commute...but assume she would have with only 2 chances) who could come back as a not having a QT if Mala investigated them.  Everyone else had a legitimate reason to have a QT or a legitimate reason why Mala wouldn't get a result from them.  So once again....why kill Mala?  The only two people she would have investigated would have been Nacho or Desperado.  I think that implicates one of them in Mala's death.  I'm starting to think there are two scum within: Titus, Eagle, Nacho and Desp.  Desperado is probably last on that list because of his claim.  Desperado...if you were lynched or NK'd would your PM votes show up in the mod's votecounts?
 
UNVOTE: Kise
 
@Titus...trying to discredit shos' claim is absurd.  You seriously think he went back and found that crumb randomly?
 
VOTE: Titus
 
@shos...Eagle is not confirmed town.  And neither am I actually unless Eagle is killed/lynched and flips town (ignoring the possibility for RBing).  So Eagle is not confirm town.
 
Post 3279 makes me feel better about unvoting Kise.
 
Post 3281 is a claim that doesn't instill belief IMO.  I'm ok with suspicions directed at Nacho.
 

Titus is at L-1.

[Desperado]

@Desperado...so Nacho is town because he was wrong about scum....and you're ok that he was wrong about penguin (D1) and me (D2)?  Worst town annointment ever.

I was wrong about Penguin too and you haven't flipped yet. Do you think Nacho is scum?

[havingfitz]

I said he could be in my last post.....

[Desperado]

Desperado...if you were lynched or NK'd would your PM votes show up in the mod's votecounts?

Yeah, Elyse will post my votes in thread and they will count.