The New Set-Up Review Thread

[Antihero]

I need someone who's run a Large theme game before to review my 17-p Organic Chemistry Mafia. It'll be similar to my micro in that it will be inventor-heavy.

Thanks in advance.

[esternogligent]

Not sure if I need to play a few games on here first, but I have a large general-themed game I want reviewed and would like to host.

Werewolf themed.
18+ players

I have 5+ years of IRL mafia party game experience (live, face-to-face), and 1+ year of online forum mafia experience (about 10 games).

[Espeonage]

I have a 13p Pokemon themed game. It's safe from massclaim as far as I can see atm, but I'm worried about my balance. Any help would be appreciated. I haven't modded in a fair while.

[callforjudgement]

Not sure if I need to play a few games on here first, but I have a large general-themed game I want reviewed and would like to host.

Werewolf themed.
18+ players

I have 5+ years of IRL mafia party game experience (live, face-to-face), and 1+ year of online forum mafia experience (about 10 games).

You'll need to play at least one game here and wait three months before you can moderate (the playing at least one game is to get acquainted with how we do things here, because it can be different from other forums). You'd also need more moderator experience before you could run a Large Normal (and your game might or might not count as Normal by our definitions; it'd depend on the details).

[Antihero]

I need someone who's run a Large theme game before to review my 17-p Organic Chemistry Mafia. It'll be similar to my micro in that it will be inventor-heavy.

Thanks in advance.

Still need this.

Please, thank you, all the other magic words...

[esternogligent]

Not sure if I need to play a few games on here first, but I have a large general-themed game I want reviewed and would like to host.

Werewolf themed.
18+ players

I have 5+ years of IRL mafia party game experience (live, face-to-face), and 1+ year of online forum mafia experience (about 10 games).

You'll need to play at least one game here and wait three months before you can moderate (the playing at least one game is to get acquainted with how we do things here, because it can be different from other forums). You'd also need more moderator experience before you could run a Large Normal (and your game might or might not count as Normal by our definitions; it'd depend on the details).

I'm sure it'll take me awhile to iron out the roles anyway. Just wanted to get a head start on feedback.
I gotta make sure I dont overlap games with the other forum and I'll sign up for one here!

My game should count as normal based on this:

The game should have at least one Mafia or Werewolf group (of at least two members). A second anti-town group can be given a separate Mafia family name, or can be a Werewolf group. There should be no more than two mafia/werewolf factions, and no more than one Serial Killer.

It will be a three-faction game.
One thing that could help... could you link to any good examples of dual-mafia games on here that show the setup?

[JasonWazza]

One thing that could help... could you link to any good examples of dual-mafia games on here that show the setup?

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=53&t=25357

That's one that i still remember well (though that may be more because i was so close to a win.) and it used 2 factions.

However one thing to note, is that most "Normal" games tend to be less Power Role based (though that may be more my experience)

[Plum]

Looking for a reviewer or two for

The Fall of Gondolin Mafia

, a Large Theme for 17 players and follow-up to Lay of Leithian Mafia and The Children of Húrin Mafia. Theme knowledge won't hurt but isn't necessary.

[BolteAltamont]

Modding a chess-themed game with some weird mechanics on a different site that needs to be reviewed. PM if interested.

[Ms Marangal]

I'm looking for one or two more experienced reviewers for Christianity Mafia, 21P themed and bastard.

it's pretty crazy, and even faraday is a little over-whelmed...

PM me, or TAM ( or Amethyst Actor) if interested. thanks in advance!

[Lord Mhork]

Would anyone like to help review a Pan's Labyrinth mini theme?

Thank you much in advance!

[Ms Marangal]

I'm looking for one or two more experienced reviewers for Christianity Mafia, 21P themed and bastard.

it's pretty crazy, and even faraday is a little over-whelmed...

PM me, or TAM ( or Amethyst Actor) if interested. thanks in advance!

still looking for reviewers

I know there has to be someone out there that can take on this challenge

[Ms Marangal]

I'm looking for one or two more experienced reviewers for Christianity Mafia, 21P themed and bastard.

it's pretty crazy, and even faraday is a little over-whelmed...

PM me, or TAM ( or Amethyst Actor) if interested. thanks in advance!

still looking for reviewers

I know there has to be someone out there that can take on this challenge

Oh, I got quite a few

thanks to

Peng. Al, Oversoul, and Natirasha!

[GuyInFreezer]

I need one more reviewer for a 21p game based on Touhou series.
Ability to moderate large theme is required.

[Plum]

Looking for a reviewer or two for

The Fall of Gondolin Mafia

, a Large Theme for 17 players and follow-up to Lay of Leithian Mafia and The Children of Húrin Mafia. Theme knowledge won't hurt but isn't necessary.

Approved by Vi, but out of paranoia I'm looking for anyone who can help me as a second pair of eyes and/or a backup Mod (Vi called it 'so fabulous', if that sweetens the deal).

EDIT: Many thanks to Faraday, I'm covered now!

[ArcAngel9]

Hello, I need a reviewer for my next theme game..
If anyone can review my game.. please let me know. Thank you in advance.

[ArcAngel9]

Hello, I need a reviewer for my next theme game..
If anyone can review my game.. please let me know. Thank you in advance.

btw.. the game name is

"Duck Tales Maifa: Treasure of the Golden Suns"

[The Baltimore Sun]

Hello. I need a reviewer for The Wire, Season 2.

Familiar with the theme may be helpful since there are a few things I'd like to trash out, but it's probably not required. (Although one reviewer of each kind might be better)

[Elyse]

Would like a few reviewers for a Large Theme Game based on Seasons 1-3 of LOST, the tv show. 25 players as of now. Knowledge of the source material would be helpful.

[Elyse]

Faraday has been EXTREMELY helpful. Would still like an extra pair of eyes to glance stuff over. Thanks.

[Kluckmuck]

I'm moderating a game on another site, and I could really use some help moderating. The game got a lot bigger then I expected, and I want to make sure it is balanced. Bioshock theme as well!

[Bulbazak]

How far ahead can we get games reviewed? Can I create the setups for several theme games that I plan on running in the future, have them reviewed, and then have them ready for when the current theme game I'm running is over so I can jump in the queue again as soon as possible? I have several ideas already formed in my mind, and I just wanted to know if I had to wait, or if I could get them reviewed as soon as they were solidified, even though it might be awhile before I could even get them in signups.

[callforjudgement]

The reviews in this thread are all on a voluntary basis. So feel free to say "I probably won't run it for a while, but I'd like someone to review this game I'm thinking about", and see if anyone's interested.

[Malakittens]

Just need one/two reviwers for two games I have been thinking of.

One is based off Charmed {s1} (TV SHOW)

Second one is just funny flavor based off my cats.

Want them to be balanced.

<33

(I do need to get my ass in gear and get my large OUAT thing up in running. hopefully downtime this week I can work with Faraday in regards tooo it <3)

[pitoli]

Requesting a couple of reviewers for a 17-P Large Theme based on

Attack on Titan/Shingeki no Kyojin

Changed it to a 13-P Mini and need help on balance! Flavor knowledge not required but can be helpful