NY 169: The EPIC XD Mafia Game of Greatness (Game Over)

[geists]

How long do you usually take to read me?

Who is this?

If Nero's doing his usual things I can read him pretty quickly. I've never played with scum-Nero, though, so when I feel like his game doesn't seem quite the usual, I default to null or null/scum until the read finally firms up. It will be interesting to finally play a game where he's scum one of these days.

If GiF is doing his usual things I also get a read on him pretty quickly, but I footnote the hell out of it because I have a bad habit of townreading him when he's scum.

Btw f16, this post has given me a pause on my geists read. I don't like this post at all.

You should probably take an "Intro to Ffery-posting" class". There are a few professors in this game.

[MC Maraca]

Gen

are you here?

I am going to bed soon, and I would love to have a little convo

[MC Maraca]

Did it work?

(I imagine not, as I feel distinctly unsorted)

P-edit: Let's see. At first I was disliking KoreanBBQ, but they picked up a little. I'm not giving GM a pass like certain people, she could be. I dislike pitoli and Tammy so far, but someone brought up that this is normal for the former and I have more confidence in my ability to read the latter if I let her be her for a while. Stuffed Crust sucks so far, but low sample size.

I'm decidedly un-concrete on everything at present, though.

it worked, fine.

[MC Maraca]

If you didn't do what I think you did I'm going to be incredibly disappointed :/

Guess that depends on what you were thinking?

I got something that indicates that your name might as well be green in the OP.

Well I'm town so that counts!

[KoreanBBQ]

Wait varsoon's in this game?

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

The Tammy read relates to a reaction test I gave and her genuine frustration over it rather than to try and go with the flow gave me the initial town read I have.
Heists is a gut read based on a smart opening which when lightly challenged he has been calm and consistent on tone. And there are glimpses of behind the scenes work being done for the game. Intriguing slot, so I townread them.

I am feeling pretty good about Cabd being town, and to a lesser extent Geists, Tammy, and Cephrir. Fair warning, I am going to gatecrash all the in-thread Mason parties and Tammy is going to be my best buddy that I bring along.

Why are you feeling good about these three f16?

All of them are mostly based on gut.

MC Maraca

: Cabd's posts just felt like town. Marangal's latest posts are helping to firm up my read more.

Geists

: I liked Nat's reaction to Cephrir's townread on him. I also thought that ffery waffling on her read on me was townish, and I like that we are on the same page regarding Cabd.

Cephrir

: I felt in sync with Cephrir for the most part. His initial scumread on Brian followed shortly with a realization that this was dissimilar to his scumgame in Cash Cabd seemed genuine.

Tammy

: Tammy's posts felt natural and unforced. Her demeanor reminded me of Mini 1472 but not to the same extent. I will probably go more in-depth once we generate more information in this game.

What didn't you like about Geists's 219?

[KoreanBBQ]

I thought cephrir was town in cash cabd

[MC Maraca]

GIF

why do you always do this to me

[KoreanBBQ]

WHAT DID I DO LAST TIME AND WHAT DID I DO THIS TIME D:

[KoreanBBQ]

So my brain feels like its half broken so
How many posts of SC was Varsoon?
If there was more than one of his posts, im voting him.

[Generic]

The Tammy read relates to a reaction test I gave and her genuine frustration over it rather than to try and go with the flow gave me the initial town read I have.
Heists is a gut read based on a smart opening which when lightly challenged he has been calm and consistent on tone. And there are glimpses of behind the scenes work being done for the game. Intriguing slot, so I townread them.

I am feeling pretty good about Cabd being town, and to a lesser extent Geists, Tammy, and Cephrir. Fair warning, I am going to gatecrash all the in-thread Mason parties and Tammy is going to be my best buddy that I bring along.

Why are you feeling good about these three f16?

All of them are mostly based on gut.

MC Maraca

: Cabd's posts just felt like town. Marangal's latest posts are helping to firm up my read more.

Geists

: I liked Nat's reaction to Cephrir's townread on him. I also thought that ffery waffling on her read on me was townish, and I like that we are on the same page regarding Cabd.

Cephrir

: I felt in sync with Cephrir for the most part. His initial scumread on Brian followed shortly with a realization that this was dissimilar to his scumgame in Cash Cabd seemed genuine.

Tammy

: Tammy's posts felt natural and unforced. Her demeanor reminded me of Mini 1472 but not to the same extent. I will probably go more in-depth once we generate more information in this game.

What didn't you like about Geists's 219?

Glad you asked, and for a reason I will not go into right now you are also now in my town block.

What i dislike about that post is that he completely negates BOTH reads on the two heads.
Starts with a comment that he can read nero quickly - then negates that with a comment that he has never seen nero as scum, then that he sits him in the null waiting room until he gets a proper read on him. So neither a quick read then nor a read that can be held up to great scrutiny since he has never seen neros scum game.
Then moves on to GIF who again he apparently reads quickly - then COMPLETELY negates that by pointing out he often townreads him when he is scum.

That post is literally nothing. You cant make a claim to be able to read two people and then immediately caveat that with a list of contradictions.

And the follow up to my comment about not liking it is horrible, basically boils down to 'im playing to my town meta, ask those currently townreading me'.

Geists has gone from a decent town read to my opening suspicion. And all through a few questions being posed to them and a bit of scrutiny.


Mara, im here but im guessing you may not be. Don't panic, you and i will get to do our day 1 dance soon enough :p

[geists]

For the record, Generic, I think youre attributing my bravado to fferyllt's analysis. I've been pretty much AWOL at this point this game.

[KoreanBBQ]

vote tammy

Because she hates me.

but I hate you, why are you voting her over us?

I've only played with GIF, and I would hope he doesn't hate me after I dragged his sorry ass over the finish line when we were scum together and he got everyone to mislynch me in the next one.
So technically he should love me.

I enjoyed every second of that moment!

[Tammy]

VOTE: koreanbbq

[Generic]

In fact.

vote geists

That's how i feel about the follow up, i hate someone handwaving away a legitimate concern with meta arguments. And even worse since they never once asked why, yet assumed that pointing to their meta would cover what i had took issue with.

[Generic]

For the record, Generic, I think youre attributing my bravado to fferyllt's analysis. I've been pretty much AWOL at this point this game.

I don't get what you are talking about here.

I just broke down what i disliked about #219. feel free to respond to that.

[Generic]

vote tammy

Because she hates me.

but I hate you, why are you voting her over us?

I've only played with GIF, and I would hope he doesn't hate me after I dragged his sorry ass over the finish line when we were scum together and he got everyone to mislynch me in the next one.
So technically he should love me.

I enjoyed every second of that moment!

Which moment? the scum win or the mislynch? :p

[geists]

Yeah and I'm saying that I think you're appointing my(Natirasha) worldview to her(fferyllt) posting. We've not spoken at all about this game at this juncture.

[KoreanBBQ]

VOTE: koreanbbq

Ok fine I was being mean to generic a bit but that ain't the way to treat the tired

old

man.

P-Edit: mislynch, of course :p

[Generic]

Yeah and I'm saying that I think you're appointing my(Natirasha) worldview to her(fferyllt) posting. We've not spoken at all about this game at this juncture.

When did i separate you guys out again?

Your hydra posted a nothing post about the reading of the heads of koreanBBQ. That post was fluff. I expressed concerns on it and your hydra posted that i need an intro into ffery-posting...

You guys don't sign your posts so i take the comments as they are. One of you fluff posted a nothing comment on reading koreanBBQ then qualified my concerns with my lack of reading ffery posts without ever asking what i had issues with.

Why are you now defending the situation with 'you are confusing the heads'... when i haven't once separated you out.

[KoreanBBQ]

So my brain feels like its half broken so
How many posts of SC was Varsoon?
If there was more than one of his posts, im voting him.

Can someone pls answer this?
It's important.

[geists]

It seemed like you were mixing them up, mostly the pronoun usage. If you were addressing us by hydra then okay fine. You'll still have to wait for ffery to post cuz I haven't even began thinking about this game really.

[Generic]

OK, now i see what you mean, did i use 'he'?

If you want to differ the response to the head who put you in the shit in the first place that's fine, but my vote is standing so i would have a chat with your partner at some point before she makes matters worse for you both.

[Generic]

differ = defer

And English is my first language too

[geists]

Sure. You have anything you wanna chat to me regardless?