Ok. I re-read. and the most I got out of it are people I think are probably not scum than anything else (Which is still useful).
The following are players with how likely I think they are scum (my best guesses) with reasoning. i obviously did not include myself.
Fritzler: 60% - Hammered SJ (-10%), but didn't come in until the very end after SJ was pretty much doomed (Negated^). While killing a scumate early would be stupid, I could see scum trying to finish off a doomed scum member to look good. Plus killed SJ before a claim and discusion could be made (+10%) which is agreed as a bad move for town.
Chamber: 55% - A little too lurky for my liking (+5%). Obviously willing to give Ether a chance to change this.
Fuldu: 52% - Kind of late comer on SJ lynch. possible scum tactic?
JDodge: 50% - Acting suspicous in relation to SJ (+10%), but no real reason to beleive fairly solid claim of chickenboo (Negated^)
Blake Judge/Hurrikitty/Mole - 50% Can't really get a read on these either way.
Thesp: 35% - Pushed on Mole for little good strategy in my opinion (+5%). Early on SJ lynch (-20%)
VitamanR: 35% - Making a few statements that I thought were a little scummy (+5%), but at the same time early on the SJ lynch. (+20%)
Based on this I'm going with a
Unvote Vote: Fritzler
. Not a sure-fire vote mind you, but hopefully this will get more conversation going.
Winner of the "if real life was like mafia" thread. :D
**May be going on permanent Limited Access as soon as April 1st. :(**