Mini 396: ChatMafia Mafia; GAME OVER

[Zindaras]

My paramaters have verily been put forth in Post 423:

Okay, let's take a look at this stuff. Now, I decided to take a long hard look at Twito. What I noticed is that he didn't start off voting Masterchief, who I've noticed to be his usual random vote. I also noticed that he completely avoided weighing in on the Angus issue. I don't really like his first milkman FoS in 166 either. I keep noticing some scumbuddy vibes between Jack and Twito. 207 is a good example of this, and I believe Jack was really eager to vote StallingChamp when he voted Twito earlier as well. He starts to look better later on, when he appears to put time in the game. Something that I noticed was Jack's MC vote in 330. I think the town thing to do after the absence of a painting was to FoS Angus. Jack's and Twito's votes, therefore, look bad to me. Y's vote doesn't make me happy either.

CDB's looking pretty townish. Dragy gave off town vibes in his early discussion with Angus, but 70 made me feel bad about him, and he left his vote on me for a loooong time, which I still find odd. Jack and Katy still look bad to me over the Angus-wagon. For some reason, I feel that StallingChamp is town, though I find the absence of any 11th Houring somewhat disturbing. Y's vote in 283 sets off minor pings. Katy looked real bad but the way she's been posting lately has me thinking she's town.

Summary of opinions:

Towny: Katy, CDB.
Scummy: Y, Twito, Jack.

Coron needs to post a lot more. Something akin to actual thoughts. AniX needs to get off his lazy ass and make us all blanch in fear of Scully and The 11th Hour. I'd like some more detailed stuff from dragyn and milkman.

Vote: Jack

Katy and CDB aren't as towny as they used to be, Jack is now solidly in the towny category, but my two suspicions remain, so to speak.

Qua prodding, far be it from me,

Mod

, could you, as it were, in terms of prodding, send prods to Anix, Coron, dragyn and the other inactives.

[Twito]

This game is so slow I could prolly keep up with it from internet cafes but it's still easier not to.

[al_kohaulec]

Coron is busy until Sunday, I'm trying to get a replacement for AniX.

[HurriKaty]

Let me put it this way, the reason I may not be as townie as I use to be, in terms of the quantity and quality of my posts, is concordantly related to the posting requirement put in place. Far be it from me to make excuses, but its making it really hard to read posts and make posts, and so to speak, I've also been busy as I just moved 1000 miles away from home and haven't had time to post as much as I use to... per se.

[Y]

I believe the restriction is killing the game. People are trying to avoid posting, since it's so unnatural and annoying. I know that's what I'm doing.

Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly

[al_kohaulec]

Although it's a part of the game, I understand that this restriction is ruining the game. To clarify, merely listing and/or quoting with those words used

is

acceptable as it meets the general requirement of each post

containing

those words.

Along with that bit of info., I will prod every player still alive and post up a tenative deadline for

Wednesday March 21 at 10 PM PST

. This will be revoked if enough activity comes back and an extension is requested.

[Jack]

Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly

I have to wonder what the point of having a doctor is if there aren't any night kills.

[Y]

The question is: "Does the lack of a NK has something to do with the doc?". It is very improbable that a player guessed right two nights in a row, but it isn't impossible, and he might have stopped one of them, while some one else stopped the other or no kill was made due to inactivity.

ergo
Q.E.D.
e.g.
i.e.
You're begging the question

[Zindaras]

Let me put it this way, so to speak, in terms of lynching, I believe that we should, as it were, get rid of Twito.

Concordantly,

Vote: Twito

.

See? It's not that difficult to get five of those lines in a post.

I already outlined why I feel Twito is suspicious yesterday. He's been wagoning town all game. He could be the guy who missed the kill, and so on and so on.

[Y]

milkman bothers me a bit more than Twito. The "I didn't skip any night choice, but I had the chance to make a rule and didn't do it" seems fishy to me.

Vote milkman.

Vis-à-vis
Per se
As it were
Verily
Qua

[milkman]

milkman bothers me a bit more than Twito. The "

I didn't skip any night choice

, but I had the chance to make a rule and didn't do it" seems fishy to me.

Vote milkman.

Vis-à-vis
Per se
As it were
Verily
Qua

Except I didn't say that.

Let me put it this way, milkman, as it were, didn't send in

all his choices

Night 1. Verily, I don't know for sure what we should tie to this in terms of or qua conclusions, but it may mean something, so to speak.

I'm not really sure why you'd post that, and what does all his choices mean? Is that the way it was formated?

It looks like I misstepped and claimed a power role, and you're fishing again.

Vote: Y

.

ps:
Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly

[Y]

I'm not really sure why you'd post that, and what does all his choices mean? Is that the way it was formated?

It means that you had choices or roles and you didn't send them in and I know about it.

speaking of laws, n1 I was given a chance to write a law, but I didn't send it in. I did think of some annoying things though.

Apparently I'm not the only one to see you doing so. Now you're trying to get things out of context.

Where was I fishing for info? The only thing I did was to insinuate you're a liar. You're just straw-manning.

[Y]

You're begging the question.
You're being defensive.
Don't compare apples to oranges.
What are your parameters?
You're so linear

[Twito]

Let me put it this way.. nah don't let me.

[al_kohaulec]

Twito has been placed under arrest.

[al_kohaulec]

al_kohaulec:

Here comes a

Vote Count:

milkman

- 2 - ChannelDelibird, Y

Twito

- 1 - Zindaras

Y

- 1 - milkman

Those who have forgotten they're in the chat room

- 5 - AniX, draygn_mage, HurriKaty, Jack, Coron

Under Arrest

- 1 - Twito

10 alive, 6 to lynch

Each post must contain at least 5 of the following:

Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly
Vis-à-vis
Per se
As it were
Verily
Qua
So to speak
ergo
Q.E.D.
e.g.
i.e.
You're begging the question.
You're being defensive.
Don't compare apples to oranges.
What are your parameters?
You're so linear

Tenative deadline for

Wednesday March 21 at 10 PM PST

. This will be revoked if enough activity comes back

and

an extension is requested.

[al_kohaulec]

HackerHuck replaces draygn_mage.

Thank you HackerHuck.

[HackerHuck]

Welcome, I'll get readthrough done in the next 24 hours. I really can't believe that I'm required to say five items from this list!

Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly
Vis-à-vis
Per se
As it were
Verily
Qua
So to speak
ergo
Q.E.D.
e.g.
i.e.
You're begging the question.
You're being defensive.
Don't compare apples to oranges.
What are your parameters?
You're so linear

Fortunately I guess I can just use the list itself.

[Zindaras]

Let me put it this way, in terms of scumgroup, I believe that, as it were, so to speak, Y and Twito is verily the one we are looking for.

[HurriKaty]

Let me put it this way.. nah don't let me.

Twito, why did you just intentionally arrest yourself?

Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly

[ChannelDelibird]

This list of required phrases is really getting on my nerves, hence the reduction in posting.

unvote milkman

, seems like a fair reason for not using all night choices.

I'm going to

vote: AniX

. I didn't like StallingChamp's behaviour on D1 and exactly nothing has been done by AniX to allay my fears.

Y is probably my second bet. Twito just looks like he's as pissed off with the restriction as I am.

Let me put it this way
Be that as it may
Far be it from me
In terms of
Concordantly
Vis-à-vis
Per se
As it were
Verily
Qua
So to speak
ergo
Q.E.D.
e.g.
i.e.
You're begging the question.
You're being defensive.
Don't compare apples to oranges.
What are your parameters?
You're so linear

[Y]

unvote milkman

, seems like a fair reason for not using all night choices.

You're begging the question.
You're being defensive.
Don't compare apples to oranges.
What are your parameters?
You're so linear

Could you rephrase his reason, please? I can't recall reading any.

[ChannelDelibird]

In addition to his role he was given the chance to make a law on the night in question, but declined.

As it were
Verily
Qua
So to speak
ergo

[Y]

In addition to his role he was given the chance to make a law on the night in question, but declined.

As it were
Verily
Qua
So to speak
ergo

But it doesn't change the fact that he first said he didn't skip any night choice and later said he did, two posts apart.

[HackerHuck]

Let me put it this way. It's really late for me and I was hoping to have this reread done sooner. In terms of sleep, I'm lacking, ergo I won't be putting forth a great post. Be that as it may, I do need to contribute -i.e. post my suspicions - with the deadline approaching.

Just prior to the last few posts regarding Milkman's night choice, he was my top suspect.

Vote: Milkman

Since it's late, I haven't thought through all of the implications of his night actions, but he seems pretty scummy to me.

Milkman's attack on Angus did seem reasonable at first glance, but the bad vote count and his bulldogging of it seemed a bit over the top. I also got a very weird feeling about his defence of Angus on day 2. It seemed like scum trying to win points by defending an easy townie lynch.

Stalling/AniX is definitely a close second on this one. I wouldn't be opposed to moving my vote that way. Way too defensive of his early lurking and then more lurking following by Jack's (I believe) callout on him for the definitely scum vote on Twito.

I'm going to hit the high points of everything else and then hopefully get a full reread in before deadline.

Zindaras seems really argumentative. Some of his points have been a little weak, but he's really pushed hard on most of his points. The irregular debate with Jack and the Katy posting issue are prime examples. I also was concerned by his defensiveness regarding the Dragynmage vote.

Jack seemed pretty scummy up until his claim, but I agree that it's likely he was just on the wrong side of his arguments, not the scummy side.

I'd like to put down more, but my eyes are weak and I want to get some more substance down on the remaining people.

FWIW Zindy, I don't think Twito's the play today. Care to give us something more concrete?