Mini 405 - GAME OVER on a Loveboat - THE SHIP GOES DOWN!

[LyingBrian]

based on the actions you did

before

after you decided you wanted to

quit/play again

request replacement.

fixed... that puts it in the proper time period... i decided to "quit" when my computer stopped working, then decided to come back since Sailor Jerry couldn't find a replacement... i've already explained those actions, time & time again... i was frustrated w/ everything but the game, then i took it out on the game...

I don't see why you are asking me to compose my posts. I tend to get letters rearranged, however, I say what I mean - and if what I say causes misunderstanding, I correct myself and take responsibility for what I've done.

i asked that of you b/c your Post #345 confused the hell out of me... if you truly do correct yourself, please address the question i asked you in Post #346 that you didn't answer... voting me doesn't make Post #345 any less scummalicious, it just proves you're reacting to me which isn't a good townie trait...

So I hereby un-proxy my vote, and keep my vote on LB. I just don't like his play.

[sarcasm]what a great analysis[/sarcasm]
would you mind giving me specifics, The Central Scrutinizer?..

and i also request somebody to unvote me as opportunistic scum could very easily jump in right now (not w/o just cause, but still) to lynch me... in fact, if i am lynched, tomorrow, town, you may want to pressure Skruffs & whoever hammers me...

[LyingBrian]

based on the actions you did

before

after you decided you wanted to

quit/play again

request replacement.

fixed... that puts it in the proper time period... i decided to "quit" when my computer stopped working, then decided to come back since Sailor Jerry couldn't find a replacement... i've already explained those actions, time & time again... i was frustrated w/ everything but the game, then i took it out on the game...

I don't see why you are asking me to compose my posts. I tend to get letters rearranged, however, I say what I mean - and if what I say causes misunderstanding, I correct myself and take responsibility for what I've done.

i asked that of you b/c your Post #345 confused the hell out of me... if you truly do correct yourself, please address the question i asked you in Post #346 that you didn't answer... voting me doesn't make Post #345 any less scummalicious, it just proves you're reacting to me which isn't a good townie trait...

So I hereby un-proxy my vote, and keep my vote on LB. I just don't like his play.

[sarcasm]what a great analysis[/sarcasm]
would you mind giving me specifics, The Central Scrutinizer?..

and i also request somebody to unvote me as opportunistic scum could very easily jump in right now (not w/o just cause, but still) to lynch me... in fact, if i am lynched, tomorrow, town, you may want to pressure Skruffs & whoever hammers me...

[kilmenator]

ummm... i guess vote

no lynch

cause we are at deadline...

[LyingBrian]

mod, can you please move the deadline again, or remove it?...

[Skruffs]

For the record - no oppurtunistic jumped on because we are pegging scum right now.

[Sailor Jerry]

Retracting deadline.

I would far rather you built a lynch on your own, and while conversation is ongoing, I'd far rather have you do the work than have a deadline no-lynch.

[LyingBrian]

For the record - no oppurtunistic jumped on because we are pegging scum right now.

or the scum are already on my bandwagon... now i want you to think about something... i realize this is WIFOM, but why would scum ask for the deadline to be retracted?.. i could have easily not said anything and lived to see another day (possibly, depending on the mod) i realize that i could've done it to make myself look more townish, but the risk vs. reward is too great for scum to attempt it IMO... yes, as i said it is WIFOM, but just think about it for awhile... i would still like somebody to unvote... if you guys decide to definitively lynch me, ok, but i'd rather not risk a quicklynch b/c somebody wanted to be stubborn...

[Skruffs]

See? Even Sailor Jerry thinks that lynching Lying Brian is better than a nolynch.

kilmenator - town has no ability to prevent a death. Do you really think letting scum kill off more townies is better than potentially killing one of them?

At this point I am fairly confident that LyingBrian is scum. I have no way to really prove it except with a noose. He's very persuasive and I have been tempted to unvote him several times, but this time I think I would rather stand behind my convictions, becuase I think they are good convictions.

So come on. Do it for akbar.

[LyingBrian]

@Skruffs

so you're willing to risk lynching a pro-town role, just b/c you're stubborn enough to hold onto whatever from a low point in my game rather than listening to the points i'm brining up?...that sounds scummish to me... you may be convinced that i'm scum, but if that's the case it's only b/c you're trying so hard to make yourself look townish... if i go down today, i would definitely advocate your going down tomorrow, regardless of what role you "claim"... you are scum, you know it & i know it, i just hope i'm persuasive enough to get you lynched tomorrow if i get lynched today...

[ac1983fan]

unvote

for now... there's not enough info for me to make a good vote now. so, I'll reread saturday.

[Skruffs]

The reason I am voting you is because of my LB/Fircoal scum theory. You made a distraction to avoid that and then used the distraction as your defense. Nobody else is really saying anything to counter it, though. Until a more definite or plausible scum is revealed, I am going to keep my vote on you. This boat is three quarters sunk already, it feels like. If you are scum, we might be able to unsink it.

Saying you are pro-town isn't helping town out at all right now. There's no way to protect you at night.

[Y.C]

the fact that LB is trying to convinvce us that Skruffs is scum makes him look much scummier to me.
He hasn't voted for him to avoid casting suspicion on himself, but tries to get us to do his dirty job for him.

LB, please vote for him or raise more valid points regarding Skruffs' scumminess than "i know it", as the current situation does not put you in a favourable position.

[kilmenator]

See? Even Sailor Jerry thinks that lynching Lying Brian is better than a nolynch.
kilmenator - town has no ability to prevent a death. Do you really think letting scum kill off more townies is better than potentially killing one of them?(

see, I do not necessarily agree with the whole bit of a no lynch being a bad play, although, I am not sure it is a good play in this situation, the argument against a no lynch is that you gain more information by a lynch than a no lynch and getting rid of a pro-town player is worth that, but I do not necessarily agree with that theory.

I also forgot that our doc died in this game. (I think it was this game... right?) So a no lynch may not be a good idea, but if we were coming up on deadline, then it seemed the most feasible to me, especially since deadline really did not spark much discussion. But, being that as it is, I think I will

vote:lyingbrian

because now that I think about it, he is rather scummy. I dont like the disinterest in the game and then suddenly he is extremely interested. I dont know, that just doesnt sit well and the fact that scum hasnt hammered, well, that does make me wonder... I dont know, anyway, where does that put him? Four, I think.Yup, four, with the unvote of AC1983

[ac1983fan]

... it would still be four even if i hadn't unvoted, i was voting no lynch.

[LyingBrian]

i wasn't lying... i really am just a vanilla townie... guess that blows Skruffs LyingBrian/Fircoal scum team out of the water... oh well, hopefully the town still has a fighting chance...

[LyingBrian]

as you wish, Y.C, although it doesn't make a difference now...

vote: Skruffs

[Sailor Jerry]

LyingBrian (5) - the Central Scrutinizer, Y.C., wicked, Skruffs, kilmenator
The Central Scrutinizer (1) - Fircoal
Skruffs (1) - Lowell

Not voting (2): LyingBrian, ac1983fan

A mob is formed. "LyingBrian!" "LyingBrian!" "Lying!" "Brian!"

"WALK THE PLANK!"

"What is this, a pirate ship?"

"Yarrrrrrr!!!!"

Well... no it isn't a pirate ship. It's a loveboat. However, there appears to be no love for Brian on this little dinghy boat anywhere. But have the mob found their man?






Nooooooooo.

LyingBrian was a townie. It is Night 2! Get me some night choices!

[Sailor Jerry]

Nobody slept last night. Everyone stayed in their cabins and locked the doors.

Some sat watching their doors, armed with makeshift weapons... just in case...

Others invited other trustworthy passengers to stay with them... "for protection"...

Strange noises were coming from many cabins - but none so sinister as the sounds from Lowell's cabin... the sound of gunfire!

Lowell, TOWNIE, has been shot.

It is Day THREE! Get to it, town!

[Sailor Jerry]

For the record, I know that the first post hasn't been updated.

There's some issue with my mod rights at the moment... Hopefully whoever screwed it up is going to get unscrewing it!

[Skruffs]

Guys, *please* do not vote without reason - I don't know if we are at LYLO or not.
IN C ASE WE ARE... let's talk first.. vote later. Please.

[ac1983fan]

Well, let's see... 12-5=7, assuming 3 scum, that's 4 town, and also assuming there's no big, we are in lylo.

[Skruffs]

Kilmenator, Wicked, Fircoal, The Central Scrutinizer, what do you all think of each other?

[Fircoal]

Ok here my opinions on those 4


2. kilmenator - Looks Pro-town but should post a bit more often. Her long posts makes sense, but sometimes, I think she follows Skruffs to much.
5. wicked - Her posts are a bit scummy, she also needs to post more.
8. The Central Srutinizer - How TCS acts isn't that scummy, but DAS acted really scummy. But sadly, TCS can't provide the thoughts of DAS
10. fircoal - Definitely Pro-town

[The Central Scrutinizer]

I think Kilmenator and Wicked are scum... but that's a gut feeling. Once I have the time to reread this I will post something more coherent, but I doubt much is to be gained here... this game is confusing.

[wicked]

Hey guys! I didn't realize it had started back up b/c I just glanced at the title. I know I haven't posted a lot, but I'm been extremely busy in real life. Now with the weekend here, I'll get back into the game and post my theories.