Newbie 320 - Berry Village Mafia V (Game Over!)

[Blackberry]

Azibo Village Vote Count

[/color]

Cogito Ergo Sum

## 2 [Nocmen, now a ranger]

remussaidow

# 1 [GreenLiquid]

Not Voting: Eldarion, Peter Venkman, remussaidow, Cogito Ergo Sum

Four Votes to Lynch.

[remussaidow]

Ranger, swearing on your mother's grave won't get you anywhere in this game. (1) we don't even know if your mother has a grave (not meant to give offense, I swear)

(2) if she does have a grave, you're either going to {a}get yourself lynched everytime you don't swear on her grave, or {b} damn your mothers grave quite often. Not sure how that will look, but then that's an outside of game factor and one thats really none of my business.

[Peter Venkman]

...and if your mother rises from the grave, who you gonna call?

[remussaidow]

ghost busters?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

And claiming so early is a detriment to the town. It certainly wasn't required.

[Peter Venkman]

I agree with CES. At this point in the game, we all presume each other claim town. Stating that is meaningless and suspicous.

I still retain my FoS on

CES

,

Remu

, and i'll add

Now a Ranger

.

-Peter

[Nocmen]

Someone here likes to swear. To be honest, I really think you are doing a bad job at being a scum cover up. But voting for the person who is most likely to be your buddy, that is what I dont fully understand.

My vote stand on CES, but

Major Fos: now a ranger

[now a ranger]

You think I'm doing a bad job of scum cover up; IT'S BECAUSE I AM NOT A SCUM. =)

[remussaidow]

it wouldn't be covering up. Who do you think is scum?

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Psst, romulus, why don't you vote for Eldarion? It'll be fun.

[remussaidow]

why don't you?
negligible pink of suspicion: CES for getting my name wrong (NOTE: THIS IS A JOKE)

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

I don't see how that question's relevant. Certainly your vote does not depend on mine, Romulus?

[remussaidow]

no, but then, my vote isn't dependent on what's fun either.

[GreenLiquid]

IT'S BECAUSE I AM NOT A SCUM. =)

"I'm Not Scum, <smileyface>" is not a defense

In Mafia, it is important that players logically defend their actions, by either indicating their intent in performing them or the pro-townness of them. One must explain their actions, and if they do not, they will likely be lynched.

Although I don't usually factor in the type of metagaming you employed, I am not likely to vote due to the extremeness of your instance, but still,

IGMEOY

.

Right now, I'd like pressure on CES and remussaidow. As now a ranger has already claimed, I don't see what more we'll get out of pressuring him.

[Eldarion]

Psst, romulus, why don't you vote for Eldarion? It'll be fun.

Well, of course Remus said Ow... His brother killed him.

You

could

of course vote for me and I guess it'll be fun for

some

of the people involved...

A townie claim on D1, this is unfortunate.

[Eldarion]

Ah I forgot to add, in support of GL's post, that Townies defending their actions is

vital

to having a good chance of winning. If everyone plays perfectly, it will be the scum who show up.

[Eldarion]

EDIT - '... that townies

defend logically

...'

I suck at grammar, and life.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Grammar, yes, life, only a little.

[Peter Venkman]

Hi everyone, I'm back to regular computer usage!

Suprisingly, not a whole lot has happened over the past four days.

Now a Ranger

emerged as our final player and promptly claimed town.

CES

appears to be back doing his "let

me

tell you who to vote for" that irritated me so much in the begining.

Greenliquid

indicates he wants to put pressure on CES and Remu yet doesn't switch his vote (remember, Remu didn't get lynched allready when he was at -1 to lynch).

Eldarion

triple posts his philosophy on finding scum.

Nocment

FoS's Now a Ranger but doesn't add much more.

Remussaidow

fingers CES.

I am curious why

Remus

and

Greenliquid

don't just cast their votes on CES. Are you trying to distance yourselves from a mislynch only you two know about?

I am also curious why

Cogito Ergo Sum

isn't casting a vote on anyone, yet is pressuring others to do so. CES claimed he likes to use the power of his vote to the fullest, yet suspiciously isn't.

Finially, i'm disapointed in

Now a Ranger

. A person joining a game this late has a unique opportunity to asses each player objectively and give a summary. He completely blew that chance with some really crappy play.

I'll be checking this thread more often now, so please respond to my commentary. Did I miss anything? Am I completely off base with my summary?

-Peter

[remussaidow]

Peter, read my entire post. It's the negligible pinky of suspicious, it doesn't count.

[now a ranger]

I'm mafia.

[remussaidow]

*sigh*

That's not really the point of the game, you know.

[remussaidow]

and its also a bad play, no matter who you are. See, if you claim scum, you either screw up the town (if you are actually town) because then they lynch you and it was a townie lynch. If messes up the scum (if you are scum) because you just stranded your partner and the only reason to strand your partner is if you're trying to lose.
and its not even like you could be a jester.

[Peter Venkman]

Now a Ranger

>

My last statement about you was a little harsh. I am sorry. I have seen mafia games get heated, but calling another person's play "crappy" is completely uncalled for. I sincerely feel bad, and understand my mistake.

In addition, it was wrong of me to ask you to do anything. Your play is your own, and while I think it would have benefitted the town to hear a new perspective, I should not be telling other players what to do.

Finially, I feel bad that my statement appears to have pushed you to throw your hands in the air and say the mafia equivalent of "I quit!"

Remember,

everyone

on the town side wins when both mafia are caught. During normal play, it is almost a guarantee that a mislynch will occur. Part of playing this game as town is making sure that your team will benefit from your possible death. Your team-mates will re-read your previous posts and observe your voting pattern, knowing you are confirmed with a role.

Again, I am sorry for my harsh language.

-Peter

[Peter Venkman]

Peter, read my entire post. It's the negligible pinky of suspicious, it doesn't count.

Oh. Um.

It appears I'm not exactly batting 100% tonight. Can you understand that I might confuse a negligible pinky with a finger??

-Peter