Kingmaker II-Game Over

[mnowax]

im still working on it! and i replaced how long ago?

[Smashy]

So basically, it's either SV or LL. I'll let you argue for a bit more before I smash someone.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

LL is easier to read(both me and IH correctly pegged him as the GF in Fairytale mini). Go for SV.

[Glork]

It should be MoS. I'd go with LL over SV, but meh. Whatevs.

[Toaster Strudel]

Pick one! Anyone! Gah!

[Shanba]

If any of you people saying "keel! keel!" turn around and say that Smashy made the wrong choice, it will not be happy making.

[Der Hammer]

Out of the two (LL and SV) I know think LL is the better choice based on LL's recent posts.

[Yosarian2]

If that's the choice, then yeah, I think LL would be a better choice then SV. SV really hasn't looked especally scummy to me, while LL's "lynch Yos over pooky" choice does seem like a possible scum tell, and the general "follow certain people" attitude seems a bit scummy as well.

[petroleumjelly]

Mmf.

I would personally like to keep LL around for at least another day; once he adjusts his playstyle (presumably to using his 'townie tells' for how he votes instead of "X thinks Y is scum, so I'll vote Y") I think we will be better able to read him. I think SV is the preferable execution here.

[Mastermind of Sin]

No one will tell me why SV is scum...

[Thok]

Deadline March 12. To make the time official 8:00 PM Pacific Standard Time (GMT-8). In case of no execution Smashy dies of incompetence.

Let me know of any prods that are desired/needed.

VOTE COUNT

*King Smashy*
Sort of kind of LOE (LuckayLuck, Spectrumvoid)

Cogito Ergo Sum (2): Mnowax
Der Hammer (3): LuckayLuck
DragonsofSummer (4): Mnowax, MOS, LuckayLuck
Fritzler (1): Toaster Streudel
Glork (1): MOS, Fritzler, Der Hammer, LuckayLuck
KaleiÐoscøpe (0): pablito
Lowell (0): spectrumvoid, Mnowax
LuckayLuck (5): spectrumvoid, Der Hammer
Mastermind of Sin (6):
Mnowax (3): MOS
pablito (2): olio, petroleumjelly, RafK, MOS
petroleumjelly (1): Spectrumvoid, DragonsofSummer, Der Hammer
RafK (2): spectrumvoid, Yosarian2, Cogito Ergo Sum
Shanba (0): MOS, SpectrumVoid, RafK
spectrumvoid (5): Glork
ThAdmiral (1): pablito, LuckayLuck, Toaster Streudel, Yosarian2
Toaster Streudel (2): DragonsofSummer, LuckayLuck
Yosarian2 (3): DragonsofSummer, Cogito Ergo Sum, MOS
Zindaras (0): Yosarian2, DragonsofSummer

Please let me know if this needs corrections.

[pablito]

I'm not a bit fan of executing either SV or LL.

I found that both looked townie after some moves. SV progressed from one top 3 to a completely different one - that shows that SV was able to critically look at some arguments/evidence and develop new cases or figure out why her previous cases were not well-developed. LL just reeks townie, it's just that he has previously defended/proxied at inopportune times. LL came into the game with a bang and a very strong profile, and thus, I agree, it makes LL much easier to read. Furthermore, LL is very willing to take some extreme or unfavorable points. SV does as well, but she hasn't it done it too much lately.

If, a gun is pointed at my head and I would be executed if I didn't give a choice, then and only then would I advocate for an SV execution because her logic hasn't been the most concrete over time and some of her old suspicious still remain wonky. It seems that LL is a fairly polarizing character though.

@PJ - are you advocating more for "keep LL" than "execute SV"?

@CES - Same question.

[pablito]

Oh, in case anyone asks, I'd rather DragonsOfSummer or ThAdmiral be executed. Both replaced somewhat scummy characters and it could help us to just save them the trouble of having to re-read.

[petroleumjelly]

What? I want SV executed today. I thought my posts kinda made that point already.

MoS, considering you're always asking for us to read

your

posts intead of just looking at who people vote for, I would suggest you look at who is voting for SV, and

then

look back at their posts for seeing why they are voting SV.

[Yosarian2]

Yeah, I'd be in favor of a DragonofSummer execution.

[pablito]

K, I read your posts PJ, it was a way far back when you last mentioned SV in detail. But it exists. In fact, it makes me feel better that your notes/memory are that good. I'll

unvote: PJ

.

But CES should answer the question I posed as well.

But really, DoS is a safe execution that should be re-looked. If not today, at least tomorrow.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Essentially yes, pablito.

[Yosarian2]

Note: you've only got about a day left before deadline, smashy. Better kill someone.

[Smashy]

Yeah, and I've came to my decision.

Smash: LuckayLuck

No more posting after this.

[Thok]

LuckayLuck has been smashed. He was a

townie

. With that, King Smashy steps down from the throne.

It is now night. Kingmaker, Assassins, send in your choices in to me (not BMQ) quickly.

[Thok]

This morning you find Glork's body in the center square, covered with a fine sticky goo, and a note saying "How do you like being Glorked?" Obviously, this means he was a

townie

.

Also,

Yosarian2

takes the throne! All hail King Yosarian2!

[Glork]

This is impossible. I am the only person in the world capable of glorking. I will assume that the goo was misidentified as glorking goo and that I was poisoned with some other substance.


At any rate, bah. Go town!

Mod Note: There are currently two competing theories on how the Assassins were able to Glork Glork. One is that they carefully analyzed the dead body of Pooky, and were able to use their scientific know-how to synthesize synthetic imitation Glork.

Alternatively, they may have just bought some Glork-in-a-can.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

All hail our glorious ruler! And let his magnificent light illuminate the darkest desires!

[petroleumjelly]

Hrmf.

Well, I'll update my notes and reread the game as soon as possible.

Note: But this will (in all reality) probably have to wait until next week. I will be focusing my attention on a different forum game for today in particular, tomorrow is a day out with friends, Thursday I will be finishing an essay, and Friday through Monday will be at Mock Trial. After that, I will hopefully have time to get reacquainted with this game and the new information.

I'll figure out where my votes will go after the reread. If Yos2 would like to give my any fairly short "assignments" though, I could probably do that.

[Toaster Strudel]

Praise be to His Royal Highest Yosarian II.